Liz Courts Contributor |
Removed posts.
Please move any discussion that isn't specifically about this book to this thread here.
Estrosiath |
I don't know... I thing one of the good things Paizo did about elves is end the proliferation of silly subraces. Now you just have elves and drow (and aquatic elves, but they are, by and large, normal elves that live underwater and use different weapons, not have different stats and racial traits). All other differences are cosmetic, which is fine by me.
But I have to say I miss the 2nd edition complete book of elves. That was a sourcebook about elves, with everything there was to know about them. I was expecting something more; the book did not really give me a sense of having learned more about the elves of Golarion.
And the magical food section... I mean. It's... Flavorful, but (again, to ME) it seemed like they were desperately trying to fill space. I would have preferred write-ups of other nations and places with important concentrations of elves.
deinol |
And the magical food section... I mean. It's... Flavorful, but (again, to ME) it seemed like they were desperately trying to fill space. I would have preferred write-ups of other nations and places with important concentrations of elves.
And the magical food section was my favorite article in the whole book. I guess for me it was one of the more unique topics to touch on, that hasn't been covered a zillion times before in other RPG books.
Estrosiath |
Estrosiath wrote:And the magical food section... I mean. It's... Flavorful, but (again, to ME) it seemed like they were desperately trying to fill space. I would have preferred write-ups of other nations and places with important concentrations of elves.And the magical food section was my favorite article in the whole book. I guess for me it was one of the more unique topics to touch on, that hasn't been covered a zillion times before in other RPG books.
Oh, I agree that it was definitely original.
But I still would have preferred something about, say, the Mordant Spire Elves, the ex-capital now claimed by the drow, or proper write-ups for the three elven deities, which were given close to no space, which is a shame.
3.5 Loyalist |
I don't know... I thing one of the good things Paizo did about elves is end the proliferation of silly subraces. Now you just have elves and drow (and aquatic elves, but they are, by and large, normal elves that live underwater and use different weapons, not have different stats and racial traits). All other differences are cosmetic, which is fine by me.
But I have to say I miss the 2nd edition complete book of elves. That was a sourcebook about elves, with everything there was to know about them. I was expecting something more; the book did not really give me a sense of having learned more about the elves of Golarion.
And the magical food section... I mean. It's... Flavorful, but (again, to ME) it seemed like they were desperately trying to fill space. I would have preferred write-ups of other nations and places with important concentrations of elves.
And Mwangi wild elves. Still the sub-races persist.
Evil Lincoln |
And Mwangi wild elves. Still the sub-races persist.
But are they mechanically different, that's what matters to me.
I mean, we have more than half a dozen human subraces in Golarion that make total sense. Having a few cultural variants based on geography is fine — just as long as it doesn't become a different species statistically that exists solely for the purpose of people trying to jigger their stats into an optimal range.
Estrosiath |
What Lincoln said. I don't so much mind "sub-races" or other cultures, so much as I hated the fact that every single one of them had to have different stats and cater to one class. You could have the elven fighter who was a wild elf, the drow cleric, the star elf sorcerer, the high elf rogue and the gold elf wizard. It's like they wanted elves to always have the best stats modifiers for every class.
Don't get me wrong, I love elves. I'm a big fan. I just thought it was silly.
And Golarion's elves are great. They're not different on a genetic level, just a cultural one. Much better (imo).
3.5 Loyalist |
3.5 Loyalist wrote:And Mwangi wild elves. Still the sub-races persist.But are they mechanically different, that's what matters to me.
I mean, we have more than half a dozen human subraces in Golarion that make total sense. Having a few cultural variants based on geography is fine — just as long as it doesn't become a different species statistically that exists solely for the purpose of people trying to jigger their stats into an optimal range.
Gah! Yeah I've seen players try to do that so much. And this type will allow me to be a better ranger. I can start with a 22. As always the power-gaming is the problem.
Yeah more cultural work, less stat tailoring.
Christopher Rowe Contributor |