X versus Y


3.5/d20/OGL

1 to 50 of 52 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>
Scarab Sages

So here is a thread I was inspired to do after one of my responses to the movie thread. What two monsters would you most like to see go toe-to-toe, head-to-head, tooth-and-claw, tentacle-to-wing in a knock-down, drag-out, fight to the finish. No templates! No class levels! No items! Just one thing against another.

My choice from that other thread was a Pit Fiend vs a Balor. Some others are:

- Behir vs Hydra
- Hobgoblin vs Orc
- Frost Giant vs Fire Giant
- Naga vs Yuan-ti Abomination


Tarrasque v Everything else

:)

Scarab Sages

Nermal2097 wrote:

Tarrasque v Everything else

:)

You know, in the Tarrasque's MM entry, I think they say something like it could even give the oldest of dragons a run for their money. So that's is what I would say - a Great Wyrm Gold Dragon (or maybe a Red) versus the Tarrasque.


An ancient Gold might take it down, just. But it might need help from a Titan or two grappling the beast.


Vampire mind flayer vs. werebear war troll.


matt_the_dm wrote:

Vampire mind flayer vs. werebear mind flayer.

Gotta thing for mind flayers?


Nermal2097 wrote:
matt_the_dm wrote:

Vampire mind flayer vs. werebear mind flayer.

Gotta thing for mind flayers?

Maybe. I mis-posted though and you caught me pre-edit. Mind flayers aren't eligible for lycanthropy.

Scarab Sages

Nermal2097 wrote:
An ancient Gold might take it down, just. But it might need help from a Titan or two grappling the beast.

Ooohhh..inspiration! A Titan versus a dragon. That would be cool.

Scarab Sages

matt_the_dm wrote:

Vampire mind flayer vs. werebear war troll.

Aaarrgghh...come on guys...no templates. If people start doing that this will just degenerate into a mindless template-fest.


Aberzombie wrote:
Aaarrgghh...come on guys...no templates. If people start doing that this will just degenerate into a mindless template-fest.

What? You mean we don't need another template-fest thread? My bad for not fully reading your rules of the post.

How about rust monster vs. iron golem?

Basilisk vs. medusa?

Invisible stalker vs. displacer beast?

M@

Scarab Sages

Aberzombie wrote:
Aaarrgghh...come on guys...no templates. If people start doing that this will just degenerate into a mindless template-fest.

Awww, and here I was gonna suggest an Zombie Quaggoth with Yuan-ti grafts vs. an Advanced Celestial Krenshar


I'd like to see two Shreikers going at it...

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Ultradan

Dark Archive Bella Sara Charter Superscriber

Nermal2097 wrote:

Tarrasque v Everything else

:)

Tarrasque v. kobold!*

*Kobold gets a stick. Oooh! Stick!!!**

**And not the Order of the Stick either. A non-magical piece of wood. A club if you will.***

***This footnoting is excessive. A player in my AoW game has a wizard and didn't bother purchasing any weapons. After finding the abandoned mine house, they decided to set off for the Whispering Cairn. The wizard asks if there are any pieces of wood around. I tell him, sure, there's an old broken up table. He scavanges a leg from the table and declares that he is now armed with a club. He then proceeds to point out that the club does indeed cost 0gp according to the phb. He did manage to take out an opponent using said club, and thus I believe that a kobold with a similar stick, Str, and BAB could take out the Tarrasque.


Ultradan wrote:

I'd like to see two Shreikers going at it...

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Ultradan

LOL!!!!!

*spews seafood gumbo all over desk*


a small water elemental vs a giant fire elemental...in the plane of water.


Flesh Golem (Frankenstein) Vs. Mummy

Mummy Vs. Vampire Spawn (Closest I can get to a vampire without using a template).

Any other combo that pits classic horror monsters against each other.


Oh...

Any Deity Vs. Any Deity

Just to see how it plays out.


Ultradan wrote:

I'd like to see two Shreikers going at it...

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Ultradan

I'm still laughin.., still.., la.., ugh.., ing..,


Will 'o Wisp Vs. Lantern Archon

Hound Archon Vs. Chain Devil

Shambling Mound Vs. Black Pudding

The Exchange

Choker vs. Cockatrice
get it? cause a cockatrice is like a chicken? Chokers like to choke things? Oh, Gods am I funny or what!?!

FH


bullette v. ankheg

the image of these two fighting reminds me of an old Japanese monster movie.


Ultradan wrote:

I'd like to see two Shreikers going at it...

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Shreiker 1 : "Twwwwwweeeeeeettt!!!!!!!"

Shreiker 2 : "Twwwwoooooooottttt!!!!"

Ultradan

You are a strange, twisted individual and I would like to be the first to offer my undying devotion and loyalty to your warped mind. That is priceless!! Two Shreikers!! I love it!!


And my own choice...

As a serious match-up; Quickling vs. Troll. With the Quickling's massive speed and quick attacks matched up against a Troll's regeneration, could be interesting...

As a humorous match-up; Phoenix vs. Lich (I know it's a Template) Think of it, two creatures that just keep coming back from death over and over and over and over.... Make sure it's a BIG tub of popcorn if you're going to watch that fight!


Joex The Pale wrote:
You are a strange, twisted individual and I would like to be the first to offer my undying devotion and loyalty to your warped mind.

Your training is now complete:

So from this day forward, you will no longer be known as Joex The Pale. You will be known as... DARTH BUCKET!

Rise, my friend.

Palpadan


Mimic vs Doppleganger-a fight that ensures all parties including onlookers will be surprized

Cadaver collector vs a hulking corpse

an army of rot reavers vs Vecna

Sea cat vs Dire Shark

Treant vs Dire Squirrle

The Exchange

Sexi Golem 01 wrote:

Mimic vs Doppleganger-a fight that ensures all parties including onlookers will be surprized

Cadaver collector vs a hulking corpse

an army of rot reavers vs Vecna

Sea cat vs Dire Shark

Treant vs Dire Squirrle

stat up the Dire Squirrel and put in the NPC database that Lilith has going, that would be cool. Unless its already statted in another book that is.

FH


Flumph v Flumph

Scarab Sages

VedicCold wrote:

Flesh Golem (Frankenstein) Vs. Mummy

Mummy Vs. Vampire Spawn (Closest I can get to a vampire without using a template).

Any other combo that pits classic horror monsters against each other.

Oh all right, feel free to use undead templates.


Fake Healer wrote:

Choker vs. Cockatrice

get it? cause a cockatrice is like a chicken? Chokers like to choke things? Oh, Gods am I funny or what!?!

FH

You should be ashamed. I should be more ashamed because I laughed pretty hard at that.

Jormungandr (Midgard Serpent) vs. Bambi.


I agree with any god vs any god, but who would, who could gm it and who would play each god; sheesh this is a gm nightmare if you actually make them fight.


Tarrasque v Tarrasque

Grendel v Grendel's Mom (Jerry Springer ain't got nothin' on this)

Really Ancient Old Great Wyrm Gold Dragon v Really Ancient Old Great Wyrm Red Dragon

Let's get ready to RUMMMMMMMMMMMMMBLLLLLLLLLLLE!!

And in this corner, we've got Schinitaryxellian, bringer of Light and bearer of Bahamut's Glory. And in the other corner, we have Gordianteroptyrantyx, scourge of the Seven Kingdoms and fiery Lord of the Lake of Fire! This is a champ-eeon-ship match, ladies and lords, winner takes all the land from the Green Sea to the Frozen Jungle.

*ding ding*

There's the bell!

....

Oh come on, I know I wouldn't be the only one at *that* fight. :-D


Iron Golem v. Shield Guardian
Githyanki v. Githzerai
Modron v. Slaad
Lammasu v. Heiracosphinx
Hippogriff v. Pegasus
Nymph v. Hag

I have weird tastes in fights, I know, but I have some theories behind each of these battles.


matt_the_dm wrote:

Vampire mind flayer vs. werebear war troll.

Werebear Wartroll... Now thats an awsome monster - I got to go make one of those just to see what level my PCs have to be to fight it.

Scarab Sages

Strahd v Azalin
or
Orcus v Demogorgon
or
Acererak v Keraptis


Changeling vs Changeling pick any class as desired; start at opposite gates of a city; they have to find and eliminate the other.


Chaos Beast v. Choo Choo Bear (read Something Positive)


Stone golem vs dire wraith

Displacer beast vs displacer beast

Drizzt vs Eclavadra (all those who know Greyhawk will know who I am talking about)

Black pudding vs ochre jelly (each starting 1 mile from the other at the start of the battle)

Green slime vs yellow mold

Dryad vs succubus (in a pit of mud or jello and wearing chainmail bikinis)

Mordekainen vs Elminster (in a pit of mud or jello and wearing chainmail bikinis)


Sebastian wrote:
Nermal2097 wrote:

Tarrasque v Everything else

:)

Tarrasque v. kobold!*

*Kobold gets a stick. Oooh! Stick!!!**

**And not the Order of the Stick either. A non-magical piece of wood. A club if you will.***

***This footnoting is excessive. A player in my AoW game has a wizard and didn't bother purchasing any weapons. After finding the abandoned mine house, they decided to set off for the Whispering Cairn. The wizard asks if there are any pieces of wood around. I tell him, sure, there's an old broken up table. He scavanges a leg from the table and declares that he is now armed with a club. He then proceeds to point out that the club does indeed cost 0gp according to the phb. He did manage to take out an opponent using said club, and thus I believe that a kobold with a similar stick, Str, and BAB could take out the Tarrasque.

I have a Kobold Paladin/ Mage that I took through the Shacked City Adventure Path that I would bet money on against a Tarrasque. I've never played a character that were so loved by the dice gods. At this point he has four dragons under his belt (Black Dragon scale of course.)

Scarab Sages

Phil. L wrote:

Mordekainen vs Elminster (in a pit of mud or jello and wearing chainmail bikinis)

You know, I love seeing Elminster mocked as much as the next guy, but that is not the type of image I wanted to start my day on. Please excuse me while I go douse my brain in bleach to try and clean that mental picture out.


Aberzombie wrote:
Phil. L wrote:

Mordekainen vs Elminster (in a pit of mud or jello and wearing chainmail bikinis)

You know, I love seeing Elminster mocked as much as the next guy, but that is not the type of image I wanted to start my day on. Please excuse me while I go douse my brain in bleach to try and clean that mental picture out.

Relax, they would be required to polymorph themselves into Salma Hayek before the match.

Now the only thing to wrack your psyche is the unnerving idea of getting turned on by two old guys wrestling.

The Exchange

Sexi Golem 01 wrote:
Aberzombie wrote:
Phil. L wrote:

Mordekainen vs Elminster (in a pit of mud or jello and wearing chainmail bikinis)

You know, I love seeing Elminster mocked as much as the next guy, but that is not the type of image I wanted to start my day on. Please excuse me while I go douse my brain in bleach to try and clean that mental picture out.

Relax, they would be required to polymorph themselves into Salma Hayek before the match.

Now the only thing to wrack your psyche is the unnerving idea of getting turned on by two old guys wrestling.

Please stop.

Scarab Sages

Okay then, back on topic. Some other fights I would love to see...

- A grell versus a roper.
- A mindflayer (with random thrall) versus a neogi (with umber hulk).

Scarab Sages

Joex The Pale wrote:

And my own choice...

As a serious match-up; Quickling vs. Troll. With the Quickling's massive speed and quick attacks matched up against a Troll's regeneration, could be interesting...

Did they ever update the quickling to 3.5?

Scarab Sages

I've had elementals on the brain lately, so I was wondering, have they ever done battles between elementals. I'd love to see a fire elemental vs a water elemental, or an earth elemental vs an air elemental. Hell, they could have one big elemental war.


Aberzombie wrote:
I've had elementals on the brain lately, so I was wondering, have they ever done battles between elementals. I'd love to see a fire elemental vs a water elemental, or an earth elemental vs an air elemental. Hell, they could have one big elemental war.

Elemental War -> Next Adeventure Path.

Kraken vs. Dragon Turtle
I'm thinking that this would be the typhoon-causing battle to end all sea chanteys.

And since I just found this thread I want to offer Ultradan a Twenty-one Shrieker Salute. Gentlefolk, aim your shriekers!


Twwwwweeeeeeeeeet!


Twwwooooooooootttt!

A friend and I once ran a tarrasque vs great gold wyrm match to see who would win. I made the mistake of playing the dragon - the tarrasque is far more straightforward in his combat options, whereas the dragon has complicated full attacks, a breath weapon, flight and spells.

Basically, the great gold wyrm would win - but only just. He uses his superior speed and flight to keep just out of the tarrasque's full attack range, while hitting him repeatedly with spells like polymorph any object to turn the tarrasque to stone. Eventually one such spell would hit, whereupon he could crush the tarrasque to dust and then use wish to keep it dead.

The tarrasque would win in a fair, toe-to-toe fight, but the dragon is under no obligation to provide such a fair fight.


a balor vs bone devil

balor vs a great wyrm crystal dragon

storm elemental vs cinder swarm

charnel hound vs feral yowler


Mind Flayer vs. Reason Stealer

Just some sick irony for those of us who don't get enough of that sort of thing...


Gelatinous Cube Vs. Will-O’-Wisp.

Just because it would be weird.

1 to 50 of 52 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Gamer Life / Gaming / D&D / 3.5/d20/OGL / X versus Y All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.