outsiders are 'uneffected' by the field. but my DM said, the gear and the items are effected. is he right? and if he's right: the monk is uneffected, but no items, no supernatral abilities ... uneffected against what?
where is the difference:
antimagic field vs. monk lvl19
and
antimagic field vs. monk lvl20
|
The spell description does not say that outsiders are completely unaffected. After talking about how magical constructs - such a golems - will still function in an anti-magic field, it says that outsiders are likewise unaffected.
It is saying that outsiders don't disappear or have any adverse effects like summoned creatures do. A monk of 20th level will be affected in exactly the same way as a 19th level monk. All magic items and supernatural abilities will cease to function.
summond outsiders are simply affected.
all other '... outsiders are unaffected ...', but in which way? where is this 'effect' which is 'unaffected'? ... this clause makes no sense. outsiders aren't unaffected in any way. they are affected in all matters :)
Summoned outsiders will simply vanish (as if banished).
as i said above
the only thing i could find is 'i am not hungry' in an AMF *rofl*
outsiders are unaffected ;)
Summoned outsiders will simply vanish (as if banished).
outsiders are 'uneffected' by the field. but my DM said, the gear and the items are effected. is he right? and if he's right: the monk is uneffected, but no items, no supernatral abilities ... uneffected against what?
where is the difference:
antimagic field vs. monk lvl19
and
antimagic field vs. monk lvl20
It's pretty straightforward if you read it in context:
The spell has no effect on golems and other constructs that are imbued with magic during their creation process and are thereafter self-supporting (unless they have been summoned, in which case they are treated like any other summoned creatures). Elementals, corporeal undead, and outsider are likewise unaffected unless summoned. These creatures' spell-like or supernatural abilities may be temporarily nullified by the field.
In other words, constructs elementals, corporeal undead, and outsiders aren't nullified by the field despite being inherently magical. Otherwise, constructs would shut down, undead would revert to being dead, and I don't know what would happen to elementals and outsiders, but it wouldn't be good for them.