I'm a bit torn on this one myself. While I like the classic nature of a medusa, I always kind of think of them as reclusive loners. After all, its hard to lead an army when they can't really look at you. Both of your previous entries kind of grew on me over time so I hope this one does too. With a few tweeks I could see using any of your entries in a campaign. I hope you make it to the next round so we can see what else you've got. Maybe if she was a yuan-ti...
Very imaginative, but I share the same beef Alex Handley expressed. The scale of things are way off. Occupying not only the tops of the towers, but the mined innards would be more 'believable' in scale. How do you fit 20,000+ in a 300' diameter? Stringing a few pillars together with some sort of bridges may also have been a possibility.
I agree with Raymond - "steak no sizzle"
Very flowery indeed, but I think if you've only got 1000 words to describe an entire country, its history, and inhabitants and make it interesting then using flowery descpription-names is appropriate. It gets the point across quickly without using a lot of words. It really does read like the back of a book cover.
This was only the second entry I read, but it has me excited me enough to read the rest of them. First blush I really like this one. I can see taking elements of it and dropping them into almost any campaign which is always a plus. Must me that Dungeon submittal background Erik mentioned that taught you this. It is a little Dark Sunnish, with the heavy druidic influence, slave-like population, and weather control aspects, but it's different enough to probably get my vote.
I'm still trying to figure out what a goblin has to do with a Listen check skill(they only have +2) or a silence spell (okay they do have +5 to moving silently). Wouldn't some other sneaky creature or one with exceptional hearing make more sense? Kind of like the old days when you wanted to create a magic item you had to hunt down components to create them that actually made sense rather than just casting a few spells on something. |