Is The Succubus Being Used To Her Full Potential?


Pathfinder First Edition General Discussion


1 person marked this as a favorite.

The succubus is one of the most common demons for parties to face at mid to high levels, and everyone has at least one story about her. But is she just a demon done up in sexy? Should we dig a little bit deeper in order to really bring the fear of losing control into the game? Or do we not push as hard as we can in order to avoid pressing on player's comfort zones?

Whatever your feelings, check out these facts about succubi (and by extension incubi). For instance, did you know the succubus is directly related to Lamashtu (the Middle Eastern goddess, not the Pathfinder one)? That might be a connection more than worth exploring if you want to go down a darker path.


Or you could do something *really* evil and use the Charm Monster SLA, multiple times on the same person. Sound pointless? Well if you want to uncharm someone you'll need to dispel each and every instance of it. And since it's an hour per level spell, in the span of a mere 10 minutes, a succubus can stack 100 instances of Charm Person.

*GM smile*


4 people marked this as a favorite.

If you want to be insanely evil, give the succubus class levels and adjust some stats accordingly.

Everybody expects the manipulator succubus who uses her wiles. Nobody expects the succubus who spams the party with Charm Monster before rushing into melee in a berserker rage.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
MagusJanus wrote:

If you want to be insanely evil, give the succubus class levels and adjust some stats accordingly.

Everybody expects the manipulator succubus who uses her wiles. Nobody expects the succubus who spams the party with Charm Monster before rushing into melee in a berserker rage.

Someone made a reference to Helen of Troy that this reminded me of. The face that launched 1,000 ships... but before she was Helen of Troy she was Helen of Sparta. I actively endorse people giving the succubus a surprise so that parties get shocked out of their comfort zones.


MagusJanus wrote:

If you want to be insanely evil, give the succubus class levels and adjust some stats accordingly.

Everybody expects the manipulator succubus who uses her wiles. Nobody expects the succubus who spams the party with Charm Monster before rushing into melee in a berserker rage.

Shame that tanks the SLA's DCs.


Neal Litherland wrote:


Someone made a reference to Helen of Troy that this reminded me of. The face that launched 1,000 ships... but before she was Helen of Troy she was Helen of Sparta. I actively endorse people giving the succubus a surprise so that parties get shocked out of their comfort zones.

That reminds me...

Q. How many Helen of Troys does it take to launch 1 ship?
A. 1 Milli-Helen.

[ducks]


NGC... that might be my favorite post I've seen today.

Sovereign Court

2 people marked this as a favorite.

Succubus Antipaladin...do it, your players are going to cry foul.

Liberty's Edge

3 people marked this as a favorite.
Ipslore the Red wrote:
MagusJanus wrote:

If you want to be insanely evil, give the succubus class levels and adjust some stats accordingly.

Everybody expects the manipulator succubus who uses her wiles. Nobody expects the succubus who spams the party with Charm Monster before rushing into melee in a berserker rage.

Shame that tanks the SLA's DCs.

Huh?

Giving PC classes gives +4/+4/+2/+2/+0/-2...so four levels of Barbarian can give you a succubus with Str 18 (+1 from leveling, remember) Dex 19 Con 22 Int 18 Wis 12 Cha 31. That's a CR 9 with DC 24-25 on the good stuff. That's still way higher than normal for the CR and 2 higher than a standard succubus.

They won't be using spell-like abilities while Raging, but it's a valid choice.

Sovereign Court

5 people marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Maps, Rulebook, Starfinder Maps, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber

Or build a Succubus Monk Grappler.

Grand Lodge

15 people marked this as a favorite.
Tim Statler wrote:
Or build a Succubus Monk Grappler.

THERE ARE NO BRAKES ON THE TETORI NEGATIVE-LEVEL TRAIN!


2 people marked this as a favorite.

I'm fond of whip wielding Kensai Succubi myself. I mean, Vamperic Touch is just waiting there as a SLA, begging for a spellstrike. Bonus points for looking just like a regular old Succubus.


Deadmanwalking wrote:
Ipslore the Red wrote:
MagusJanus wrote:

If you want to be insanely evil, give the succubus class levels and adjust some stats accordingly.

Everybody expects the manipulator succubus who uses her wiles. Nobody expects the succubus who spams the party with Charm Monster before rushing into melee in a berserker rage.

Shame that tanks the SLA's DCs.

Huh?

Giving PC classes gives +4/+4/+2/+2/+0/-2...so four levels of Barbarian can give you a succubus with Str 18 (+1 from leveling, remember) Dex 19 Con 22 Int 18 Wis 12 Cha 31. That's a CR 9 with DC 24-25 on the good stuff. That's still way higher than normal for the CR and 2 higher than a standard succubus.

They won't be using spell-like abilities while Raging, but it's a valid choice.

Probably referring to this clause of Charm Person:

Quote:
If the creature is currently being threatened or attacked by you or your allies, however, it receives a +5 bonus on its saving throw.


Prince Yyrkoon wrote:
I'm fond of whip wielding Kensai Succubi myself. I mean, Vamperic Touch is just waiting there as a SLA, begging for a spellstrike. Bonus points for looking just like a regular old Succubus.

Unless I'm missing something, only Magus spells can be used on a spell strike, no SLAs.


Weapon Finesse can work pretty well for the succubus. A succubus Anti-Paladin with Shield Slam could also have fun knocking good aligned PCs off of high places.

I wonder what the OP was getting at with the idea of getting outside of people's comfort zones. Are we talking about forcing PCs into actions which might make their players uncomfortable? Most groups have some taboos or sense of decorum, but I'd guess that they probably vary a lot.


Devilkiller wrote:
I wonder what the OP was getting at with the idea of getting outside of people's comfort zones. Are we talking about forcing PCs into actions which might make their players uncomfortable? Most groups have some taboos or sense of decorum, but I'd guess that they probably vary a lot.

I think he's talking about succubus concepts outside of the DnD-standard and more towards other concepts. DnD 5E kinda does this.


The most dangerous thing you can possibly do to any outsider is give them one fighter level and a full plate. At that point they've got AC FAR FAR IN EXCESS of level appropriate.

Liberty's Edge

Undone wrote:
The most dangerous thing you can possibly do to any outsider is give them one fighter level and a full plate. At that point they've got AC FAR FAR IN EXCESS of level appropriate.

Meh. Any succubus can get a +1 Mithral Chain shirt for only slightly more than that (2k vs. 1.5k). Add in the mere +1 Max Dex of Full Plate and that only gives +2 AC over what they can get naturally without the level (AC 25 with the Chain Shirt, AC 27 with the Full Plate).

All you're really saying is 'give them good armor and they get hardcore'. Which is true, but not notably more or less true if you give them Class Levels.


11 people marked this as a favorite.

Does inspiring a 900 post thread count as 'using to full potential'?


9 people marked this as a favorite.

I'd use that succubus to her full potential if you know what I mean.

Liberty's Edge

Undone wrote:
The most dangerous thing you can possibly do to any outsider is give them one fighter level and a full plate. At that point they've got AC FAR FAR IN EXCESS of level appropriate.

Heck, just giving full plate to warriors can be brutal enough. Had a GM one time who had us facing off against warriors with Full Plate and shields at level 1-2. Most of us had to roll a 17+ to hit, even with Bless and flanking.


chaoseffect wrote:
I'd use that succubus to her full potential if you know what I mean.

Who wouldn't?


Chrysanthe Spiros wrote:
chaoseffect wrote:
I'd use that succubus to her full potential if you know what I mean.
Who wouldn't?

Gotta be careful though as they aren't actually immune to disease...

Liberty's Edge

chaoseffect wrote:
Chrysanthe Spiros wrote:
chaoseffect wrote:
I'd use that succubus to her full potential if you know what I mean.
Who wouldn't?
Gotta be careful though as they aren't actually immune to disease...

Pssh, you've got control over/the allegiance of a Succubus, you think you can't afford a Remove Disease or ten? Just use one on her beforehand.


Never underestimate a wizard! ...or a succubus.


3 people marked this as a favorite.
MagusJanus wrote:

If you want to be insanely evil, give the succubus class levels and adjust some stats accordingly.

Everybody expects the manipulator succubus who uses her wiles. Nobody expects the succubus who spams the party with Charm Monster before rushing into melee in a berserker rage.

Wait . . . something seems to be missing here. What you want are INQUISITOR class levels. Nobody expects the Abyssal Inquisition!


They are not really combat creatures with how I see them, but they are good for manipulation. If I were to have one in combat I would more than likely have meat shields with her in the back trying to mind control everyone.

Liberty's Edge

wraithstrike wrote:
They are not really combat creatures with how I see them, but they are good for manipulation. If I were to have one in combat I would more than likely have meat shields with her in the back trying to mind control everyone.

It's pretty clear that this is the Succubus's intended use. Her Save DCs are really absurd for her CR...enough so that she's still a very effective mastermind/leader for a CR 10 or so encounter.

However, that doesn't mean combat class Succubi aren't effective and scary. Racially, she's got +2 Str, +6 Dex, +10 Con, and eight d10 hit dice of Full BAB. That's a pretty solid combat chassis if you toss on some levels of a combat class...which will be at 1/2 CR Increase for at least the first 6. +14 BAB with at least 147 HP is nothing to sneeze at on a CR 10.


Deadmanwalking wrote:
wraithstrike wrote:
They are not really combat creatures with how I see them, but they are good for manipulation. If I were to have one in combat I would more than likely have meat shields with her in the back trying to mind control everyone.

It's pretty clear that this is the Succubus's intended use. Her Save DCs are really absurd for her CR...enough so that she's still a very effective mastermind/leader for a CR 10 or so encounter.

However, that doesn't mean combat class Succubi aren't effective and scary. Racially, she's got +2 Str, +6 Dex, +10 Con, and eight d10 hit dice of Full BAB. That's a pretty solid combat chassis if you toss on some levels of a combat class...which will be at 1/2 CR Increase for at least the first 6. +14 BAB with at least 147 HP is nothing to sneeze at on a CR 10.

Yeah but once you modify a monster it is really something different so I was only speaking of the stock monster.

As an example even throwing breastplate on a humanoid shaped monster can give it incredible AC for its CR.

Liberty's Edge

wraithstrike wrote:

Yeah but once you modify a monster it is really something different so I was only speaking of the stock monster.

As an example even throwing breastplate on a humanoid shaped monster can give it incredible AC for its CR.

Oh, totally. But even a single level in, say, Swashbuckler, can make a Succubus quite the melee character.

And now I want to play one of those sometime...


5 people marked this as a favorite.
Deadmanwalking wrote:
wraithstrike wrote:

Yeah but once you modify a monster it is really something different so I was only speaking of the stock monster.

As an example even throwing breastplate on a humanoid shaped monster can give it incredible AC for its CR.

Oh, totally. But even a single level in, say, Swashbuckler, can make a Succubus quite the melee character.

And now I want to play one of those sometime...

That's a lot of Panache.


Deadmanwalking wrote:
wraithstrike wrote:

Yeah but once you modify a monster it is really something different so I was only speaking of the stock monster.

As an example even throwing breastplate on a humanoid shaped monster can give it incredible AC for its CR.

Oh, totally. But even a single level in, say, Swashbuckler, can make a Succubus quite the melee character.

And now I want to play one of those sometime...

I made a succubus cleric once, but never got to use it, but one day..

Liberty's Edge

Doomed Hero wrote:
That's a lot of Panache.

Indeed. :)

Still not half as terrifying as the Succubus Antipaladin, though. I mean...those Saves and Smite Goods...to say nothing of the creepy aspects of the whole 'plague bringer' ability in the hands of a Succubus.


How about a paladin succubus? All that charisma has it's uses.


2 people marked this as a favorite.

Succubi are considered combat monsters so the following core classes are considered disassociated for them: Bard, Cleric, Druid, Monk, Paladin, Monk, Sorcerer, and Wizard (by proxy we can probably assume that Alchemist, Oracle, Ninja, Magus, and classes similar to the above are unassociated).

As a result, it's actually not terribly hard to get some fun variants of succubi without inflating their CR to obscene degrees. For example, being CR 7 normally, 7 levels of wizard will net you a CR of 10, but will allow you to have a more mystical succubus. Alternatively, tossing some prestige classes such as Eldritch Knight or Arcane Archer on them could be fun. In fact, due to their SLAs and the nonsensical FAQs, you can probably turn them into some eldritch horror with a mixture of spellcasting required prestige classes worthy of a Lovecraftian smut magazine.

In other words, be creative and have some fun. :P


Dead Phoenix wrote:
Prince Yyrkoon wrote:
I'm fond of whip wielding Kensai Succubi myself. I mean, Vamperic Touch is just waiting there as a SLA, begging for a spellstrike. Bonus points for looking just like a regular old Succubus.
Unless I'm missing something, only Magus spells can be used on a spell strike, no SLAs.

"Spell from the Magus spell list" is the exact wording, which vamperic touch certainly is. Nothing about it actually having to use a Magus spell slot. Now, of course you could argue the intent is that the spell really does have to be cast as a Magus spell, but if I'm in a position to use a Succubus there's a 95%+ chance I'm also in a position to pull the "I'm the DM and I'm allowing it because it's cool, and frankly you lot could use a bit of a challenge, I'm far too generous with the loot" card.


shadowkras wrote:
How about a paladin succubus? All that charisma has it's uses.

Wizards of the Coast actually did something like that a few years back.


It's not really a new concept, but clerics are also pretty good as succubi, specially if they get Aligment Channel.


AndromedaRPG wrote:
shadowkras wrote:
How about a paladin succubus? All that charisma has it's uses.
Wizards of the Coast actually did something like that a few years back.

A succubus paladin seeking redemption, at that!

Spoiler:
Doesn't that sound a bit like the succubus in Wrath of the Righteous?


MagusJanus wrote:
Devilkiller wrote:
I wonder what the OP was getting at with the idea of getting outside of people's comfort zones. Are we talking about forcing PCs into actions which might make their players uncomfortable? Most groups have some taboos or sense of decorum, but I'd guess that they probably vary a lot.
I think he's talking about succubus concepts outside of the DnD-standard and more towards other concepts. DnD 5E kinda does this.

What I was talking about is turning the succubus into a genuine horror concept. That would require getting under a player's skin, and as anyone who's been at a table knows fear and sexuality can often be very uncomfortable for some people. The overt tone of rape (mentally, spiritually, emotionally, and physically) that comes with a succubus's very existence is something that's rarely played out, but if a group was interested in those dark places it's very possible to go there.


The title of this thread is just... wow... so many thoughts trying to get out of my head...


MagusJanus wrote:
If you want to be insanely evil, give the succubus class levels and adjust some stats accordingly....

Yeah, a while back we got hit with a succubus with a bunch of ninja levels and multiple uses of a high level vampiric touch. That was incredibly painful.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Neal Litherland wrote:
... is she just a demon done up in sexy?

“Just”?

Grand Lodge

MagusJanus wrote:
AndromedaRPG wrote:
shadowkras wrote:
How about a paladin succubus? All that charisma has it's uses.
Wizards of the Coast actually did something like that a few years back.

A succubus paladin seeking redemption, at that!

** spoiler omitted **

Spoiler:

Not quite the same, she's going a vastly different route. as she's seeking Desna, not Iomedae and going chaotic neutral insead of lawful good.

Grand Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.
MagusJanus wrote:
AndromedaRPG wrote:
shadowkras wrote:
How about a paladin succubus? All that charisma has it's uses.
Wizards of the Coast actually did something like that a few years back.

A succubus paladin seeking redemption, at that!

** spoiler omitted **

And then some knights sent by a wizard arrived...

It's honestly funny how none of the Paizo books get to say "Dungeons & Dragons" because of copyright, and instead say "The World's Oldest Roleplaying Game". It's like they're trying to avoid saying "Beetlejuice" three times.


Succubus + sorceror levels is seriously terrifying once you're able to cast 4th level spells and up, because her save DCs are going to be crazy high. Succubus + antipaladin is pretty whack, too.

However, I think you can have a lot of fun in other ways, too. Let me dig up my old post about the Sisters Market...

Doug M.


3 people marked this as a favorite.

Ah, found it.

* * * * *

The Sisters Market; or, making the Succubus more trouble

What makes the succubus different? No, no, besides the obvious.

I'd say it's this: succubi are, by their vary nature, social creatures. Other demons are solitary top predators, or slithering connivers, or rampaging monsters of pure destruction. But succubi need a social context to work.

So: succubi have a network. You could almost say an organization. Oh, it's a very chaotic organization, full of lies, jealousy, plots and treachery. Succubi don't actually *like* each other. But they have a lot in common, and as noted above they're social creatures, and also they can find mutual profit in working together.

How? Why, through the Sisters Market.

The Market is an informal network of succubi. It reaches all across the Abyss, and well beyond. Think of it as a Craigslist for demons. Though the current incarnation of the Market is fairly recent, something like it has existed for millenia. Because demons are demons, the network regularly gets crashed by cheating and abuse; but because it's so damn useful, it keeps getting recreated.

Succubi trade some physical stuff -- magic items and the like, and of course dominated slaves -- but mostly they trade information, roles, and hooks. Roles are identities that they've taken over. A "hook" is a Suggestion or Domination that a succubus has placed on a victim. (Yeah, it turns out that these things can be traded between two willing demons.)

So, say Candi has infiltrated a small mortal kingdom, dominating the queen and planting suggestions in the King's mind, and is driving the kingdom towards war and utter ruin. But suddenly she has to to away. Maybe she has a better job offer somewhere else; maybe she's suddenly become bored (this is the eighth kingdom she's ruined, frankly she'd like to try something different now); maybe she just got the news that the Shining Crusade is about to come to town and the palace will be crawling with good clerics and paladins. Whatever the reason, she contacts the Sisters Market and offers her role and her hooks -- the suggestions on the King, the domination on the Queen -- for sale. Tanya, who's been hanging around the Abyss torturing the same damned souls over and over, jumps at the chance; she offers an interesting magic item and, oh, the true name of a minor devil. An agreement is reached and, boom.

(Context: my PCs recently defeated a succubus; she got a Suggestion into one of them but then flew off because they were obviously too powerful. She's now traded the suggestion-hook to a more powerful demoness, who has just joined the party undercover.)

The Sisters Market also trades information. Much as they dislike each other, succubi tend to be gossips, and they love nothing better than a good, juicy secret. And they trade tactical information: I serve this demon lord, but I've noticed a weakness in his defenses. I'll trade it for information about the powerful good party that's rumored to be preparing an expedition to my plane of the Abyss. From a PC's point of view, this means that once you've encountered a single succubus, any subsequent one you meet may suddenly know much, much more about you. (This is especially true for characters who have embarked on a career of fiend-hunting, demon-binding, or anything else that seems likely to bring them into conflict with the sisters more than once. Demons are chaotic, but intelligent; they're not going to sit in rooms waiting for you to show up and kill them.)

The Sisters Market isn't only for succubi. Other fiends, and even high-level characters, can occasionally try buying or selling something. Just making contact would be a minor challenge in and of itself, and then of course you're dealing with a bunch of millenia-old chaotic evil outsiders with high Wis, very high Int, and very high Cha indeed. Good luck negotiating with the gal who can read thoughts, cast suggestions all day long, and -- oh, you have Protection From Evil up? -- talk rings around you anyway, because she has +27 Bluff.

Anyway, the Sisters Market. Thoughts?

Doug M.

Liberty's Edge

LazarX wrote:
MagusJanus wrote:
AndromedaRPG wrote:
shadowkras wrote:
How about a paladin succubus? All that charisma has it's uses.
Wizards of the Coast actually did something like that a few years back.

A succubus paladin seeking redemption, at that!

** spoiler omitted **

** spoiler omitted **

Spoiler:
In fairness, she's aiming for CG, she's just only part of the way there (CN) when you meet her. Part of the AP is helping her get the rest of the way.
Grand Lodge

Douglas Muir 406 wrote:
Stuff.

An alright idea, but I think it sells other demons short on their capacity to plan and exploit weaknesses, and utilize what others know for those ends.

Almost any demon has some capacity to wreak its favored sin in a social context. Glabrezu come most prominently to mind, peddling wishes that turn against the wisher. Hezrou may seek to pollute a community with drugs and other toxic thrills. Balors command entire legions of demons.

That said, I'm guessing Glabrezu likely frequent the Sisters Market quite regularly.

Shadow Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.

I like the Sisters Market.

Neal Litherland wrote:
What I was talking about is turning the succubus into a genuine horror concept. That would require getting under a player's skin, and as anyone who's been at a table knows fear and sexuality can often be very uncomfortable for some people. The overt tone of rape (mentally, spiritually, emotionally, and physically) that comes with a succubus's very existence is something that's rarely played out, but if a group was interested in those dark places it's very possible to go there.

I had a succubus possess a wizard PC's estranged wife. She asked for his help and subtly hinted that there might be a possibility for reconciliation, used him (and the party) to destroy her enemies, and then killed a rival who the party had captured and who had knowledge of her crimes. This blew her cover, so she held the wife hostage in an attempt to coerce the wizard into "keeping the guard busy" while she completed her scheme. The wizard crit a bluff check to convince the succubus that she had successfully seduced him - physically and morally - and he led her into an ambush. (I did give her a few levels in ninja to make her more of a combat challenge.) The party barely managed to rescue the wife, but not before the wizard briefly got a profane gift that dropped him to about 2 Cha when ripped out.

We didn't get too explicit, but there were definitely some moments that were very uncomfortable for the characters.

I consider her one of my best villains.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / General Discussion / Is The Succubus Being Used To Her Full Potential? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.