Why is Summon Elemental a 2nd level spell and Summon Celestial / Dragon / Entity / Fiend / Giant a 5th level spell?


Rules Discussion


Honestly this makes no sense to me, other than there aren't any monsters of those types at a lower level. But that's not true when the lowest level dragon in the bestiary is a fairy dragon which is level 2, well within the grasp of a 3rd level Summon Animal/Construct/Fey/Plant spell (if it wasn't a dragon).

I kind of want this for some lower-level cultists, to be able to summon really low-level aberrations or the like, but RAW I can't. I just want to know if there was a specific reason why this is the case. It just seems odd to me. I mean, a level -1 Giant also seems odd, but whatever.

(Since I'm the GM in my home games, I can change whatever. It is also house ruled that all the Summon * spells work like Summon Animal, but for the given creature type. But this isn't going to help my mildly-crazy occult sorcerer who likes to summon ABERRATIONS when she can only summon FEY in Society play. ugh...)


If I had to guess, I'd say this isn't much more than a flavor decision.

Summoning an animal simply sounds like a lower level thing to do, regardless of the CR of the summoned creature. Summoning an elemental might sound like a step up.

But summoning a dragon at lvl 1 is, well... even if just happened to be a CR -1 dragon somehow, that's still a pretty epic thing to do. Perhaps too epic for a lvl 1 character.

That's all just speculation. I don't think it will unbalance anything if you house-rule those spells as lvl 1 spells and follow normal rules for heightening as Summon Animal. That is... assuming any homebrewed stat blocks you come up with for lower CR creatures of that type aren't broken.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder Second Edition / Rules Discussion / Why is Summon Elemental a 2nd level spell and Summon Celestial / Dragon / Entity / Fiend / Giant a 5th level spell? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.