After finding the route to the lost city of Neruzavin, the adventurers must mount
an expedition into the vast and deadly desert region called the Parchlands,
where they hope to catch up to their treacherous former employer. Once
they brave the heat-blasted wasteland, the heroes arrive in an abandoned city at
the edge of a lake where a Great Old One slumbers. The adventurers must track
Count Lowls's party, recover a vile tome, activate the city's Star Stelae, and perform
a powerful ritual that allows them to follow the insane noble to Carcosa. Along the
way, the heroes must be careful they don't wake the slumbering Great Old One
or stir up the flying polyps sealed beneath the city!
"What Grows Within," a Pathfinder RPG adventure for 13th-level characters,
by John Compton.
Examination of the fungal blot that spreads through dreams in an article about the
Great Old One Xhamen-Dor, by James Jacobs.
An exploration of the blasphemous tome known as the Necronomicon, by James Jacobs.
An icy tomb hides a terrible secret in the Pathfinder's Journal, by Arinn Dembo.
A bestiary containing a new Great Old One and other hideous
monsters, by John Compton, Adam Daigle, and James Jacobs.
ISBN-13: 978-1-60125-913-4
"What Grows Within" is sanctioned for use in Pathfinder Society Organized Play. The rules for running this Adventure Path and Chronicle sheet are available as a free download (723 kb zip/PDF).
Other Resources: This product is also available on the following platforms:
I was torn between 3 and 4 Stars. I write this from the DMs perspective.
Preparing parts 2 and 3 of the book was an immense struggle. Usually you know "ok, event A happens, then B, then either C, D, or E, depending on B...." you can basically make a flowchart of ideas and scenarios that could obviously get railroaded. Part 1 of the book does this perfectly, but as another reviewer said, it's a bit railroady, but I'm not bothered by that. You know what the players encounter and you can work with that. Do the PCs have an eagle that scouts? Then they will see what comes ahead easier! You can still work with it but it also gives clear directions for the GM....
Not so the second and third part. I don't know if this is an isolated experience, but I felt utterly lost on the line the players were supposed to follow. There was no "this is what happens when the players ask around" or "when the players seek out a tavern" etc.... They just give you a bunch of random encounters and say "but most of those should be done after condition X", without ever saying how to reach that condition. I was very much missing the guidance for the GM in those parts.
But enough negativity! You know why I finally decided for 4 Stars? Because of everything and everyone you encounter. WOW! I introduced this book to my players with "from here on out, things only get more exciting!" because I was so hyped to Roleplay such diverse NPCs, ideas and things, and have some rather interesting fights and encounters.
TL;DR: Parts 2 and 3 lack guidance for the GM which he needs to work out himself, but the diversity and creativity in the book is amazing and great!
In role playing games, railroading is when the players are forced into a specific set of actions regardless of their wishes. This chapter of the adventure path does this in the worst way possible. The plot goes as follows: The big bad has used an evil book to perform a ritual to enter the realm of Hastur, an evil demigod who looks like some guy in a yellow hood. The players must save the day and prove their heroism by....reclaiming the aforementioned evil book and performing the same evil ritual to enter the evil demigod's home realm. Sigh. The book is located in yet another ruined city filled with monsters who sit around waiting to be attacked. Seriously, is it possible to go half a block without stumbling into a ruined city in gaming? In the course of the adventure, the players will be forced to kill no less than two angels who are simply doing their jobs. (Three if you count that guru-angel turned emo). The book explicitly states that it is impossible to avoid killing the angels, without making a deal with a devil and even that only reduces the death toll to one. Not exactly friendly to players who play paladins and clerics.
Making matters worse is the fact that there is no real reason to do any of the adventure. No reason is given for why the players cannot simply use common dimensional travel magic to reach their goal. For that matter, what exactly is the threat that bad guy possesses? The text indicates that he may elevate his patron from demigod to outer god, but it never stated how this to take place and what its significance is. Hastur is already featured as a challenge rating 29 entry in the Beastiary 4 and seems to have no difficulty interacting with the mortal world.
The rest of the book is given over to discussing the evil book, but honestly, Paizo has already gone over similar ground in earlier projects and much more competently. Also, there is an overview of the Great Old One Xamen-Dor, but it is just another evil demigod who uses fungus to create undead. This setting already has about a half dozen bad guys who do the same thing and honestly, it is kitchen mold. How scary can it be? The villain has some other gimmick about becoming more powerful the more people know of it, but this never really plays much a role.
I cannot recall the last time, Paizo has published a turkey like this. Hopefully, it will be the last time this happens
Pathfinder Lost Omens, Rulebook, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
So hyped! I wish my Bloodborne-Lovecraftian campaign was delayed by 5 months so I could shamelessly rip from what is looking to be utterly fantastic work.
Where Xhamen-Dor’s comet came to rest is unknown—but its cult agrees that the fallen star that bears the Great Old One’s core lies at the depths of a large but remote lake somewhere in the world.
Pathfinder Lost Omens, Rulebook, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Kalindlara wrote:
Slumbers in a lake, if I recall correctly. ^_^
One moment...
Wake of the Watcher wrote:
Where Xhamen-Dor’s comet came to rest is unknown—but its cult agrees that the fallen star that bears the Great Old One’s core lies at the depths of a large but remote lake somewhere in the world.
Ah yes. Good catch. I wouldn't be surprised if that is the lake the abandoned city lies on.
Where Xhamen-Dor’s comet came to rest is unknown—but its cult agrees that the fallen star that bears the Great Old One’s core lies at the depths of a large but remote lake somewhere in the world.
Doy! This is what happens when you are half asleep when posting. Also, for some reason I was thinking Xhamen-Dor was the guy in the mountain next to Xin-Shalast, but I now remember that is Mahr.
Brilliant cover image. Who's the guy on the front?
While we have no specific knowledge of his identity, his wrappings are suggestive of a denizen of Leng. The mouthparts poking out seem to confirm that. Most denizens don't have horns as big as that, though...
He's wielding the favored weapon of the King in Yellow, so he's probably tightly associated with the Unspeakable One.
That blot on his arm is likely a mote of Xhamen-Dor, givne the adventure's association with that being.
I don't remember seeing any horns on denizens of leng. But he could have a template or even class feature for that anyway.
In the original Lovecraft story The Dream-Quest of Unknown Kadath, which the denizens are taken from, they wear those yellow turbans and wrappings to hide their horns. (They're not very big horns - think tiefling.)
As he is strongly tied to this AP, and specially to this volumes, as it contains details about him, is it safe to suppose that Xhamen-Dor is the Great Old One among the monsters in the bestiary article?
I'd consider it a fairly safe bet. Among other things... the GM needs those stats if the players wake it up. ^_^
I enjoy providing numbers. Numbers give players the hope that, in the horrible event they do awaken a Great Old One, they stand some chance. Sometimes numbers start with a plus sign and are divisible by 43. Sometimes players regret their actions. Sometimes the GM gets to use the really big stat blocks.
Perhaps that's relevant to this adventure and/or its backmatter—not my place to say just yet. I think we'll have to wait until subscribers start getting their copies.
or, it could be like how they give stats for the Spawn of rovagug in the adventure as an if you do wake it up, here's the stats, we'll still be giving you Ghatanothoa, Chaugnar Faugn, Rhan-Tegoth, or Yig. Mhar, Orgesh and Xhamen-Dor can easily be worked into the adventure, making people search for them, but I doubt they'd have gotten the rights to use those great old ones without making them stats. Chaugnar Faugn is the only one of those mentioned that are listed in the front page's Product Identity, so he's a likely candidate for one of the last two. i wouldn't mind seeing a double-sized bestiary to work the rest of them in, since, with four of the great old ones from the pulps being left, they'd have to put two in the last two, or three in the very last one. I hope they stat all of them, personally, Cthulhu and Hastur were getting lonely being the only CR 29 and Cr 30 aberrations
or, it could be like how they give stats for the Spawn of rovagug in the adventure as an if you do wake it up, here's the stats, we'll still be giving you Ghatanothoa, Chaugnar Faugn, Rhan-Tegoth, or Yig. Mhar, Orgesh and Xhamen-Dor can easily be worked into the adventure, making people search for them, but I doubt they'd have gotten the rights to use those great old ones without making them stats. Chaugnar Faugn is the only one of those mentioned that are listed in the front page's Product Identity, so he's a likely candidate for one of the last two. i wouldn't mind seeing a double-sized bestiary to work the rest of them in, since, with four of the great old ones from the pulps being left, they'd have to put two in the last two, or three in the very last one. I hope they stat all of them, personally, Cthulhu and Hastur were getting lonely being the only CR 29 and Cr 30 aberrations
The final adventure (Black Stars Beckon) only has a single support article, and that's the Continuing the Campaign one. It stands to reason that its Bestiary could also be a few pages longer to accommodate additional GOOs.
The final adventure (Black Stars Beckon) only has a single support article, and that's the Continuing the Campaign one. It stands to reason that its Bestiary could also be a few pages longer to accommodate additional GOOs.
We don't have a final description of Black Stars Beckon, but right now it also includes "a history of Golarion."
The final adventure (Black Stars Beckon) only has a single support article, and that's the Continuing the Campaign one. It stands to reason that its Bestiary could also be a few pages longer to accommodate additional GOOs.
Yak. Why would there be goo in this one? sorry, couldn't resist
The final adventure (Black Stars Beckon) only has a single support article, and that's the Continuing the Campaign one. It stands to reason that its Bestiary could also be a few pages longer to accommodate additional GOOs.
We don't have a final description of Black Stars Beckon, but right now it also includes "a history of Golarion."
I remember reading somewhere that James Jacobs said that the "History of Golarion" article got cut, but that could have changed.
Also i don´t think we get more than one GOO per Bestiary, because all the other ones by HPL or Paizo can still be in Bestiary 6 or 7 or inserted when needed.
Xhamen-Dor could be in the NPC Gallery or the adventure itself OR in the Bestiary of book 5, but book 6 will most likely only have Chaugnar Faugn.
The history article did indeed get cut. It wasn't the right place to do an article like that, honestly, and the Continuing the Campaign article has some good stuff that we got to get into as a result of having more room.
There's only one Great Old One in this one, like all the rest.
Chaugnar-Faugn isn't out of question, but he was illustrated in the first book of the AP. If I'm not mistaken, it was said that "not getting an illustration" was a hint about the Great Old Ones that would be stated in the AP.
So, while I'm not sure if this is still a thing, I'm guessing that the last Great Old One to be stated will be either Ghatanothoa or Orgesh.
I'm new to subscriptions and saw that this book dropped off the radar on my Subscriptions page, January isn't in the upcoming section and book 5 isn't the most recent or next at the bottom. Not really worried but just curious if this is normal and what people know about why it happens?