Another HIPS question

[Diskordant]

PRD wrote:

Hide in Plain Sight (Su) : A shadowdancer can use the Stealth skill even while being observed. As long as she is within 10 feet of an area of dim light, a shadowdancer can hide herself from view in the open without anything to actually hide behind. She cannot, however, hide in her own shadow.

Me: if dim light is 10' away from the SD he an HIPS

DM: the SD must be in an area of dim light that is at least 10' large to use HIPS

Who's right?

Also does anyone read this ability as a SD can always stealth while being observed but still needs cover or concealment unless near dim light?

[VRMH]

In my interpretation: you.
In reality: the GM. The GM is always right.

[thejeff]

There is a difference between "within 10 feet of an area of dim light" and "within a 10 foot area of dim light".

I don't see how to get your GM's reading from the text.

Of course, I also think any one can hide within an area of dim light, since it provides concealment, but I tend to favor boosting stealth and other mundane abilities.

Obviously in his game, the GM's word goes. I'd talk to him about it out of game, if you haven't already. At least to get a better idea of what other restrictions you might not be aware of.