|
FURY OF FLAME p. 73
Ranged Iterative Attacks: No Quick Draw, so can't have Iterative Attacks
Skill Points Unused : 2
Skills Ranks: 72 = 56 class skills +14 race mod +2 Favored class
Total Ranks Used 70forgot healer's kit ?
Climb +8 = +3 ranks, +5 Str, +3 class skill, -3 Armor Check Penalty
Fly +5 = +4 ranks, +1 Dex, +3 class skill, -3 Armor Check Penalty +0 Medium
Handle Animal +6 = +4 ranks, -1 Cha, +3 class skill
Heal +12 = +3 ranks, +4 Wis, +3 class skill +2 healer's kit
Knowledge (geography) +7 = +4 ranks, +0 Int, +3 class skill
Knowledge (nature) +11 = +6 ranks, +0 Int, +3 class skill +2 Druid
Perception +15 = +8 ranks, +4 Wis, +3 class skill
Perform (oratory) +5 = +6 ranks, -1 Cha
Ride +7 = +6 ranks, +1 Dex, +3 class skill, -3 Armor Check Penalty
Spellcraft +11 = +8 ranks, +0 Int, +3 class skill
Survival +23 = +14 ranks, +4 Wis, +3 class skill +2 Druid
Swim +9 = +4 ranks, +5 Str, +3 class skill, -3 Armor Check Penalty
As said before, if holding one in each hand to start, it's fine. The bigger issue though is that this character doesn't have more than 1 masterwork shortspear to throw, anyway.
Also healer's kits aren't counting.
|
|
CREEPING DEATH p. 74
Calls Wood Fist a Spell-Like Ability. It is Supernatural, and has previously appeared as a special attack.
forgot haste?
Fort: Computed: 13 Stat Block: 12
+9 ClassMod +0 RaceMod +1 AbilityMod +1 OnGoingMods( +1 Haste- Save Mod) + 2Cloak of Resistance Save ModFirstly, haste not properly applied. Second, barkskin and amulet of natural armour not stacking to give a +6 armour bonus. the base statistics block suggests they overlap, but I seem to recall it being definitively decided that they stack.
AC Value: Computed: 33 (+7 armor, +2 deflection, +3 Dex, +2 dodge, +6 natural, +3 shield) Stat Block: 31
AC = 10 +7 Armor +3 Shield +3 DexUsed +10 OtherBonuses +0 Rage
OtherBonuses = +2 Deflection +6 Natural +2 Dodge +0 SizeModhaste not properly applied
Melee Attack Bonus-+1 scythe: Computed: 14 Stat Block: 13
11 BAB +1 AbilityBonus +0 SizeMod +1 Enchantment Bonus +1 Haste- Attack Modhaste not properly applied
CMB: Computed: 13 Stat Block: +12
11BAB +0 SizeMod +1 AbilityMod +1 OnGoingAttackMod
1) Alright, your issue with wood fist being a supernatural ability is valid. However...
2) Haste increases Reflex saves, not Fort saves. Saves are incorrect, but it's Reflex that needs to be increased by 1.
3) Natural armor bonuses come in 3 different varieties: natural armor bonuses (like an animal's hide), increases to natural armor bonuses (like the natural AC increases of the Dragon Disciple), and enhancement bonuses to natural armor (like from barkskin and amulet of natural armor). Increases to natural armor always stack, but the former and latter don't, ever. Therefore, natural AC can be calculated as:
Natural AC = Highest natural AC bonus + total increases to natural AC + Highest enhancement bonus to natural AC
Because barkskin and amulet of natural armor are both enhancement bonuses to natural armor, they don't stack, and barkskin will override the AoNA for its duration. AC should be:
AC 32, touch 17, flat-footed 27 (+7 armor, +2 deflection, +3 Dex, +2 dodge, +5 natural, +3 shield)
4) You're right about the melee attack being too low, but you forgot to mention that it needs an extra attack in its full-attack due to haste. Melee should read:
Melee +1 cold iron scythe +14/+14/+9/+4 (2d4+2/x4)
5) You're right about CMB, but CMD also needs to be increased as the dodge bonus from haste hasn't been applied. CMD should be 29.
6) Lastly, there's one error you missed. Due to haste, speed should actually be 50 ft. (60 ft. normally, -10 from armor). After 5 rounds pass, the potion of haste will wear off and then the longstrider spell she cast will take over, since the two effects are enhancement bonuses and don't stack. When that happens, then her speed will be 30 feet as it is written in the stat block.
Healer's kits have charges, so we don't list the bonus for them (you have to opt-in to get the +2 and use a charge to do so).
|
|
TAIGA STALKER p. 75
Skill Points Unused : 2
Skills Ranks: 84 = 64 class skills +16 race mod +4 Favored class
Total Ranks Used 82forgot healer's kit?
Craft (woodworking) +11 = +8 ranks, +0 Int, +3 class skill
Fly +8 = +8 ranks, +2 Dex, +3 class skill, -5 Armor Check Penalty +0 Medium
Handle Animal +9 = +7 ranks, -1 Cha, +3 class skill
Heal +14 = +3 ranks, +6 Wis, +3 class skill +2 healer's kit
Knowledge (geography) +9 = +6 ranks, +0 Int, +3 class skill
Knowledge (nature) +15 = +10 ranks, +0 Int, +3 class skill +2 Druid
Perception +21 = +12 ranks, +6 Wis, +3 class skill
Ride +3 = +3 ranks, +2 Dex, +3 class skill, -5 Armor Check Penalty
Spellcraft +17 = +14 ranks, +0 Int, +3 class skill
Survival +22 = +11 ranks, +6 Wis, +3 class skill +2 Druid
Again, don't think they're counting healer's kits, due to the charges. However the masterwork woodcarving tools should be applied to Craft (woodworking), granting it a +2 bonus, since they don't have charges.
Additionally the saving throw line should include "+5 vs. exposure to cold weather" due to the cold weather outfit (I'm pretty sure clothing items are worn underneath armor, yah?)
We don't generally include clothing benefits to stat blocks.
|
|
I think this is because the are "empowered"Fury of Flame, p. 73
5th level - empowered fireball listed in two non-domain slots, domain spells not on a spell list can't be used except in domain slots
He's saying that there are two empowered fireballs in his 5th-level spell information. This would be fine if he only had one and it was in a domain spell slot, but his 5th-level domain slot is being taken up by fire shield. Since fireball isn't a druid spell, he can't have those prepared. They both need to be replaced by something else.
|
|
Pg. 206 - Vaultbreaker
In this lady's Other Gear, she's got a lens of detection. This item's from the Core Rulebook, but Ultimate Equipment updated this item into lenses of detection, which made it an eyes slot item instead of slotless. The illustration supports this.
Additionally, from the prestige classes, the following are missing their pouch:
Pg. 207: God Stealer
Pg. 208: Sacred Killer
Pg. 210: Murderous Scythe
Pg. 214: Dragon Chieftain
Pg. 223: Mithral Wizard
Pg. 224: Divine Loremaster
Pg. 225: Nature Scholar
Pg. 226: Master Historian
Pg. 227: Demonologist
Pg. 229: Sound Warrior
Pg. 230: Death Master
Pg. 231: Holy Battle Mage
Pg. 232: Aloof Scholar
Pg. 233: Mad Prophet
Pg. 235: Battle Skald
Pg. 237: Midnight Dancer
Pg. 238: Black Ice
Lastly, from the NPC classes:
Pg. 246: Guru
Pg. 249: Cultist
|
|
Pg. 56 - Master of Undeath
In addition to chopswil's report that this character is missing a 2nd, 3rd, 6th, and 7th level spell, it looks like two spells have been listed as domain spells in his 6th level spell info. Since both create undead and harm are 6th-level cleric spells anyway, it's a simple matter of just deleting the superscript of "D" from one of them.
|
|
Skill points come out fine. Remember that the armor check penalty's only -3, since it's magic breastplate and gets the masterwork benefit.SCARRED WANDERER p. 25
Skill HD Max:Acrobatics: Computed: 21 HD: 20
Skill:Survival: Computed: 2 Stat Block: 6Favored Class: Barbarian
Favored Class Points: 20
Favored Class Points Devoted to HP: 20Skill Points Exceeded : -1
Skills Ranks: 80 = 80 class skills
Total Ranks Used 81Acrobatics +22 = +21 ranks, +2 Dex, +3 class skill, -4 Armor Check Penalty
Climb +20 = +15 ranks, +6 Str, +3 class skill, -4 Armor Check Penalty
Intimidate +20 = +19 ranks, -2 Cha, +3 class skill
Linguistics +3 = +3 ranks, +0 Int
Perception +25 = +20 ranks, +2 Wis, +3 class skill
Profession (miner) +5 = +3 ranks, +2 Wis
Survival +2 = +0 ranks, +2 Wis
I'm sorry chop I was wrong on this one. I forgot to add the armor check penalty from the shield. Acrobatics is indeed wrong, but there's actually 2 skill points overspent total. Your program, if I understand how it works, didn't give Survival its full amount of ranks because it ran out of ranks to give out. Survival, listed at a +6 bonus in the book, has 1 rank.
TL;DR: Because this all originated from a miscalculated ACP, decrease Acrobatics and Climb each by 1.
|
|
Pgs. 26, 32, 33, 36, 38, 39, 43 - Various bards
The bards on these pages are missing their musical instruments in their other gear (although the cruel instructor and seance medium on 32 and 33 respectively would be hard pressed to carry a piano around). On page 26, only the street performer is sans instrument, the tavern singer's fine.
On a related note, the courtesan on page 35 has a mstwk harm for Perform (string) but nothing for her Perform (wind) skill.
Additionally, these prestige classes are missing their instruments:
Pg. 214: Dragon Chieftain
Pg. 226: Master Historian
Pg. 232: Aloof Scholar (although it'd be difficult to carry around a piano)
|
|
There's another issue here. Notice the HP. It says "2d8+1" but he has Con 13. At 2nd level, that'd be 2d8+2 at least. Unless you decide to put a favored class bonus into hp, that'd be hp 15 (2d8+2) and 14 total skill points to throw around.STREET PERFORMER p. 26
...
Slight correction here, it's actually 14 (2d8+2)
8+4+2 (originally I did 8+5+2)
|
I'll add my 2 coppers worth. I like this product, minor error and all.
My list of minor error...
The Dwarf NPC characters on pages 10, 13, 17, 25, 30, 37, 62, 79, 83, 87, 91, 100, 106, 114, 119, 124, 131, and 184 are all missing the Darkvision info the senses block.
Not sure if this has been posted before didnt feel like looking through 400+ posts.
|
|
I'll add my 2 coppers worth. I like this product, minor error and all.
My list of minor error...
The Dwarf NPC characters on pages 10, 13, 17, 25, 30, 37, 62, 79, 83, 87, 91, 100, 106, 114, 119, 124, 131, and 184 are all missing the Darkvision info the senses block.
Not sure if this has been posted before didnt feel like looking through 400+ posts.
When in doubt, you can go to the top of the page when you're in a thread and you should see a "Search this thread" box. You could type darkvision in here and it would pop up every instance where darkvision was mentioned in the entire thread.
|
|
HALFLING SLINGER p. 84
weapon to-hits (all)
They're all 2 points low. I think that Heroism has been improperly applied.
example
Melee Attack Bonus- short sword: Computed: 16 Stat Block: 14
9 BAB +3 AbilityBonus +1 SizeMod +1 weapon training +2 Heroism- Attack Mod
Yes on this, but I'm reading that the ranged entry is actually correct, unless I'm missing something:
9(BAB) + 5(Dex) + 1(size) + 1(ench) + 1(Wpn Fcs) + 1(Gr. Wpn Fcs) + 2(heroism) + 2(wpn training) = 22
EDIT: What's more, the Base Statistics line without bull's strength or heroism is correct for the short sword and ranged use of the +1 halfling sling staff, but it's melee entry is still 2 points too low.
|
|
SPRY AMBUSHER p. 97
forgot race mod to perception?
Skill Points Unused : 2
Skills Ranks: 20 = 20 class skills
Favored Class Points Devoted to HP: 4
Total Ranks Used 18Acrobatics +8 = +4 ranks, +1 Dex, +3 class skill
Bluff +5 = +4 ranks, +1 Cha
Climb +6 = +2 ranks, +1 Str, +3 class skill
Perception +12 = +4 ranks, +3 Wis, +3 class skill +2 Race Mod
Stealth +12 = +4 ranks, +1 Dex, +3 class skill +4 Small
I say put 'em into Climb since it's not full yet. This monk's also missing the bonus from the gnome's obsessive racial trait. They should either have a specific Craft skill at +3 or a specific Profession skill at +5.
SHOPKEEPER p. 257
Missing Armor Proficiency: studded leather needs Light
Since mwk studded leather has an armor check penalty of -0, you can use it just fine without a feat.
The Battle Mage on page 179 seems to be getting 2 extra skill points.
Abilities: Str 12, Dex 15, Con 12, Int 17, Wis 10, Cha 8
Skills
Acrobatics: 2 ranks + 2 Dex = +4
Climb: 1 rank + 1 Str = +2
Knowledge (Arcana) 3 ranks + 3 Int + 3 favored class bonus = +9
Knowledge (History) 3 ranks + 3 Int + 3 favored class bonus = +9
Perception 3 ranks + 2 racial = +5
Spellcraft 3 ranks + 3 Int + 3 favored class bonus = +9
Stealth 2 ranks + 2 Dex = +4
Total: 17 Skill ranks. Should only have 15.
I guess you could drop 2 hit points if you really wanted both acrobatics and stealth.
MASTER DUELIST p. 219
Feat Pre Req: Deflect Arrows is missing prereq feat Improved Unarmed Strike
He gets this feat from the PrC (level 9). I guess the sentence "you can use this feat even if you do not have the normal prerequisites" is missing.
Moreover, I think he should have Quick Draw if he wants to be able to throw so many daggers!
DEMONOLOGIST p. 227
Prismatic Wall is level 8 and not level 9
DARKSTAR p. 239
He misses 1 rogue talent. He should have 5 from his rogue levels (level 2, 4, 6, 8 and 10, last one being advanced) and 3 from his shadowdancer levels (level 3, 6 and 9) -> 8 talents + defensive roll (Shadowdancer 5) + slippery mind (Shadowdancer 7) = 10. He has only 9. Moreover, slippery mind isn't noted into the rogue talents parenthesis.
Having achieved level 10 Shadowdancer, his shadow call ability allows him to use Shadow Conjuration, Greater so I guess the corresponding DC should be 17 and not 14 (calculted as if it was Shadow Conjuration).
God Stealer p . 207
level 0 spells - two of his list are from opposition schools so they should cost twice to be learned, and he still has four spells
level 4 spells - he misses one, as chopswil mentioned earlier
level 6 spells - disintegrate is from one opposition school so he has one extra spell he should not.
Note: he carries a medium load with his bag of holding on.
Holy Battle Mage p 231
He misses one second level cleric spell
I'm a bit confused by the Novice Scout's starting equipment (pg. 128). I may well have missed a very remedial rule about starting wealth, so please point me in the right direction if I have. 1. The max starting gold for a 1st level ranger is 300 gp? The Novice Scout has almost 400 gp worth of gear. Is my math incorrect? 2. She has 3 masterwork arrows but I thought you normally had to buy them as a bundle, so is this just using simple division to arrive at a lower price or is there a specific place this rule is mentioned. Thank you for any assistance.
1st level NPCs with PC classes get 390 gp of wealth.
Also, you can always buy ammunition in single shots, and the rules on masterwork weapons explicitly state that buying a single unit of masterwork ammunition adds 6 gp to the price.
1st level NPCs with PC classes get 390 gp of wealth.
Also, you can always buy ammunition in single shots, and the rules on masterwork weapons explicitly state that buying a single unit of masterwork ammunition adds 6 gp to the price.
Brilliant, thank you. See? I told you, remedial. :)
Has anyone else noticed that the local celebrity doesn't seem to have his human +2 attribute bonus? it looks like they spent 15pt then didn't apply the bonus.
Shadow Cleric (Soufara Ebonwind) p. 59
Immune: Shouldn't there be "poison" as she casts delay poison?
Class Abilities: master's illusion should be DC 25 (10 + 18/2 + 6). She can use it 18 rd/day and it is listed as "at will" SLA as well. It might be the way it is intended to be written but it is a little bit confusing.
Spells: poison is level 4 and not level 3.
Skills: hp are 18d8+(2*18+9 (favored class)) so she has (2+1)*18+(18-9)=63.
Bluff - 9 (Rk) - 1 (Cha) + 3 (class skill from trickery domain) = 11
Diplomacy - 9 (Rk) - 1 (Cha) + 3 (class skill) = 11
Disguise - 9 (Rk) - 1 (Cha) + 3 (class skill from trickery domain) = 11
Knowledge (Religion) - 9 (Rk) + 1 (Int) + 3 (class skill) = 13
Perception - 0 (Rk) + 6 (Wis) + 0 (class skill) + 2 (keen senses) = 8
Sense Motive - 9 (Rk) + 6 (Wis) + 3 (class skill) = 18
Stealth - 13 (Rk) + 3 (Dex) + 3 (class skill from trickery domain) + 5 (shadow armor) = 24
Total Rk = 9+9+9+9+0+9+13 = 58
My guess is that the shadow armor competence bonus wasn't taken into account so Stealth Rk is 18.
|
|
MERISIEL Level 1 p. 292
Skill:Disable Device: Computed: 4 Stat Block: 7
Skill Points Unused : 1
--------------------------------------
ACP -1 = -1 studded leather
Skills Ranks: 8 = 8 class skills
Total Ranks Used 7Acrobatics +7 = +1 ranks, +4 Dex, +3 class skill, -1 Armor Check Penalty
Bluff +5 = +1 ranks, +1 Cha, +3 class skill
Climb +5 = +1 ranks, +2 Str, +3 class skill, -1 Armor Check Penalty
Disable Device +4 = +0 ranks, +4 Dex, -1 Armor Check Penalty +0 thieves' tools + (1/2= 0 ) Rogue Disable Device (Level /2)
Knowledge (local) +4 = +1 ranks, +0 Int, +3 class skill
Perception +6 = +1 ranks, +0 Wis, +3 class skill +2 Race Mod
Sleight of Hand +7 = +1 ranks, +4 Dex, +3 class skill, -1 Armor Check Penalty
Stealth +7 = +1 ranks, +4 Dex, +3 class skill, -1 Armor Check Penalty +0 Medium
You calculated Disable Device incorrectly. Remember, it's minimum +1 for trapfinding. It is incorrect, however, because the stat block doesn't take into account this bonus anyway (treating it like the Perception bonus which only applies to traps, while the Disable Device bonus is universal and should be noted). It should look more like this:
Disable Device +8 = 1 rank + 4(Dex) + 1(trapfinding) - 1(ACP) + 3(class)
|
|
Page 148 - Deadly Spy
Gear only lists one dagger but the Ranged line has 2 attacks with it. Probably should only have the +10 attack since it's tough (read: impossible) to throw the same dagger twice is one round.
I'd say change his gear to say he has two daggers. After all, even his artwork shows him holding a pair of daggers.