Is R’lyeh on Earth?

[FallofCamelot]

As much as I enjoyed the Lovecraft elements of various Paizo products I would actually prefer not to see a Lovecraft AP. Personally I think less is more when it comes to this sort of stuff and I think that there's a perfectly decent RPG already fully dealing with the Mythos.

Plus another Horror AP after CC is a bit like treading the same ground twice.

Not a criticism just something I would prefer not to see when there are already loads of other arenas to explore within Golarion.

[Tholomyes]

To me, I always figured that part of the Golarion use of the Great Old Ones would have implied a much less Cthulhu-focus, simply because R'lyeh is on Earth. Granted, I don't know how the Bestiary 4 will do it, but to me, Cthulhu's dreams can permeate to Golarion, but him not being on the scale of the Outer Gods, he would be at most a minor influence, compared to other nearer Great Old Ones, and the Outer Gods

[TwiceGreat]

I second the question about the Dreamlands.

And also, that Compass-headed goddess on the Dreamlands map is reminisce of Lissala, and we all know Thassilon and the Dreamlands had all of the pen-palism going on.

[Trinite]

I'd say that between Carrion Hill, Wake of the Watcher, Into the Nightmare Rift, and the stuff in Distant Worlds, Varisia, and the Darklands, there's plenty of published material to help a GM create an excellent 100% Lovecraftian AP for themselves.

Though I'm sure it would be chock full of stuff I'd like, I'd rather not see a purely Lovecraftian full AP. It would run the risk of consigning all that type of stuff into a single easily-marginalizable box. I like the current technique of mixing mythos/cosmic horror elements into other things much better.