Deathwatch: Stone Golem vs. Statue made of stone


Rules Questions


Would Deathwatch inform the user the ability to detect a construct creature if that creature was just standing still as if it were a statue?


Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Pathfinder Starfinder Adventure Path, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber

Originally I was going to say that deathwatch doesn't detect constructs, but looking at the wording it actually does. So yes, Deathwatch would be able to tell the difference. That's actually... really powerful, for a first level spell.

Now it looks like deathwatch does not tell you where the creature is. So if there are 5 statues in range you just get "one construct", it doesn't tell you which statue.


Yeah, the wording is confusing to me, it says not alive or dead (such as a construct), so the construct is an example...I feel it could have equally said "such as a rock". But then of course, it doesn't say that and does specify another creature type which makes me wonder if that is the intent.

Contributor

Using the powers of necromancy, you can determine the condition of creatures near death within the spell's range.

Constructs are creatures. A statue is not a creature. Thus, the spell would look at a construct and say "not alive or dead," and at a statue and say "no creature detected" (as it would respond to any other non-creature rock).


Thanks Sean for the reply!


MaxAstro wrote:

Originally I was going to say that deathwatch doesn't detect constructs, but looking at the wording it actually does. So yes, Deathwatch would be able to tell the difference. That's actually... really powerful, for a first level spell.

Now it looks like deathwatch does not tell you where the creature is. So if there are 5 statues in range you just get "one construct", it doesn't tell you which statue.

I don't mean to controdict you. but the description within the spell for death watch does say "You instantly know whether each creature within the area is..."

so really it doesn't tell you, because it doesn't have to, you already know so you should know which one is which one. I notice that this one spell/ability confuses ALOT of people.

and I kinda get slightly irritated that people get to much into trying to nerf this thing because the fill it's too powerful. honestly I don't she this as being anymore powerful then haveing darkvision

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Deathwatch: Stone Golem vs. Statue made of stone All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rules Questions