Petty, could you link the new list?
Petty, could you link the new list?
You can find it here:
Ok I created a new sheet because I don't know if I can set permissions on separate sheets.
I am going to guess 219 items post-cull
Thank you, Ms. Sullivan! The bonus is: I saw mine on said list very, very quickly.
OK, I didn't think my item would have been culled but I was still a little anxious nonetheless. I did see it on the post culled list.
Ok! now I get the most brilliant idea for a weapon, always next year!
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
OK, I didn't think my item would have been culled but I was still a little anxious nonetheless. I did see it on the post culled list.
I've seen it
Sweet that armor made it.
Now I've got a mental image of my alchemist while the other PCs stand around chanting "Chug! Chug! Chug! Chug!"
Dear would be designer, is there a particular reason why you haven't used existing weapon properties instead reinventing them for your item? Is the slight difference in damage inflicted sufficient reason for this? (which would be otherwise decent homebrew item)
Insect-themed item vs insect themed item... Coincidence?
Oh yay! My item is on the post-cull list! :D Still haven't seen it in the wild, but I still have quite a few voting days ahead of me.
Insect-themed item vs insect themed item... Coincidence?
Inevitability. Just got soul-eater vs. soul-eater. Now I get to decide which one did it better.
My item seems to have persevered as well!
It's nice to know I made the cull, but it's even nicer to have good pairs to vote on!
I don't generally vote for cthulhu-y stuff, but that one item does it well, so I gotta.
Yeah, made it!
And I immediately started to see new items, which is a nice plus.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Disarming shield VS Disarming shield
Who has the better grasp of making one of these?
Seen my first 100 unique items post cull...
Interesting for me is...
a) 7 brand spanking new unique items not seen pre cull before :)
b) The other 93 are all items I have upvoted previously at least once.
So I'm batting well this year with my voting choices ;)
Most rods are kinda eh. But this one rod that reminds me of a very classic rod...
Insect-themed item vs insect themed item... Coincidence?
My favorite insect one would eat the others :)
Most rods are kinda eh. But this one rod that reminds me of a very classic rod...
That seems to be a fan favorite this year, this thread is littered with positive references to it. Personally I like it, but I don't love it.
That cull was so needed. Thanks Paizo staff!
Why not just go whole hog and do a bone spear too while you're at it?
Looks like my item cleared the cull. Feeling a bit more optimistic now.
The cull definitely helped raise the quality of matchups. And I saw my item, so I'm pretty ecstatic about continuing on, especially since it was on my 6th vote.
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
18 of the 25 items on my Keep list have shown up in the post-cull list so far. Good job to all of you fantastic designers! I obviously wasn't the only one you impressed.
RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32
,
Champion Voter Season 6, Champion Voter Season 7, Champion Voter Season 8, Champion Voter Season 9
|
18 of the 25 items on my Keep list have shown up in the post-cull list so far. Good job to all of you fantastic designers! I obviously wasn't the only one you impressed.
28/32 so far. Hoping the post cull list grows and more from my keep list make it.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I still don't see one of my favorites, which bums me out. I wasn't sure how well it would do overall, though I've seen it on at least one other shared list.
Whew.
Still alive post cull!
Congrats to everyone else who has seen their item.
Hold out hope if you havent!
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
First RPG Superstar entry and I made it past the cull! Nice.
Anyone know what percentage they culled this year? In past years it was the bottom 25%, but currently less than 50% of all recorded items seen pre cull have been seen (and recorded) since. They are still trickling in with 348 currently, but if there are about 600 items still in the pool, you would think they would be coming faster until we get closer to 600. Did they cut 50% this year?
Marathon Voter Season 8, Marathon Voter Season 9
|
Anyone know what percentage they culled this year? In past years it was the bottom 25%, but currently less than 50% of all recorded items seen pre cull have been seen (and recorded) since. They are still trickling in with 348 currently, but if there are about 600 items still in the pool, you would think they would be coming faster until we get closer to 600. Did they cut 50% this year?
I've math-ed it out to 43% of items passing the cull so far.
A new item! And one that could interact with my item in some very confusing ways! Heh.
Yay! That staff is still around!
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Still alive!
This ring is so thematically awesome and mechanically interesting, but displays zero knowledge of pricing mechanics.
Still, its better than the ring it opposes.
Anyone know what percentage they culled this year? In past years it was the bottom 25%, but currently less than 50% of all recorded items seen pre cull have been seen (and recorded) since. They are still trickling in with 348 currently, but if there are about 600 items still in the pool, you would think they would be coming faster until we get closer to 600. Did they cut 50% this year?I've math-ed it out to 43% of items passing the cull so far.
Brigg, you just made my day... becuase I just saw my Item for the first time! It made it past the first cull.
I am so very happy!
Post-cull status, baby! Oh, yeah!