
Alistair, the Dark Alchemist |

I do have one question that may skew the small amount of character creation I have yet to do. Will you allow me to use the spontaneous alchemy rules from the alchemy manual? I most likely won't even be using the combat crafting abilities, I just think it's a little unfair that it takes me almost 3 days to craft an Alchemist's Fire.

![]() |

I do have one question that may skew the small amount of character creation I have yet to do. Will you allow me to use the spontaneous alchemy rules from the alchemy manual? I most likely won't even be using the combat crafting abilities, I just think it's a little unfair that it takes me almost 3 days to craft an Alchemist's Fire.
Actually I thought about the crafting rules so here is the changes I am thinking about implanting.
If your trained [ie have a rank] in a craft skill you generate gp instead of sp. if your untrained or you fail you generate 1 step down fail by 5 2 steps 10 FUBAR[ ex. gp--sp--cp]. So for example if you have 12 ranks a craft skill and you roll a 10 a 22 so you make it in a day. If you get a nat 20 you double the amount and cut the time in half. For every 5 passes the time is cut in half to a min of a hour.
So what do you think?

Alistair, the Dark Alchemist |

So:
Craft Alchemy: 1d20 + 19 ⇒ (5) + 19 = 24 to craft an Alchemists fire
So 24 x 20 = 480
480 / 20(Crafting Price in gold) = 24
So I craft it in 1/24th of a week or a day?
That's 7 hours or 1 hour respectively.
I feel like those are fairly good rules for magical items, but i think alchemy is a little unique. If it's going to take me a even an hour to craft something i can only use once, I don't think I'll be doing much crafting. I mentioned the alchemy manual because it does a good job of differentiating between items. It only takes 10 minutes to craft an alchemists fire but 1 hour to make an acid flask even though the acid has a lower dc. I believe thats a good ruling because no matter how easy it is to make, I think I think the acid would still logically take more time.

Bisag Yegigoth |

Do you have a base of operations? I'd say any good science geek would, and that means you've likely got a stash, or at least a shelf of mixtures waiting on a final catalyst.
Pulling MacGuyver style potion mixing could be very dangerous, even for the well trained, and it's not likely you'll be able to substitute crab grass for major ingredients.
Just my 2 cents.

Alistair, the Dark Alchemist |

Well yes, obviously during downtime I will have an alchemy lab wherever we decide to hang out. My worry is not that I won't have the means to craft when we're away, my worry is that I won't be able to make a few flasks when we make camp, or that I won't have enough flasks to last through our adventures.
That being said, all the flasks I throw are extra on top of what the alchemist can normally put fourth. I just invested a few choices into alchemical weapons, and would like to make as much use out of them as I can.

Bisag Yegigoth |

A flying boat sounds like a great place to have an alchemical lap set up for you to do stuff and things!
As a note, can we all get or link our characters in our character profile so we can all see them? Also, Has anyone seen Silverseabird since he mentioned that he was producing a Skinwalker druid? I didn't actually see his submission though.

Bisag Yegigoth |

What's happening y'all?
Just trying to get a bead on the situation.
Do we have all the players?
Catman, you ready?
Is there anything else we need to know before we play?
Etc.

Bisag Yegigoth |

All else fails, I also have my White Mage/Spellslinger, but I'd rather not be playing 2 characters in 1 game.

Bisag Yegigoth |

sliver, Check your profile, the url link isn't functioning.
its {ulr=[hyperlink here]} Description {/url}
replace {} with []

Alistair, the Dark Alchemist |

I may or may not have gone a little crazy with my inventory, so check it out and see what you think. The size of some of these items is somewhat of a grey area after all. Also, I was wondering if you would allow me to take proficiency in the Flask Thrower as my weapon granted from the grenadier archetype? I purchased it without knowing it was an Exotic, but I have no use for any of the martial weapons, especially after my racial favored weapons.

Niven Steeldrake |

Hybrid weapons are only good for 24 hours. You should probably only prepare a few. Other than that it seems good to me. Most GM's only go with weight for the haversack because calculating volume is a real pain.
I'd allow the flask thrower, as it's an alchemical-themed item, but I'm not the GM. (I also play a grendadier/gun tank in another game)
Edit
Doh, I saw that was burst jar in your 'hybrid'. That should last.

Bisag Yegigoth |

Are we all here and ready to go? What's up?
I should probably get reacquainted with the posting expectations as well. Were we supposed to be doing every day or once a week?
I'd like to get all the details of everything fleshed out so we can get rolling.

Bisag Yegigoth |

Between myself and who?
Honestly I'm more interested in increasing my weapon capabilities than my fists... Which hit like greatswords anyways.

Bisag Yegigoth |

Just waiting on the decision to be made based on my survival check.
Would you guys rather go "interesting" or "Safe"? as it seems like I'm more or less the guide on that one.

Bisag Yegigoth |

Still waiting on GM to decide which way is "interesting"
But I've already presented my responses to the options.

Niven Steeldrake |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |

Okay Catman, if RL is hectic, then say so and say when you expect to get time. But you need to do more. You are our window to the world. If you don't give us feedback and description, then this whole thing doesn't work. Right now, I don't know what is going on, which means you aren't doing your job.
Each person should know where they are in respect to the combat and what the results of their previous action was before we go on.
If you aren't going to take this game seriously, why should we?

Bisag Yegigoth |

so...
It's been more than 2 weeks, just wondering what's going on?
Is this a dead game or just on hold? Please let me know.