The Skinsaw Murders - Burning Down Foxglove Manor


Rise of the Runelords


My players have just finished Burnt Offerings and are going to be moving on to Skinsaw Murders. I think it's very likely that they may, possibly after a room or two, possibly not even that late, try to just burn down Foxglove Manor. What suggestions do you have for the results of this attempt, and/or the XP impact involved? Thanks!


Cole Long 936 wrote:
My players have just finished Burnt Offerings and are going to be moving on to Skinsaw Murders. I think it's very likely that they may, possibly after a room or two, possibly not even that late, try to just burn down Foxglove Manor. What suggestions do you have for the results of this attempt, and/or the XP impact involved? Thanks!

When they try to burn the place, the supernatural forces there say "Nay!"

Paizo Employee Director of Brand Strategy

Spoiler:
The guy they really need to get there is in the caves beneath, so they can burn down the mansion, though they'll miss a level's worth of XP with all the haunts. You could even have Iesha survive and come running out of the house at them as she tries to get to the well to get to the caves. I'd rule, however, that Vorel's power keeps the fire from doing anything, though it can be explained to the players as the wood being damp and mildewy, covered in slimy mold, and just unresponsive to even the most pyrotechnic of attempts to light it aflame. Consider that Aldern's mother tried to burn the place down too, and that Vorel's spirit possessed his father to push her to her death out the second story window.


Pathfinder Maps Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Starfinder Charter Superscriber

My players tried that approach too. Well, one of the players. I had the supernatural effect have something happen each time she tried to burn the place down, as well as something happen, an eerie effect, when she started talking about it.

To add some emphasis to it, she had a lot more of the haunts affect her than normally would have, especially any that had anything to do with fire.

It played well with the "feel" for the place.


The best way to set fire to a place is inside it. Your fire is sheltered from the windy cliffs. And once it catches, it burns exterior and interior walls.

Plus, don't you have a murder of crows or two to deal with?


wspatterson wrote:
When they try to burn the place, the supernatural forces there say "Nay!"

It's an option, but having the house magically unburnable will start to feel forced. Half of the wooden structures in Burnt Offerings were unburnable per the module already. I'm all for it being *hard* and I'd love for suggestions for good mechanical approaches to make it hard.

yoda8myhead wrote:
The guy they really need to get there is in the caves beneath, so they can burn down the mansion, though they'll miss a level's worth of XP with all the haunts.

The fact that they have to go into the cave anyway to catch the Skinsaw man is what lets me think that maybe they ought to be able to get away with at least partial success in burning.

yoda8myhead wrote:
though they'll miss a level's worth of XP with all the haunts.

I'm trying to think of a reasonable ad hoc XP award if they do so. Just permanently being a level behind (and they've already got a lot of sidequests around just to keep them caught up and give them half a chance later on) and therefore getting killed due to burning down an evil house doesn't seem right. If the house were full of orcs and they died, or even fled out and were killed outside their lair, they wouldn't just miss a level of XP.

Maybe a "burned out" haunt could be "ejected" as a weak incorporeal undead.

yoda8myhead wrote:
You could even have Iesha survive and come running out of the house at them as she tries to get to the well to get to the caves.

She's a revenant, so I'm sure she will survive.

yoda8myhead wrote:
Consider that Aldern's mother tried to burn the place down too, and that Vorel's spirit possessed his father to push her to her death out the second story window.

I'd rather implement something in keeping with the house's history than saying it just won't burn. At the least, it's part of an issue of keeping the players in the scene versus thinking "does the module just say it won't burn?" Ideas?

Mistwalker wrote:
I had the supernatural effect have something happen each time she tried to burn the place down, as well as something happen, an eerie effect, when she started talking about it.

What kind of effects did you use?

roguerouge wrote:

The best way to set fire to a place is inside it. Your fire is sheltered from the windy cliffs. And once it catches, it burns exterior and interior walls.

Plus, don't you have a murder of crows or two to deal with?

That's they way they tend to think. And yes, yes they do.

Thanks guys!

Paizo Employee Director of Brand Strategy

Cole Long 936 wrote:
yoda8myhead wrote:
Consider that Aldern's mother tried to burn the place down too, and that Vorel's spirit possessed his father to push her to her death out the second story window.
I'd rather implement something in keeping with the house's history than saying it just won't burn. At the least, it's part of an issue of keeping the players in the scene versus thinking "does the module just say it won't burn?" Ideas?...

You could design your own haunt which would possess whichever PC tries to burn it down so that they think they're Cyralie. Then another PC should think that they're Traver and attack the pyro with the intent of killing them. I'd make the will save pretty high on this one (meaning the haunt would be a higher CR) since it would represent the manor's survival instinct. If they succeed, the higher CR of these haunts will make up for some of the lost haunts they didn't encounter, and if they fail, the haunts that prevented them from setting it alight fit right in with the history of the house. If they do burn it down, you might have to slip them all the exposition that the haunts provide unless you have players who don't care about these sorts of things. (I figure you might, since they would burn down a house with so many answers contained within.) Best of luck.

Paizo Employee CEO

My group thought about burning it down, but decided not to because they figured that there was a bunch of good treasure in a rich guy's house, and they didn't want to lose that. Also, I had it pouring rain by the time they made it to Foxglove Manor. I mean pouring. I also described the wood of the house as very wet and anybody who has made a campfire with wet wood knows that it is an uphill battle. So they went through the house normally, however, they plan to come back sometime later in the campaign and burn the place to the ground when the weather is better and they have access to more powerful magical fire spells.

-Lisa


Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Charter Superscriber

Both the dampness and the supernatural nature of the Manor should preclude burning it down. At most, I would say some scorch marks that eventually dissapear after 24 hours.

If they ask for advice from the Sheriff or someone like that I would suggest that he, or whomever, mention that we are talking about a noble's property.

Not to mention, there could be evidence anywhere in the Manor, at least as far as the PCs know.

Have fun!

Paizo Employee Creative Director

When we create adventures, we generally assume that players want to go on the adventures, not destroy them. If we have an adventure where you have to board a pirate ship and rescue a captive, we assume the PCs won't just sink the ship, then pay to have the drowned captive resurrected. Likewise, when we present a haunted house, we assume that "burning down the house" isn't something most parties will do.

Of course, there's always exceptions. Even if burning down the house or sinking the ship is a terrible idea since it'd destroy clues, resources, and allies.

In any case, having the PCs arrive at the scene during a rainstorm is a great solution, and not only because it discourages fire. It's a great solution because it REALLY adds to the atmosphere of the adventure.

If your PCs are hellbent on burning the manor down, though, and if they STILL are when they're reminded that arson is a crime or that if they clear the manor it could make for a cool hideout or headquarters, the best solution is...

Spoiler:
... to turn to the timeline on page 23 for inspiration. In 4693 AR, Cyralie tried to burn the house down. She got the servants' quarters fine, but the house itself is protected by Vorel's infusion of the structure. In her case, the spirit stopped her by forcing Taver to murder her. It's not good gameplay to do the same to PCs by having Vorel possess another PC... but what you CAN do is say that the fire spring up and starts to burn, but suddenly the flames coalesce into their own entity, transforming into a towering humanoid form. This is Vorel's spirit taking control of the fire; he uses it to attack the PCs. You can treat this manifestation of Vorel's spirit as a Large fire elemental, and as the PCs defeat it it shrieks in rage and spirals up into a vortex that then races through the house, leaving scorch marks in its wake and eventually leading down to the cellar and into the caves below. The PCs can then follow the scorching trail left behind to find out where the spirit went... if THAT doesn't lure them in... then maybe you should just let them burn the house down next time (or perhaps throw a HUGE elemental at them next time). Even with the house burnt down, unless they go on to slay Foxglove, the murders in Sandpoint will just continue... and if you're REALLY into the eerie supernatural stuff, when the PCs return to the manor later, they can find it completely restored as if their fire had never been started.


When I ran it

Spoiler:
they killed Aldren but the house was still possessed. They burned it down with a good riddance and basked in the roaring flames. When they came back from the next adventure ghouls were still haunting the area around the manor. Sandpoint friends was wondering why they told everyone they burned it down while it was still there. They go back and sure enough it stands defiantly. Took quite a creepy battle with the now more powerful haunts to make there way down to the basement. There they was able to battle there way past ghoul ogres to destroy the fungus.
Then I let them burn it down for good.

Dark Archive

James Jacobs wrote:
When we create adventures, we generally assume that players want to go on the adventures, not destroy them. If we have an adventure where you have to board a pirate ship and rescue a captive, we assume the PCs won't just sink the ship, then pay to have the drowned captive resurrected. Likewise, when we present a haunted house, we assume that "burning down the house" isn't something most parties will do.

Yeah you would think that...until you game with a couple guys in my group. :)

Dark Archive

Cole Long 936 wrote:
My players have just finished Burnt Offerings and are going to be moving on to Skinsaw Murders. I think it's very likely that they may, possibly after a room or two, possibly not even that late, try to just burn down Foxglove Manor. What suggestions do you have for the results of this attempt, and/or the XP impact involved? Thanks!

Maybe do a poltergeist effect. Since V tried to be a lich, the house is its "body" so to speak and until the PCs burn his "phlactery" the house will burn and then re-create itself...


The Fire Elemental Idea is bad ass I think there is a corupted elemental template somewhere that I will make sure I have on the elemenetal if they try to burn it down


James Jacobs wrote:
If your PCs are hellbent on burning the manor down, though, and if they STILL are when they're reminded that arson is a crime or that if they clear the manor it could make for a cool hideout or headquarters, the best solution is... [spoiler]... to turn to the timeline on page 23 for inspiration. In 4693 AR, Cyralie tried to burn the house down. She got the servants' quarters fine, but the house itself is protected by Vorel's infusion of the structure. In her case, the spirit stopped her by forcing Taver to murder her. It's not good gameplay to do the same to PCs by having Vorel possess another PC... but what you CAN do is say that the fire spring up and starts to burn, but suddenly the flames coalesce into their own entity, transforming into a towering humanoid form. This is Vorel's spirit taking control of the fire; he uses it to attack the PCs. You can treat this manifestation of Vorel's spirit as a Large fire elemental, and as the PCs defeat it it shrieks in rage and spirals up into a vortex that then races through the house, leaving scorch marks in its wake and eventually leading down to the cellar and into the caves below. The PCs can then follow the scorching trail left behind to find out where the spirit went... if THAT doesn't lure them...

I really like the Fire Elemental idea. Does anyone know if the old Ravenloft "Funeral Pyre Elemental" has been updated to OGL stats?

Sovereign Court RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16, 2011 Top 32

My players set fire to one room, then went to the basement to confront the final scene. As they were leaving they heard the sounds of sawing and hammering. Let them burn it down. And then let it rise up again. That'll REALLY freak them out!

Paizo Employee Creative Director

Cole Long 936 wrote:
I really like the Fire Elemental idea. Does anyone know if the old Ravenloft "Funeral Pyre Elemental" has been updated to OGL stats?

I know that there's a demonically-infused elemental template that we ran in Dragon; I believe it got put into the Dragon Compendium. Alternatively, there's always Green Ronin's Advanced Bestiary, if you have access to it; plenty of templates there that'd work. And if you only have the SRD, you can even just slap the ghost template on the fire elemental and let it loose.


Cole Long 936 wrote:
I really like the Fire Elemental idea. Does anyone know if the old Ravenloft "Funeral Pyre Elemental" has been updated to OGL stats?

If you have access to it, the 3.5 version of the Pyre Elemental can be found in Ravenloft: Denizens of Dread, by White Wolf/Arthaus's Sword & Sorcery line. There is also a 3.0 version in their Denizens of Darkness. Both books are out of print now, but still available from various places (e.g., Amazon).

Sovereign Court

Heroes of Horror (I think) has a necromental template. You can see it here: http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=dnd/iw/20041015b&page=3

Sovereign Court

Hehe, I was a player in this particular adventure path. During the process of clearing foxglove manor we had one player die because he decided to grabble the revenant on the second floor >.> After finishing the clearing out of Foxglove manor we resolved to burn the place to the ground however, something prevented anything from taking flame in the manor. We decided at that moment that if we couldn't destroy it with fire instead, we would return at a later date once we had learned the earthquake spell and knock the entire cliffside into the ocean. We did so with a scroll of Earthquake much much much later.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder Adventure Path / Rise of the Runelords / The Skinsaw Murders - Burning Down Foxglove Manor All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rise of the Runelords