Are you a Genius #2 ?


Off-Topic Discussions


(this is not a math puzzle)

An idler sighed: “Everyone says, ‘We don’t need idlers. You are always in the way. Go to the devil!’ But will the devil tell me to get rich?”
No sooner did the idler say this than the devil himself stood in front of him.

“Well,” said the devil, “the work I have for you is light, and you will get rich. Do you see that bridge? Just walk across and I will double the money you have now. In fact, each time you cross I will double your money.”

“You don’t say!”

“But there is one small thing. Since I am so generous you must give me $24 after each crossing.”

The idler agreed. He crossed the bridge, stopped to count his money …a miracle! It had doubled.

He threw $24 to the devil and crossed again. His money doubled, he paid another $24, crossed a third time. Again his money doubled. But now he had only $24, and he had to give it all to the devil. The devil laughed and vanished.

.

The moral: When anyone gives you advice you should think before you act. How much money did the idler start with?

Answer:

Spoiler:

It is probably best to think about this backwards. Before the third crossing the idler had $12. Adding the $24 he gave the devil after the second crossing, he had $36, twice the $18 he had before the second crossing. Adding $24 again, he had $42, twice the $21 he started with.

The Exchange RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16

Hey, Tensor. I got it; thanks for the diversion!

But in what way is this not a math puzzle? (Variations on it, with different things that happen during the iteration, are standard fare in math classrooms and math teacher training workshops.)


My dad told me this one.

When I was as old as you are, you were half as old as I am. When you are as old as I am, together we'll be 63. How old am I?

Hint:
The answer is not 21 and 42.


Chris Mortika wrote:

Hey, Tensor. I got it; thanks for the diversion!

But in what way is this not a math puzzle? (Variations on it, with different things that happen during the iteration, are standard fare in math classrooms and math teacher training workshops.)

Lets call this a Finance Puzzle.

Spoiler:

I'm trying to alleviate math-phobia with the power of suggestion.

Silver Crusade

I got it right, but all I can say is... You know who isn't a genius? The guy who crossed the bridge...

Spoiler:
It doesn't take a genius to know that the only scenario in which the devil's offer would be profitable is if the idler started with more than $24. In any other case, the amount he would make for doubling his money would be less than the $24. However, I find this scenario plausible because a lot of people really are that stupid.


Tensor wrote:
Chris Mortika wrote:

Hey, Tensor. I got it; thanks for the diversion!

But in what way is this not a math puzzle? (Variations on it, with different things that happen during the iteration, are standard fare in math classrooms and math teacher training workshops.)

Lets call this a Finance Puzzle.

** spoiler omitted **

Waitaminute...there was math involved in that problem! FRAUD! FRAUD! goes back to hide underneath math-impervious lead shielding

RPG Superstar 2013 Top 32

Tensor wrote:

(this is not a math puzzle)

Yes, it is.

But I got it.

Still trying to parse the sentence on the age thing.

Silver Crusade

DoveArrow wrote:

My dad told me this one.

When I was as old as you are, you were half as old as I am. When you are as old as I am, together we'll be 63. How old am I?

** spoiler omitted **

Finally got it.

Spoiler:
I was looking for a valid age for a father and son, but it's just a riddle your father told you... Because that would just be wrong...

Don't read unless you already know the answer:
27

Sovereign Court

Celestial Healer wrote:
DoveArrow wrote:

My dad told me this one.

When I was as old as you are, you were half as old as I am. When you are as old as I am, together we'll be 63. How old am I?

** spoiler omitted **

Finally got it.

** spoiler omitted **

** spoiler omitted **

my answer:
I got the ages to be 21 and 28...

x/2=y-(x-y)=2y-x => 3x = 4y
x+(x-y)+y+(x-y)=63 => 3x-y = 63 => 3y=63

The Exchange RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16

I got the same answer as Calixymenthillian, but I chose to set the variables as Y = "your current age" and D = difference in ages.

So the speaker's current age is Y + D.

The restrictions literally translate then as:

Spoiler:

Y - D = 1/2 (Y + D)
and
(Y + D) + (Y + D + D) = 63.

The first sentence simplifies down to
Spoiler:

Y = 3 * D.
So we substitute "3D" into the second equation wherever there's a Y.
(3D + D) + (3D + D + D) = 63
9D = 63.

Liberty's Edge

Pathfinder Adventure Path, Rulebook, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Calixymenthillian wrote:
Celestial Healer wrote:
DoveArrow wrote:

My dad told me this one.

When I was as old as you are, you were half as old as I am. When you are as old as I am, together we'll be 63. How old am I?

** spoiler omitted **

Finally got it.

** spoiler omitted **

** spoiler omitted **

** spoiler omitted **

Those don't fit the first constraint (as I read it):

Details:
If the older person is 28 and the younger is 21, seven years ago when the older was 21 (the same age as the younger is now) the younger was 14. But 14 isn't half of 21. OTOH, I think that works if the constraint is "when I was your age, your age was half my current age." But that's not how I read it.

The Exchange RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16

John, the first constraint says "half as old as I am now".

Liberty's Edge

Pathfinder Adventure Path, Rulebook, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Chris Mortika wrote:
John, the first constraint says "half as old as I am now".

I got that on the second read--perils of rushing through, I suppose. That particular incorrect solution (cf. Celestial Healer's answer, above) was internally consistent, though.

Silver Crusade

Chris Mortika wrote:
John, the first constraint says "half as old as I am now".

Good call. I did read that incorrectly.


Math hurt brian...have urge to weggie nurd...Aarrggg...

Sovereign Court

Celestial Healer wrote:
Good call. I did read that incorrectly.

It is a bit of a clunky sentence, which is usually the main difficulty in these riddles.


Celestial Healer wrote:
Finally got it.

You might want to check your math. :-)


Calixymenthillian wrote:
My answer

Calixy has it. :-)


Hulk am hate Math!! Hulk smash puny Math!!!!


Chris Mortika wrote:
I got the same answer as Calixymenthillian, but I chose to set the variables as Y = "your current age" and D = difference in ages.

My dad once figured out how to solve it with one variable. I can't remember how he did it, though. It was back when I was still just trying to figure out what the riddle was asking.


Uh, can I just say that that one about the ages works so much better in real-world terms if it's about the age of a pair of siblings than about a father and child.


Charles Evans 25 wrote:

Uh, can I just say that that one about the ages works so much better in real-world terms if it's about the age of a pair of siblings than about a father and child.

It's not about a father and child. I mentioned that my dad told me the riddle. However, he wasn't talking about us. After all, when he was as old as I am, I wasn't born yet. :P

The Exchange RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16

DoveArrow wrote:
My dad once figured out how to solve it with one variable. I can't remember how he did it, though. It was back when I was still just trying to figure out what the riddle was asking.

Well, it's a system of two equations in two unknowns. You can solve them simultaneously or, as we've been discussing, by substitution. But there's no way to start the process with only one unknown.


Chris Mortika wrote:
Well, it's a system of two equations in two unknowns. You can solve them simultaneously or, as we've been discussing, by substitution. But there's no way to start the process with only one unknown.

I wholeheartedly agree with you. However, I'm just telling you what I remember.

Silver Crusade

DoveArrow wrote:
Chris Mortika wrote:
Well, it's a system of two equations in two unknowns. You can solve them simultaneously or, as we've been discussing, by substitution. But there's no way to start the process with only one unknown.
I wholeheartedly agree with you. However, I'm just telling you what I remember.

He may have been using substitution but glossing over that part, so the first step that he put down on paper was where he had already reduced it to one variable.

Community / Forums / Gamer Life / Off-Topic Discussions / Are you a Genius #2 ? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Off-Topic Discussions