
Cyrad RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 16 |

The race is more powerful than a human, which is already considered one of the strongest races in the game. A human gets +2 to one score, a bonus feat, and 1 skill point per level. This race gets a +2 to TWO scores, a bonux feat, scent, a natural attack, and more. I also don't think you used the race builder correctly.
There's no such thing as the "canine subtype."
I like how orcs revere them as animal spirits. When I see anthropomorphic race lore, I usually see discrimination as the cliche trope. So, this was a welcome change of pace.

Azten |

I agree that it's a bit much. Now, a +2 to Constitution and then another +2 and maybe a -2 based on fur color could be interesting. I'd suggest taking a look at the Skinwalker race Paizo made for examples of one race having really different subtypes.
There's no such thing as the "canine subtype."
Before a new race is introduced, it's subtype doesn't exist. There was no "strix" subtype before the Strix, for example.
I would change it to humanoid(garou) though.

Cyrad RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 16 |

Cyrad wrote:There's no such thing as the "canine subtype."Before a new race is introduced, it's subtype doesn't exist. There was no "strix" subtype before the Strix, for example.
I would change it to humanoid(garou) though.
I'm more implying that dogs, wolves, etc don't have the canine subtype and neither should this race. As per the race builder guidelines, all humanoids need a subtype that should be either the race's name or an existing subtype.

EltonJ |

I agree that it's a bit much. Now, a +2 to Constitution and then another +2 and maybe a -2 based on fur color could be interesting. I'd suggest taking a look at the Skinwalker race Paizo made for examples of one race having really different subtypes.
Cyrad wrote:There's no such thing as the "canine subtype."Before a new race is introduced, it's subtype doesn't exist. There was no "strix" subtype before the Strix, for example.
I would change it to humanoid(garou) though.
It was hard to decide how to give them a -2 in anything. If it actually exists somewhere in the Universe, the race thinks of itself as the expression of what it is to be human. And if the race actually exists, its the source of our werewolf legends. How about +2 Constitution, +2 Wisdom, -2 Charisma?
Yes it would be interesting to do subtypes. But I won't do it. The reason is, it gives a justification for racism. There are 4 human subtypes: white, brown, black, and yellow. And you can divide us further into 12, and then there are about 130 different ethnic groups. Should we divide humans into sub-races? I think it won't be wise if I did it here. :)

Cyrad RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 16 |

Looks much better now.
Yes it would be interesting to do subtypes. But I won't do it. The reason is, it gives a justification for racism. There are 4 human subtypes: white, brown, black, and yellow. And you can divide us further into 12, and then there are about 130 different ethnic groups. Should we divide humans into sub-races? I think it won't be wise if I did it here. :)
I don't understand what you're arguing here. Races in D&D/PF are not comparable with real world race issues. Dwarves and elves are completely different species -- especially elves in Pathfinder, which are aliens from another planet. A subtype is not an ethnicity. It's a game mechanic. All humanoids should have a subtype. By default, they have a subtype that matches the name of the race.

EltonJ |

Looks much better now.EltonJ wrote:Yes it would be interesting to do subtypes. But I won't do it. The reason is, it gives a justification for racism. There are 4 human subtypes: white, brown, black, and yellow. And you can divide us further into 12, and then there are about 130 different ethnic groups. Should we divide humans into sub-races? I think it won't be wise if I did it here. :)I don't understand what you're arguing here. Races in D&D/PF are not comparable with real world race issues. Dwarves and elves are completely different species -- especially elves in Pathfinder, which are aliens from another planet. A subtype is not an ethnicity. It's a game mechanic. All humanoids should have a subtype. By default, they have a subtype that matches the name of the race.
I . . .
hmm . . .
What you are asking might be best be put into an expansion. Possibly a whole race book. I'll think about it and draw something up for Friday, after my move. :)

Alric Rahl |
Unfortunately half of Social Hunters doesnt really fit with the -2 to their charisma. is there an Intimidate and Survival class skill RP choice. if So go with that or maybe give them a straight up bonus to survival RP selection instead.
I think leaving the feat in was honestly fine. if you really think about it. Humans get a bite attack too, well all races get one, its just not natural so thats out.
Scent is situational and those situations dont come up often so while its good Role Play flavor its not really a great enhancement to "this race is better".
Since you have a -2 countering your second +2 then its ability scores is equal to humans and might actually be worse since we dont get to choose which one the +2 applies too.
Low Light vision isnt all that great since you can have Light cast on objects and toss them out, low light also gets thrown out in most dungeons because of hanging lanterns and torches, etc. Only Darkvision is really a great Racial Trait.
+10ft speed on a charge is cool, but situational and a couple of classes get that and better anyway, so again not really a powerful choice when determining Race.
So what do we have left after we take those not powerful racial traits out.
Social Hunters: extra class skills can be good
+2 to Con
This makes the class seem lacking and I feel that if you put the bonus feat back in would balance it back out. It would also bring it back to 13RP which as Jonathan Wilder said is a good number to shoot for.
most of the race features you gave this race are situational and can be negated or done by better by other means.
In conclusion. Put the feat back in and I think you got yourself an awesome race.
just curious do they have humanoid legs? where the knee bends at the front or wolf legs where it bends at the back?

Cyrad RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 16 |

Cyrad wrote:Looks much better now.EltonJ wrote:Yes it would be interesting to do subtypes. But I won't do it. The reason is, it gives a justification for racism. There are 4 human subtypes: white, brown, black, and yellow. And you can divide us further into 12, and then there are about 130 different ethnic groups. Should we divide humans into sub-races? I think it won't be wise if I did it here. :)I don't understand what you're arguing here. Races in D&D/PF are not comparable with real world race issues. Dwarves and elves are completely different species -- especially elves in Pathfinder, which are aliens from another planet. A subtype is not an ethnicity. It's a game mechanic. All humanoids should have a subtype. By default, they have a subtype that matches the name of the race.I . . .
hmm . . .
What you are asking might be best be put into an expansion. Possibly a whole race book. I'll think about it and draw something up for Friday, after my move. :)
I'm not asking anything.

EltonJ |

just curious do they have humanoid legs? where the knee bends at the front or wolf legs where it bends at the back?
They are plantigrade (heel and toe strike the ground), as opposed to digitgrade (toe strikes the ground only). The second "knee" is actually the heel. A lot of people say digitgrade is better, but if evolution is giving sapient races a plantigrade foot most every time, then there has to be some kind of an advantage.
I think that most plantigrade races, including humans, are endurance runners the plantigrade foot shows its advantage in how it's used in endurance running. Unlike other, certain, animals -- the human being is built for endurance running and not for endurance walking. I'm expecting that the Garou are endurance runners. As for digitgrade, it's used for sprinting. Sprinters need digitgrade feet so that they can sprint at high speed.
However, an Endurance Hunter can run for far longer than sprinting prey. The video explains it better than I could.