| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
By the rules, an armour must have at least a +1 before any other magical properties may be added.
So every ghost touch armour should be at least +1.
(I tend to ignore this rule, and it's weapon version, in my games, but that's why it assumes the armour will have an enhancement bonus)
"Both its enhancement bonus and its armor bonus count against the attacks of corporeal and incorporeal creatures." Seems to count only when a corporeal creature wears it, so your ghost would only get the enhancement bonus to AC. As for the Ghost Touch weapon property, it simply negates the incorporeal 50% miss chance. In a ghost's hands it would deal regular weapon attacks against corporeal foes, and against other ghosts would ignore the 50% miss chance. The weapon affects incorporeal foes as if they were corporeal, and allows incorporeal creatures to hit corporeally while still being able to pass through objects.
Also: In complete agreement that the rule that you need at least a +1 before enchanting with properties sucks balls. I usually ignore it as a rule and use the total enhancement bonus for determinations.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
"As for the Ghost Touch weapon property, it simply negates the incorporeal 50% miss chance"
There is no 50% miss chance for weapons in Pathfinder - it's a 50% damage reduction.
Ah, sorry about that, I meant the 50% damage reduction don't know why I typed miss chance. Anyway, it states that it acts as both corporeal and incorporeal, but by your reasoning wouldn't a corporeal creature using it on another corporeal creature use it as a touch attack? No. It treats incorporeal creatures as corporeal for attacks and allows incorporeal creatures to wield/wear corporeal objects (which normally they can't affect at all, their touch attacks aren't physically affecting corporeal bodies, its a negative energy effect) That is what it meant when they stated it is both incorporeal and corporeal.
If the armor can be worn by both, and both it's enhancement and armor bonus count against both attacks, why wouldn't the ghost get the armor bonus as well as the enhancement bonus?
It's possible that they mean that it doesn't get the armor bonus because the armor becomes more incorporeal when worn by a ghost so the ghost can still pass through solid objects.
Then again, the RAW is ambiguous. "Both its enhancement bonus and its armor bonus count against the attacks of corporeal and incorporeal creatures." It never actually says "incorporeals don't get the armor bonus" (just that they do get the enhancement bonus) so a GM could justifiably allow a ghost to get the full benefit.
The ghost touch weapon can count as "both corporeal or incorporeal". That is bad grammar - you say "both .. and ..." or "either ... or ..." which adds to my suspicion that these entries weren't proof-read carefully enough.
I'm pretty sure when a ghost attacks a human with it, it's supposed to count as corporeal, since if incorporeal it wouldn't cause damage. (Although I can imagine an incorporeal magic sword that does 50% damage to humans and 100% damage to ghosts, but can't be held by a human...)
I agree that the wording is ambiguous, but let me try one more time.
A Ghost Touch weapon basically becomes "solid" to what ever it hits. Thus a human can hit a ghost, and a ghost can pass through a wall and stab a human. Ghost Touch armor/shields are less useful. They are "solid" to incorporeal creatures when corporeal creatures wear them because that is the point of their magic, however when ghosts use that magic to transform the physical armor itself incorporeal, the armor can't be solid and have a ghost wear it and all you get is the enhancement bonus. An armor bonus is the armors physical capacity to turn aside or blunt blows, if the armor counted as solid against corporeal foes then that means the ghost wearing it couldn't go through walls and it would be able to be hit/have its armor broken, and that would make it completely detrimental for them to wear it. Its the same reason why incorporeal creatures can't have NAT AC, they have little to no physical presence by their very nature. I would rule that a Ghost Touch armors' armor bonus applies against ghost touch weapons for incorporeal creatures though, so there is still a reason for them to wear it. And you are right, Ghost touch armor was not designed for ghosts, it was designed to fight them. I would tend to think of their properties when wielded by ghosts as accidental and that most magic arms/armor creators would look at them as being unavoidable side affects considering they just weaponized a vengeful ghost if the person buying the ghost touch items gets killed.
Actually, given that last part I'm a little surprised they don't cost more as thematically, I wouldn't want to sell you ghost touch items, have you get killed, then have an angry ghost running around wearing my ghost touch items chasing me or other people....
In theory, doesn't mean you don't have weak magey wrists incapable of lifting said ghost touch weapons.
I think there may be confusion at the term "enhancement bonus".
My interpretation is only opinion, yet this is how I view it -
Let us say there was a +1, ghost touch chain shirt. This is a total of +5 armor bonus (+4 chain shirt, +1 magic enhancement) - lets not complicate the item cost by factoring the ghost touch property.
If a ghost wore it, they would gain +5 AC bonus against tangible people and other ghosts alike. They can still pass through walls and the like, the magic armor protects the ghost in some spiritual / magical fashion as it would have when it was alive and corporeal. Weird, yet turnabout is fair play and enough ghosts have had armor with a full armor bonus to support this view in past published adventures.
If a person wore it, the +5 AC bonus would apply as an armor bonus against other people. The +5 AC would suddenly apply to a ghost's touch attack as well - hence the odd phrasing because touch attacks normally ignore armor, shield, and natural armor AC bonuses. The ghost touch item was meant to be an exception to this in the case of incorporeal touch attacks. It offers no additional protection from rays, firearms, spells, or any other corporeal attack that use touch attacks (much like force effects that help prevent incorporeal attacks, like mage armor).
The enhancement bonus on magical armor and weapons is the +1, it does not include the price for the bonus used for the ghost touch property or the armor bonus. So this means the ghost would only get the +1 to AC. Unless you are like myself and Scythia and homerule that you don't require at least a +1 bonus before you enchant, in which case you count the ghost touch property (+3 cost) then the ghost would get +4. The Ghost Touch armor property was not made to make ghosts tougher, it was designed to make it easier for players to fight them. In the case of an incorporeal creature it is usually easier just to use Mage Armor (armor bonus, wouldn't stack with the chain shirt anyway) or a ring of protection (deflection bonus to AC). Though if I remember correctly, incorporeal creatures get a Deflection Bonus to AC from their Charisma modifier, so Ring of Prot. might not work either.
If you feel that way then go with it. Ultimately the rule above all is "The GM said so."
I always use the Story Trumps Rules dynamic: if it makes the story better and you want to use it, do so.
I have a confusion with Ghost Touched armor, weapons (or anything) and ghosts in general. While Ghost Touched weapons can be used by incorporeal creatures, incorporeal creatures have no strength score - so how can they pick it up? If they get to ignore that have no strength score, can a ghost throw a giant's boulder that has been "ghost touched"?
It is an unresolved flaw that could use much clearer language.
If they get to ignore that have no strength score, can a ghost throw a giant's boulder that has been "ghost touched"?
It is an unresolved flaw that could use much clearer language.
There aren't any rules to cover this, so it comes down to: Ask your GM to make a reasonable ruling for a very edge case scenario.
(Though now I want to make an encounter with giant ghosts throwing ghost touched rocks).