Baby Kobold

crognus's page

Organized Play Member. 113 posts. No reviews. No lists. No wishlists. 1 Organized Play character.


RSS

1 to 50 of 113 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>
Dark Archive

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Just for further added context, Illithids were from 1974 and Drow from 1977. So there were no Drow in the Underdark originally anyway.

Dark Archive

3 people marked this as a favorite.

Illithids the original Underdark denizens, were heavily Cthulhu inspired. And the idea of the Underdark also seems inspired by Yoth. So, the Underdark was very Mythos inspired from the onset.

Having the primary antagonists be Serpentfolk makes a lot of sense since they are also Mythos based. In this retcon they DON'T seem Yuan-Ti inspired so much as Serpentfolk Cthulhu Mythos inspired (which heavily predates Yuan-Ti), especially from the work "The Curse of Yig" and "The Mark of Yig" (the latter work moved his domain to Yoth).

Dark Archive

2 people marked this as a favorite.
nephandys wrote:
I was really hoping to see Paizo's updated take on the Drow. Maybe bioluminescent fungus worshipers with ties to the outer gods or who knows what else. This is honestly the worst of both worlds - removing Drow and leaving nothing or nonsensical oops all snake people in their place. Cavern elves aren't even close to a substitute especially if they're going to be heroes of the darklands. I'm sure I'll get over it but I don't think I could be more disappointed than this.

If you want it to be Outer Gods or Old Ones/Lovecrast stuff , I reckon James was thinking about Yig when he decided on making the Serpentfolk as the primary under dark antagonists. He’s a full on Lovecraft super fan. So there, wish granted.

Dark Archive

James Jacobs wrote:
crognus wrote:
I am currently running a group through the APS in order and as we finish up Runelords, do you have any suggestion as to handle Second Darkness? Should I do something with “chaos elves?” That aren’t an ancestry but more like a group of elves being mind controlled by Rovagug? I want to fit the new canon of no Drow, but still run this AP.

If you and your group are comfortable building your own canon for Golarion as you go forward, run Second Darkness as-is. Since you're not publishing content for Pathifnder, you get to decide to keep drow as part of your game if you want. Then... if you DO catch up to us to a point where we publish something that contradicts your game's canon as regards drow, at that point you'll have to decide what to do. But since there are going to be about 200 adventures for you to go through before you reach that point, and possibly quite a few more if we don't do something with the Darklands that touches upon this specific subject (Sky King's Tomb does not, as far as I know)... you won't have to worry about that for a LOOOOONG time.

If you want to future proof your game's canon with what will be happening 200+ adventures in your table's future, though, my suggestion would be to run Second Darkness as-is, but the "drow" are instead just serpentfolk who are disguised as elves. Consider relocating Adventure 4 out of Zirnakaynin to a different city, since in our canon going forward, that city's going to remain a mystery for now, but again... that's over 200 adventures in your future so...

Thanks for the suggestions! I play 7 games/campaigns of Pathfinder 2E a week for the last 3 years. (I know! I’m a crazy person!) Some set early from 4707-4709. Some of them from 4719 AR-4721 AR with overlap of players. All of them in the same continuity. So it does matter immediately.

Dark Archive

James Jacobs wrote:

And frankly, another element that is not insignificant? Like what they've done with drow or not, TSR and then WotC is why drow are as popular as they are. I myself had a tiny part in helping build that popularity with them during my time as an editor for Dungeon or a writer of D&D adventures.

I still think the idea of drow, as developed by TSR and WotC, has a lot of mileage and potential, particularly as they're developed into a new and more diverse culture that leaves behind the "evil black elves" that we were in the midst of pursuing this time last year.

But with this cutting of ties with the OGL legacy of the game and us forging forward to be our own selves, we have to make individual choices for ALL of the elements from D&D that we've benefited from through the years and decide what to do with those... to cut them loose, to adjust them, to replace them, whatever.

In the case of drow, cutting them lose and, essentially, returning them to D&D entirely does two things—it lets us go forward without that potential legal complication, and it lets Wizards of the Coast take up the reins of developing one of their most successful creations and bringing them into the future. They deserve that chance. If something we have done with drow in the past helps WotC to bring them into the future even stronger and less problematic, then I'll be proud of the fact that Paizo helped in that way and consider it giving back to the company whose OGL was so generous for so long that it helped Paizo and Pathfinder and Starfinder get to where they are today.

Maybe it's right that, about 17 to 18 years into Pathifnder's life, this happened. It's kind of like a child becoming an adult and moving out of their parent's house to strike out into the world on their own. During that span, we've learned a lot from D&D, and I hope D&D's learned a lot from us. We can still learn from each other going forward, but we're looking for our own place in the world now.

I am currently running a group through the APS in order and as we finish up Runelords, do you have any suggestion as to handle Second Darkness? Should I do something with “chaos elves?” That aren’t an ancestry but more like a group of elves being mind controlled by Rovagug? I want to fit the new canon of no Drow, but still run this AP.

Dark Archive

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Dwim wrote:
crognus wrote:

I created a rules supplement to allow players to use the warg puppies in Hellknight Hill as animal companions or familiars. It also includes a Citadel Altaerein upgrade that allows other classes to gain access to animal companions.

Age of Ashes - Warg Supplement

Any chance this would still be available somewhere ?

I accidentally deleted and lost this document. Sorry.

Dark Archive

1 person marked this as a favorite.
duxfemina wrote:

So working with Crognus's simplified "Ruling Citadel Altaerein", I took the book stuff and his stuff and combined them to come up with this.

https://scribe.pf2.tools/v/YDd8606B-new-ruling-citadel-altaerein

I used a combo of Crognus's simplified costs as representing total labor and supply costs but each activity still requires a single check related to the upgrade.

Basically, I've made Administering the Citadel more about planning the repairs and upgrades to speed the activities and organizing workers about reducing waste in labor and supply cost. So PCs will choose an activity, like "Build Infirmary". They pick one PC to do an Administer (society, crafting or recall knowledge) check. The crit success and success decrease the number of days for the activity and gives a bonus to the next organize labor roll. Failure means the activity takes the full time and crit fail increases the time it takes due to poor planning.

One PC can then Organize Labor and they recruit workers and the party's rep goes up in town for being good employers. Crit success and success reduce the cost of the activity and give a bonus to the next administer check. Failure means they pay full cost, crit failure the cost increases due to slow workers wasting materials.

So one activity gets 3 checks: Administer, Organize, and then the skill check for the activity. Crafting or Medicine for the infirmary, for example.

Anyway. let me know what y'all think and give me any corrections or feedback.

I just saw this. This is really cool. Glad you liked the subsystem.

Dark Archive

My friends and I are about to finish Age of Ashes, and we are discussing going back and playing some 1E adventures to learn more about the meta-narrative of Golarion. At the top of the list was the Runelords Trilogy, but at the Erik Mona Q&A he mentioned something interesting that I didn't know. Crown of the Kobold King ties into the Tar-Baphon meta-narrative.

This made me realize that important things even happen outside of the main AP line. In your opinion, what are the most important meta-narratives of 1E and which APs and adventures tie into them?

(ie. If you want to understand New Thassilon play all of these, if you want to understand the Whispering Tyrant play all of these, etc. etc.)

Dark Archive

How is sewage/waste-disposal handled in an Azarketi city?

Dark Archive

I sent an email on April 5th about this and I haven't seen a response.

The original order numbers for my PaizoCon 2020 ticket was 10782622 and 12929103. I believe that was 3 total tickets between the two orders? Can you confirm that I have tickets to the 2022 physical event?

I already took the days off work to go to the event.

Dark Archive

Do gods/demi-gods have souls? If not, what happens to the souls of mortals who became gods? If they do, does Pharasma judge them if they die?

Dark Archive

In Age of Ashes, Jonivar states the Anima Invocation requires the souls of willing participants and that's why the ritual won't work. Theoretically, what would happen if, instead of convincing Mengkare to not to the ritual, the population was informed of the true nature of the ritual and convinced to become willing? (With the unwilling expelled/spared.)

The population seems quite culty, and if you look at real world examples of isolated communities like Jim Jones...large populations can become convinced...

Dark Archive

Diego Valdez wrote:

Hello Crognus,

You should be able to see the scenarios on your account now. You won't see the quests as those are not part of the society subscriptions.

I have moved all of the sidecarted items that were ready to go out to order 15429988 so it can all ship together. You will be receiving an updated email confirmation reflecting that change.

Thanks! And thanks for the clarification about Quests.

Dark Archive

Hi,

I backed and redeemed my codes for the latest Starfinder Humble Bundle. The codes all worked for the digital tiers, but the physical code never took me to the link to pay for shipping. Nor, do I see it in my sidecart.

It appears to just be "redeemed" at this point without the physical products ever being entered.

Dark Archive

Hi.

I have been a super-subscriber since August 2019. I should be getting all the Pathfinder/Starfinder Society Scenarios for free. For the most part I do, but I seem to be missing the following items:

https://paizo.com/products/btq022bt?Pathfinder-Society-Quest-5-The-Dragon-W ho-Stole-Evoking-Day
https://paizo.com/products/btq022kv?Pathfinder-Society-Quest-6-Archaeology- in-Aspenthar
https://paizo.com/products/btq022wz?Pathfinder-Society-Quest-7-A-Curious-Cl aim
https://paizo.com/products/btq0232u?Pathfinder-Society-Quest-8-Shadows-of-t he-Black-Sovereign
https://paizo.com/products/btq023dh?Pathfinder-Society-Quest-9-Wayfinder-Or igins
https://paizo.com/products/btq023di?Pathfinder-Society-Quest-10-The-Broken- Scales
https://paizo.com/products/btq024tt?Pathfinder-Society-Quest-11-A-Parchment -Tree
https://paizo.com/products/btq023fb?Pathfinder-Society-Quest-12-Putrid-Seed s
https://paizo.com/products/btq024wt?Pathfinder-Society-Quest-13-Falcons-Des cent
https://paizo.com/products/btq022la?Pathfinder-Society-Scenario-112-The-Bur den-of-Envy
https://paizo.com/products/btq022lb?Pathfinder-Society-Scenario-113-Devil-a t-the-Crossroads
https://paizo.com/products/btq0232v?Pathfinder-Society-Scenario-116-The-Per ennial-Crown-Part-1-Opal-of-Bhopan
https://paizo.com/products/btq0232w?Pathfinder-Society-Scenario-117-The-Per ennial-Crown-Part-2-The-Thorned-Monarch
https://paizo.com/products/btq023dc?Pathfinder-Society-Scenario-118-Lodge-o f-the-Living-God
https://paizo.com/products/btq023dd?Pathfinder-Society-Scenario-119-Iolite- Squad-Alpha
https://paizo.com/products/btq023de?Pathfinder-Society-Scenario-120-The-Los t-Legend
https://paizo.com/products/btq023df?Pathfinder-Society-Scenario-121-Mistres s-of-the-Maze
https://paizo.com/products/btq023fd?Pathfinder-Society-Scenario-122-Doom-of -Cassomir
https://paizo.com/products/btq023fe?Pathfinder-Society-Scenario-123-The-Sta rCrossed-Court
https://paizo.com/products/btq022lc?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-215-The-Inf ernal-Gallery
https://paizo.com/products/btq022ld?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-216-A-Scour ed-Home
https://paizo.com/products/btq022x5?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-219-Truth-K eepers
https://paizo.com/products/btq022x6?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-220-Shades- of-Spite
https://paizo.com/products/btq022x7?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-221-Illegal -Shipment
https://paizo.com/products/btq022x8?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-222-Rasheen s-Reception
https://paizo.com/products/btq023cw?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-223-The-Edg e-of-Cadascon
https://paizo.com/products/btq023cx?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-224-Cornere d-Rat
https://paizo.com/products/btq023hb?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-301-Crash-D own
https://paizo.com/products/btq023hc?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-302-The-Sub terranean-Safari
https://paizo.com/products/btq027p5?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-402-Settlin g-Accounts
https://paizo.com/products/btq027p6?Starfinder-Society-Scenario-403-Battle- for-the-Beacon

Also, can you please process order 15429988 and send the items in my sidecart immediately?

Dark Archive

If Lisa Stevens said, "James, you got two years to wrap up all Golarion products. We got enough. We're doing a new campaign setting after." What hanging threads or plot points would you want to close out? What would be the final Golarion products you'd want to see? Would you ever reveal some of the biggest mysteries, like Aroden's death?

Dark Archive

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Have you read Designers & Dragons (especially the Paizo history section)? If so, how accurate would you say it is?

I find that era, right after the Dragon, Dungeon, and Star Wars magazine partnership ended fascinating, and the replanning for company direction had to take place. Do you have any stories from that period before Jason pitched Pathfinder? Or any other directions that were pitched before landing on Paizo's current direction?

What was the mood like? Eg. Was there ever any discussion of doing a 4E OGL supplemental magazine? What was the mood like, excited or apprehensive?

Dark Archive

Still no answer? I'd just place another order for the physical version. But I want to ensure I get the PDF too.

Dark Archive

Because this has happened a second time now, please check my account to see if something happened on the backend. I have a feeling this issue is going to continue if some sort of subscription setting isn't checked. I am subbed to the following:

Pathfinder Adventure Card Game
Pathfinder Adventure Path
Pathfinder Battles
Pathfinder Lost Omens
Pathfinder Maps
Pathfinder Adventure
Pathfinder Pawns
Pathfinder Player Companion
Pathfinder Rulebook
Starfinder Society
Pathfinder Accessories
Pathfinder Society
Pathfinder Special Edition Rulebook

Dark Archive

Hi.

I sub to all Pathfinder subscriptions. I was never sent the following items. I sent an email about it Feb. 21st and never received a response.

Pathfinder Adventure Path #163: Ruins of Gauntlight
Pathfinder Flip-Mat: City Sites Multi-Pack

Today I saw I never received this item, so I sent another email. Hopefully either that email or this thread gets a response.
Flip-Mat Classics: Red Light District

Also, because I needed access to Pathfinder Adventure Path #163: Ruins of Gauntlight I just bought the PDF (that should be included with my Pathfinder subscription with the physical product). Once, you rectify the situation with the missing physical products, can you please refund me for that order?

Regards

Dark Archive

What is the IP state of the old APs that were joint between WOTC and Paizo? Eg. If Beadle and Grimm's wanted to do a legendary Shackled City? Would that require an okay between both Companies? Who owns Shackled City, etc?

Dark Archive

Can you reveal what coastal town Malevolence takes place in/near?

Dark Archive

Have you ever ran a game set in Golarion but with a different game system? The first book of Agents of Edgewatch seems like it might be really fun with Call of Cthulhu rules...

Dark Archive

Have you GMed any of the Adventure Paths beginning to end? If so, which?

Dark Archive

Do the alghollthus have ties to the outer gods? Reading about the ulat-kini and they have extreme "Shadow Over Innsmouth" vibes.

Dark Archive

Thanks! All of that makes sense.

In all honesty, I already buy more Pathfinder/Golarion products than I'll ever be able to read in my lifetime anyway. I own nearly every AP/campaign Setting/Player Companion since the beginning. But it's there for when I need it (never know which direction players will run)...

Good stuff.

Dark Archive

Is there a reason print on demand hasn't been utilized for the orphaned novels? POD companies like Lulu do not take copyright ownership, and your products can be repealed from them at any time.

From what I understand those novels are completed, so posting them on a POD site would take zero capital. If self-publishing later becomes more profitable, Paizo could just pull it from Lulu. POD is less profitable, but is more profitable than the zero dollars those books make currently.

Dark Archive

Does changing the terms of monsters to not constrain to the OGL give any possibility of Pathfinder Tales returning? Has there been any discussion of the orphaned novels?

Dark Archive

3 people marked this as a favorite.

I was not happy with the Citadel Altaerein upgrade subsystem. It was tedious, and the rooms were not exciting. Here is an alternative system that greatly simplifies building rooms, and includes 16 more upgrades.

Citadel Altaerein Upgrades
Citadel Altaerein Upgrade Sheet

**Fixed Link**

Dark Archive

I was not happy with the Citadel Altaerein upgrade subsystem. It was tedious, and the rooms were not exciting. Here is an alternative system that greatly simplifies building rooms, and includes 16 more upgrades.

Citadel Altaerein Upgrades
Citadel Altaerein Upgrade Sheet

Dark Archive

Scrolled past the mention of Nyarlathotep earlier, which makes me wonder: Have you ever played or ran Masks of Nyarlathotep? If so, how'd it go?

Dark Archive

This is a silly question, but irks my OCD. On the spine of AP #145, #146, the word "Pathfinder" is in Red/Orange. For the rest of Age of Ashes #147~150, Pathfinder is in white. Was this overlooked, or was it a design change because Pathfinder was hard to read on 145/146?

Dark Archive

What design choices were behind the monster name changes in 2E? (Eg. Ettercap/Web Lurker, Stirge/Bloodseeker, Aboleth/Alghollthu, Mite/Mitflit)? Was it purely creative, or were there business/product identity considerations as well?

Dark Archive

I want to have an army of Cinderclaw charau-ka cultists attack Akrivel, prior to the PCs leaving, to add more urgency to hunting down and destroying the cult, but information on the city is sparse.

What is the population of Akrivel? Is there more information on the city that had to be cut for space?

Dark Archive

As probably the voluminous RPG company, how extensively are APs and modules play tested prior to publication? Does Paizo have external players with non-disclosure agreements? Is there a team that does this in house?

I like to imagine a room full of dozens of Oompa-Loompas employed by Paizo, joyfully playing through all the content filling out play test questionnaires.

Dark Archive

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Getting published by Paizo is a dream of mine, because I absolutely love Golarion. Do you have any advice for how to get noticed? Self-publish? Pitch to smaller companies that accept unsolicited submissions? Kickstart projects?

For someone starting at the bottom and wanting to work their way up, where does Paizo generally look for new talent? What type of projects are they most likely to notice as a writer? Bestiaries, adventures, sub-system projects (like expanded downtime rules)?

Would trying to build a name for yourself by publishing for other systems with more lax third-party publishing rules work (ie. DMsguild, Foundry), or does Paizo only look at people with published Pathfinder work?

Dark Archive

Are internal employees in non-creative positions (eg. customer service reps, warehouse workers, web design, etc.) allowed to make unsolicited pitches if they've been with Paizo for some time? Or do the same rules apply to them?

Dark Archive

How has the writing process been refined/streamlined since the Dragon Magazine days or early AP days?

Dark Archive

What is the creation process behind the AP story bibles (before assigning each book to the individual authors)? Is it like screenwriting where you meet daily to make sure everyone is on the same page? How long do they take to write before the story bibles are then sent to the individual authors?

Dark Archive

I really like the aesthetic re-design of classic monsters in 2E (such as hobgoblins and kobolds). It makes Golarion instantly unique and distinctive from other products. Was this pitched by the writing team to the artists, or from the artists to the writing team? Will we see this trend continue in future Bestiaries?

Dark Archive

James Jacobs wrote:

Getting into the game rules for real-world active, powerful, widespread religions is not a good idea—that's a great way to piss people off and start arguments and lose friends. I don't go there as a result.

Earth works best as a rare spice in game to play with the game's take on reality, but the more you bring Earth into Pathfinder, the more awkward things get. "Rasputin Must Die" represents how we handle this thing—and that's by presenting a fantasy version of Earth where we simply don't address everything in print.

As the creative director for Pathfinder, I have to watch what I say online, because I'm not interested in places on the internet taking a post I make out of context to fuel anti-Paizo, anti-Pathfinder, or anti-James hate and vitriol and cancel culturing. So I don't answer questions like this. Sorry.

Classy response. I respect that this is more important than my curiosity. Was there any internal conflicted discussion on whether having an AP go to Earth was a good idea, or was everyone equally excited and on board with this idea when it was first pitched?

Dark Archive

If Paizo Earth is on the same material plane as Golarion, do Earthlings go to the River of Souls and get judged by Pharasma? If the Old Kingdom of Kemet (Egypt) shares the same pantheon as Osirion, what does that mean for other Earth religions? Does Christianity, Buddhism, Hinduism, Islam, etc. exist on this version of Earth?

Dark Archive

If Paizo Earth is on the same material plane as Golarion, do Earthlings go to the River of Souls and get judged by Pharasma? If the Old Kingdom of Kemet (Egypt) shares the same pantheon as Osirion, what does that mean for other Earth religions? Do Thor or Jesus exist on the this alternate version of Earth?

Dark Archive

What were some of the campaign setting design goals with the release of 2E? (For example, "Reinforce the idea Absalom was the center of the Inner Sea.")

Also, is it okay for me to ask these sorts of questions, or are they classified? I've been reading Designers and Dragons, and the sections about Paizo strategy and manager meetings are fascinating.

Dark Archive

James Jacobs wrote:
I can't imagine a world where players would pay for a GM to come to their house and run a game for them.

Do you mean that you don't believe it is a profession, or that you know it exists and still have trouble believing it? Having a professional GM come to your house and GM (for hundreds of dollars) is definitely a thing.

It’s a Living: Meet One of New York’s Best Professional D&D Dungeon Masters

The Rise of the Professional Dungeon Master

Dark Archive

1 person marked this as a favorite.

I look forward to learning more. I do like your team's decisions regarding the revolt. Having the revolution occur in an adventure (depending on player character concepts) could potentially be...Dances of Wolvesy...It's good that the Mwangi themselves were the ones who overthrew the colony, so they aren't passive in their own history.

Dark Archive

James Jacobs wrote:
crognus wrote:
Was there an adventure that takes place during the Mwangi revolt against Sargava, or is that just something that happened in the background? Was Baron Utilinus killed or did he retreat? What tribes banded together, and who were the major leaders of the revoltion?
That's brand new lore introduced in 2nd edition that was never a part of an adventure. All that we've really said about it is in print in the Lost Omens books, but we'll certainly have more to say about it going forward.

Will The Slithering give any more insight, or do you mean even further down the road?

Dark Archive

Was there an adventure that takes place during the Mwangi revolt against Sargava, or is that just something that happened in the background? Was Baron Utilinus killed or did he retreat? What tribes banded together, and who were the major leaders of the revoltion?

Dark Archive

1 person marked this as a favorite.

When you first read linked adventures in the TSR days did you ever imagine anything like APs as a product? Especially a continually ongoing storyline spanning over 100 volumes?

Mega-adventures existed and the B1-B9 compilation, but nothing like this. What was the inspiration for the format?

Dark Archive

"James Jacobs wrote:

Bestiary 2 has been off to the printer for a bit now. Currently, I'm doing more creative direction work and less development work. Jumping in here and there to provide more text, to adjust things, to provide advice, etc. as needed, as well as working on some things that haven't yet been announced.

How intertwined is setting and rules development when a new edition comes out? How does a typical week compare now, to a week prior to 2E Dev?