Dorgar's Falcons Hollow OOC


Play-by-Post Discussion

151 to 200 of 225 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | next > last >>

Yes. One of us should post asking if he would like to see our group concept or if he'd like us to post individually.


Wow. Sully's game filled up in less than four hours. Perhaps next time one comes available, whoever spots it should throw their name in for it, and mention knowing a group of others interested. If the one person gets in, I don't think any of us would begrudge them the opportunity to get in on a campaign.


AC 24 (25) HP 30/30 AP 8/8

I think we should just go over there and advertise for a GM. Maybe somebody will take pity on us, and not want to recruit, and just go for it.


HP 41/41 | AC 17+2(shield)| Acr +4 Ath +7 Dec +3 Int +6 Perc -1 Pers +6 Saves: S +4, D +1, C +2, I +0, W +2, Ch +6 Adv charm, disease; Imm Sleep| Init +1 | PPerc 9; PIns 10; Pinv 11; DrkVis | Spd 30' | HD 5/5 | Status: Ok | Spells 1:4/4; 2:2/2 | LoH 25/25 | DivSen 5/5 | Insp: Nope

I agree. Who's game?

Grand Lodge

I'll post it if you guys want I was trying to make sure what I put sounded good to everybody was planning on posting a thread this evening If someone else wants to though I certainly don't mind.


HP 41/41 | AC 17+2(shield)| Acr +4 Ath +7 Dec +3 Int +6 Perc -1 Pers +6 Saves: S +4, D +1, C +2, I +0, W +2, Ch +6 Adv charm, disease; Imm Sleep| Init +1 | PPerc 9; PIns 10; Pinv 11; DrkVis | Spd 30' | HD 5/5 | Status: Ok | Spells 1:4/4; 2:2/2 | LoH 25/25 | DivSen 5/5 | Insp: Nope

Great, once the thread is up, perhaps we could poke our character's head, so the candidate can take a look at them, or wait until someone shows interest?


Sounds like a good plan.

Grand Lodge

ok here is the link.GM Plea


Male Elven Alchemist 1

Sounds fine to me.


HP 41/41 | AC 17+2(shield)| Acr +4 Ath +7 Dec +3 Int +6 Perc -1 Pers +6 Saves: S +4, D +1, C +2, I +0, W +2, Ch +6 Adv charm, disease; Imm Sleep| Init +1 | PPerc 9; PIns 10; Pinv 11; DrkVis | Spd 30' | HD 5/5 | Status: Ok | Spells 1:4/4; 2:2/2 | LoH 25/25 | DivSen 5/5 | Insp: Nope
Dorgar wrote:
ok here is the link.GM Plea

Great pitch! Thanks Dorgar.


Male Elven Alchemist 1

1d10 + 8 ⇒ (9) + 8 = 171d10 + 8 ⇒ (1) + 8 = 91d10 + 8 ⇒ (4) + 8 = 121d10 + 8 ⇒ (7) + 8 = 151d10 + 8 ⇒ (2) + 8 = 101d10 + 8 ⇒ (6) + 8 = 14


HP 41/41 | AC 17+2(shield)| Acr +4 Ath +7 Dec +3 Int +6 Perc -1 Pers +6 Saves: S +4, D +1, C +2, I +0, W +2, Ch +6 Adv charm, disease; Imm Sleep| Init +1 | PPerc 9; PIns 10; Pinv 11; DrkVis | Spd 30' | HD 5/5 | Status: Ok | Spells 1:4/4; 2:2/2 | LoH 25/25 | DivSen 5/5 | Insp: Nope

AAremeth, now I'm curious.


LOL. Trevor, I think Aaremeth posted in the wrong thread. I suspect those are meant to be fort saves agaisnt seasickenss in another PbP that he, Dorgar and I are playing in.


Male Elven Alchemist 1

actually i was making up a character, and I didn't have dice on me so I made a post here, I deleted it but...aparently even though I told it I was sure I wanted to delete it, it didn't believe me.


Ahh, I see. I didn't look closely enough to see they were d10s and not d20s.


Male Elven Alchemist 1

I'll explain if I am doing any littering for my convienence from now on.

Grand Lodge

I know everyone is itching for the round to be posted, but I just found out an old friend I haven't seen in the last few years passed on. I just don't feel like posting right now. I should have it up tomorrow.

Grand Lodge

Just as an update everyone has 700xp

Grand Lodge

looks like we may have a dm for Kingmaker :)

Grand Lodge

Hey guys I'm going to be going out of town for my friends funeral and wake tomorrow, so I may not post tomorrow. Not sure how long it is going to last etc. I should be back to normal posting Sunday nothing else occurs that evening if you guys want to roleplay the next days Journey that is fine You should be nearing the Oldest tree in the early afternoon.


HP 41/41 | AC 17+2(shield)| Acr +4 Ath +7 Dec +3 Int +6 Perc -1 Pers +6 Saves: S +4, D +1, C +2, I +0, W +2, Ch +6 Adv charm, disease; Imm Sleep| Init +1 | PPerc 9; PIns 10; Pinv 11; DrkVis | Spd 30' | HD 5/5 | Status: Ok | Spells 1:4/4; 2:2/2 | LoH 25/25 | DivSen 5/5 | Insp: Nope

Sorry for your loss Dorgar. Take good care.

I'll also be away until Sunday.

Grand Lodge

Thank you for your well wishes.


Take care, and take all the time you need. We'll be here when you're ready.

Dark Archive

Some dude

Sorry to hear about your friend, and good wishes for your trip.


Male Elven Alchemist 1

doing a bit more littering for a live game charrie. viva armor craft!

a chain shirt has a dc of 14 to make as it is 10+ac(4) I bought a third of the cost 33.4sp and an artisan kit 5gp.

craft:1d20 + 5 ⇒ (14) + 5 = 19

19x14=266

1000-266=734 a forth of the way done in a week.

craft:1d20 + 5 ⇒ (10) + 5 = 15

15X13=210

734-210=524

a little bit less done this week, but nearly half way there!

craft:1d20 + 5 ⇒ (14) + 5 = 19

19x14=266

524-266=258

another good week and we are close to done!

craft:1d20 + 5 ⇒ (13) + 5 = 18

18X14=252

258-252=6

so close but so sleep, looks like it is going to have to wait til monday.

craft:1d20 + 5 ⇒ (19) + 5 = 24

24X14=336

6-336=-330.

Putting that last link in went perfectly!


Male Elven Alchemist 1

And now making chain shirt barding for the Eidolon.

it is medium so the price is only double with the dc remaining the same. 14

which i have realised is with in the means of taking ten.

15x14=210 x 10 weeks of work=2100.

let me know if this doesn't work for you drogar.if if the task would have been higher dc. but then would I have gotten a bonus for being watched by Savanah?

Dark Archive

Some dude

'Waste' one of your Eidolon's first level Evolutions (which you can swap out and replace at 2nd level) with Skilled (+8 Craft - armorsmithing) and then just Aid his rolls. :)

That probably is only gonna work if you picked a biped, 'though, since most GMs will throw something heavy at you if you try to claim that your quadruped or serpentine eidolon is banging out a chain shirt for you at the forge...


Male Elven Alchemist 1

hahahaha! thats pretty sneaky thinking, I like it. I think my gnome managed well enough though.

Dark Archive

Some dude

Playing with dice roller;

1d6d1d6 ⇒ (2, 5, 3, 3, 3, 1) = 17

1d6d1d6 ⇒ (3, 5, 6, 3, 4) = 21

1d6d1d6 ⇒ 3

Grand Lodge

Ok everybody after the cauldron and I know I am technically jumping the gun, but finding the rat tail will give you guys enough xp to level up. Go ahead and update your characters. If you would roll here for hps, and ask any questions if you need to.


Male Human (Taldan) Barbarian / 2

2nd lvl HP roll: 1d12 + 3 ⇒ (10) + 3 = 13

The Exchange

Male Human Summoner 2

2nd level hit points 1d8 + 2 ⇒ (8) + 2 = 10

Woot!

Vermiis gets mob hit points (5.5 / hit die).

Added enlarge person and read magic, as his new spells. Vermiis has lost scent and added claws and trip.


HP 41/41 | AC 17+2(shield)| Acr +4 Ath +7 Dec +3 Int +6 Perc -1 Pers +6 Saves: S +4, D +1, C +2, I +0, W +2, Ch +6 Adv charm, disease; Imm Sleep| Init +1 | PPerc 9; PIns 10; Pinv 11; DrkVis | Spd 30' | HD 5/5 | Status: Ok | Spells 1:4/4; 2:2/2 | LoH 25/25 | DivSen 5/5 | Insp: Nope

2nd level hp roll: 1d10 ⇒ 3

Oh well...


1d8 + 0 ⇒ (7) + 0 = 7


Male Elven Alchemist 1

1d8 + 1 ⇒ (5) + 1 = 6+1=7

dont forget your favored class +1hp or skill point

I'll take the hp.

I took truestrike for my new formula and percise bomb for my discovery, you guys are in a lot less danger of taking splash damage.


HP 41/41 | AC 17+2(shield)| Acr +4 Ath +7 Dec +3 Int +6 Perc -1 Pers +6 Saves: S +4, D +1, C +2, I +0, W +2, Ch +6 Adv charm, disease; Imm Sleep| Init +1 | PPerc 9; PIns 10; Pinv 11; DrkVis | Spd 30' | HD 5/5 | Status: Ok | Spells 1:4/4; 2:2/2 | LoH 25/25 | DivSen 5/5 | Insp: Nope

Leveling is making me wonder: So many game do not survive long. Do you think lack of leveling often plays a role?

I'm enjoying this game very much so far. I like the group's dynamic as they get to know each other.

Dark Archive

Some dude
Trevor the Yellow wrote:

Leveling is making me wonder: So many game do not survive long. Do you think lack of leveling often plays a role?

Speaking solely for myself, I try to design characters that I want to play *immediately.* (And, granted, that's much easier in, say, GURPS, or Mutants & Masterminds, or Aberrant.) As a result, it really doesn't matter to me if the character levels at all, as I rarely have any interest in what they are going to look like later.

That's probably a result of preferentially playing superhero games, where, even in a level-based game like Villains & Vigilantes, your character usually starts out with most of the powers you wanted anyway, and extra points / levels are just 'more stuff.'

In D&D, a 1st level Wizard, particularly in 1st edition, was pretty darn dire, so I did enjoy leveling up more then, but quickly moved on to GURPS, V&V, Vampire, etc. and found that I much preferred developing my characters slowly, after starting out relatively competent and / or powerful, than starting out weak and doubling, tripling, octupling, etc. in power as levels accrue.

3rd edition, and now Pathfinder, has made 1st level no longer the painful ordeal it was in ye olde days, but I still tend to design characters on the assumption that they have to be fun at 1st level, having seen too many games (both PBP and tabletop) die out and leave other players frustrated that their complex multi-class 'headed for the PrC' build never 'got to the good part.'

There are always exceptions. Some classes, like the Binder and Warlock, have *very* limited palettes at 1st level, and tend to be deadly dull before, say, 4th to 6th level, but I can usually have a good time with a 1st level character for quite some time.


HP 41/41 | AC 17+2(shield)| Acr +4 Ath +7 Dec +3 Int +6 Perc -1 Pers +6 Saves: S +4, D +1, C +2, I +0, W +2, Ch +6 Adv charm, disease; Imm Sleep| Init +1 | PPerc 9; PIns 10; Pinv 11; DrkVis | Spd 30' | HD 5/5 | Status: Ok | Spells 1:4/4; 2:2/2 | LoH 25/25 | DivSen 5/5 | Insp: Nope

Interesting thoughts!

Now what would you say is the equivalent power level between a Pathfinder character and a starting Vampire character? 4th?

People often comment on the "sweet spot" levels. Why not start PbP games at that level? If the games are more short live, wouldn't it be better?

I'm just trying some ideas. No great principle yet.


In some cases, you do start at a higher level. I'm in a Carrion Hill PbP that started at 5th level. Some people, myself included, like the challenge of surviving those lower levels. I recall one time, in the days of AD&D, having a 1st level magic-user who rolled 1 for his hit points. 1 hit point. Now that's a twitchy character! He did survive past first level, but not too much... In earlier editions, there were options to play zero level characters, but those were almost as hard to run as uber high level games; there are few appropriate challenges at that level.


Male Elven Alchemist 1

I like starting at one, though if I have enough first level games going then I don't mind a highlevel start here or there, though I do think the process of making the cahracter is a bit skewed.

you can make up a character totally diffrent then you would have if you had to do it levle by level.

Dark Archive

Some dude
Trevor the Yellow wrote:

Interesting thoughts!

Now what would you say is the equivalent power level between a Pathfinder character and a starting Vampire character? 4th?

Probably only 1st or 2nd for the new Vampire the Requiem rules, but 3rd or 4th-ish back in Masquerade (with Werewolves and Mages operating on a different scale, really).

On the other hand, the VtM rules use of 'freebie points' could result in a character having a single Discipline at rank 5 right out of the gate, which was pretty much the 'highest-level spell' one could have, with abilities like enduring mind control, mass invisibility, astral projection, gaseous form, etc. as well as fun abilities like the ability to make five extra attacks in an action or to punch through a brick wall. It would be like starting out a Wizard in D&D and having one spell of each level from your specialty college, but nothing else.

A different starting vampire might take 1 beginning power in each of his three 'Clan Disciplines,' and spend the rest of his freebie points on skills or abilities or merits (basically feats), and be much more like a starting D&D character. (Point-wise, that would be a terribly inefficient thing in VtM, 'though, as XP costs scaled, and freebie cost expenditures did not, meaning that you could start with a level 5 in one Discipline, but if you didn't, it could take *years* of gaming to be able to afford one, while catching up and getting the starter levels of the Disciplines you ignored at character generation was cheap. I think they fixed that in the new Requiem rules...)

Trevor the Yellow wrote:
People often comment on the "sweet spot" levels. Why not start PbP games at that level? If the games are more short live, wouldn't it be better?

Could very well be. I imagine someone could do a 'paper study' of the various PBPs here (or on RPG.now or whatever) and see how many D&D games that start at higher level have a higher retention rate than those that start at 1st level. Too much work for my blood! :)

In my experience, a 1st level game that survives to 4th level has a higher retention rate than one that starts at 4th level, as the players are more invested in those characters and their stories.

And yeah, starting a character at X level does have certain artificial qualities. It's possible that neither of my Summoners would have taken Toughness as their first feat choice for their Eidolons, had they not started at 1st level (where the Eidolon has only 6 hp!).


Male Elven Alchemist 1

well hopefully we play the game til 20th level, and then some!


HP 41/41 | AC 17+2(shield)| Acr +4 Ath +7 Dec +3 Int +6 Perc -1 Pers +6 Saves: S +4, D +1, C +2, I +0, W +2, Ch +6 Adv charm, disease; Imm Sleep| Init +1 | PPerc 9; PIns 10; Pinv 11; DrkVis | Spd 30' | HD 5/5 | Status: Ok | Spells 1:4/4; 2:2/2 | LoH 25/25 | DivSen 5/5 | Insp: Nope

Set, I played VtM for many years, and what you say about the point system is in line with my experience.

Interesting points all around about 1st level and 4th and the attrition rate.

So let me explore another line of inquiry I have: Does the rate of leveling would have an influence on the involvement of the players? Does the experience system as thought for a RL game too slow for a PbP?

Grand Lodge

Just to let everyone know I will be out of town this weekend and next weekend. Hitting up a couple local SCA (Society of Creative Anachronism)events.


HP 41/41 | AC 17+2(shield)| Acr +4 Ath +7 Dec +3 Int +6 Perc -1 Pers +6 Saves: S +4, D +1, C +2, I +0, W +2, Ch +6 Adv charm, disease; Imm Sleep| Init +1 | PPerc 9; PIns 10; Pinv 11; DrkVis | Spd 30' | HD 5/5 | Status: Ok | Spells 1:4/4; 2:2/2 | LoH 25/25 | DivSen 5/5 | Insp: Nope

So I guess we'll have to NPCDM your DM character...


Male Elven Alchemist 1

ohhhhhh, in that case, everyone level up once an hour for every hour he is gone! Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!


Safe travels! You going to be up in the Seattle area at all?

Grand Lodge

No one day hopefully, this is just local Texas stuff. I would love to go up to Washington sometime though it looks beautiful up there. Hey you going to Paizocon since you are right there you lucky dog?


The SCA is pretty strong up here, or at least it was when I was at the UW. The backdrop here is amazing for anything of the sort with the mountains, forests and lakes.

Sadly, I won't be able to do Paizocon even though I'll be right here. This summer I'm going to be working a second job with the Census.


Male Elven Alchemist 1

So I had an Idea, we never replaced rufus and while I don't think that we should do an open call, I was wondering what you thought of inviting scipion to play, having two grim reapers in there gave me the Idea.

but first what do you think GM? and second what do the other guys think? after that I'd suppose we ask mister skippy.

151 to 200 of 225 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Online Campaigns / Play-by-Post Discussion / Dorgar's Falcons Hollow OOC All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.