schattenstern's page

This scenario was a very interesting one with a ver great illusion of choice at the beginning but the forced choice in the final encounter feels wrong compared to what we can expect from other scenarios in this season.

Mechanically everything seems fine but the difficulty was very erratic between the encounters.

I played this scenario 3 times (two times high tier, one time low) and it was a blast every time.
We had always different challenges and some of them were pleasantly nasty. I love this kind of concept for a replayable and the fact that we now have a 3-7 replayable (and that this is the first replayable with no “noob protection”)
The challenge can be customized for the group present and ranges from relatively easy to “Do your worst” All kind of PC should feel necessary because skill and combat oriented characters can contribute (more or less depending on the chosen arc.)

The only warning I can give: NEVER run it cold or try to roll everything at the table because you WILL miss some important parts.

When I played this scenario yesterday we had a group of 4 lv 9 and one lv 10 so we played at the lowest possible high tier. (with adjustment) We had a very fun experience while interacting with the NPCs in the camp and the ones in the dungeon. The exploration of the weird stuff we found was also very satisfying BUT the mechanical part of this adventure seems completely underwhelming. ALL encounters were far too weak and we got even the “harder” version of the boss.

First things fist, I think this is by FAR the best Halloween themed adventure PFS has to offer. It is flavorful and very thematic. But I think the mechanical execution is very lackluster. The scenario is extremely short and no combat is even remotely challenging.

While I liked the premise of the scenario the execution was very lackluster. The scenario had mayor pacing issues and the reliance on trained only skills with these DCs at level 1-5 is very problematic.

The fact that you are denied your most used problem solvers in the first and a majority of useful class abilities in the first and second encounter is something I not only despise as a player but will make this part a very unfunny experience for some tables.

The second part of the scenario is a pseudo-sandbox where you can only get the majority of useful information (and all that will bring some light in this weird plot) at a location where no player should go if they listened to their briefing. Also, there are major problems if the players want to step outside this railroad at any other point than the one the scenario seems to expect (but provides no clues for the players that this is an option) Also the final encounter seems very lackluster and not very appropriate for a final combat.

So, all in all, I can see a very interesting setup which has a terrible execution.

The setting of this adventure is novel and very interesting but some of the mechanics are VERY stupid.

I very much liked the aiding mechanics used at the beginning of the scenario and hope they will be used more often -> they very much help to get everyone to roll and stop the discussions about who has the highest bonus. The Fights were a bit easy, but I think the tactics are to blame here -> especially in the final combat encounter.
The last skill encounter was very refreshing and exciting. The mechanic used there was very player centric and resulted in some of the most cinematic scenes in PFS I have ever experienced.

This scenario had a quite good story but there were FAR too many skill checks -> Especially the knowledge checks were far too many. It would help to reduce the number of checks and collect them in fewer checks. Sometimes we rolled more than 7 Checks in one room and it became tedious sometimes.
The encounters were interesting and especially the Respect-Interactions were very nice. The encounters were easy.

I liked the flavor of the scenario and the harrow aspects. The difficulty was quite low but I really liked the modular design and the different challenges.

Mechanically the scenario has some unclear points and the final encounter is a very complex but underwhelming encounter.

I played the scenario at a slot 0 and prepared to run it at our yearly convention:

It has a very interesting setting with memorable and interesting Encounters. It was fun to play and to prepare. The only problems are an overuse of certain monsters

All in all, I like the scenario and especially the setting with its unique opportunities. It has the right feeling for a multi table-special but I hope we will get to see the ramifications of this scenario early in season 8. The difficulty feels right and I love the two special bosses with their ability to give even power gamers an adequate challenge.