Mistwalker wrote:
Chris Mortika wrote:
Marko, why would Torch hand over the maps to Seeker's Folly when the PCs hadn't completed his tasks?
Probably due to the wording in the "conclusion" section:
Once the PCs complete (or at least attempt) all of Grandmaster Torch’s tasks to his satisfaction, he fulfills his part of the bargain by giving them several old maps.
My interpretation of that is: if Torch is satisfied that the group gave their best effort in completing their tasks, he will hand over the maps.
If the PCs get the map, they get the Prestige Point.
Exactly, the party bluffed Torch and said that they have completed the task, bluff check failed, but as FLite said it is clearly noted that Torch is willing to overlook the PCs sabotaging at least one of the tasks, but it says "sabotaging" not "failing" and my party failed one task, so that was my dilemma, should they get the PP or not... Anyway I will give the party first PP, after all your responses, I think it's fair decision. Ty all for help and answers!