Wendel

Smiles-a-lot's page

155 posts (1,061 including aliases). No reviews. No lists. No wishlists. 27 aliases.


RSS

1 to 50 of 155 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | next > last >>

Your setting is very interesting and has my creative juices flowing…. I’m thinking inquisitor would be perfect… I should have some ideas fleshed out this weekend to bounce off you. The crunchy bits will take longer to come together.


Interested. 2e and Forgotten Realms is just about perfect.


Very interested. I’m thinking investigator (but we’ll see where my imagination takes me).


Select a stat array equivalent to 15-point buy;
S: 10 D: 17 (15+2) C: 12 I: 12 W: 10 Ch: 14 (12+2) (2, 7, 2, 2, 0, 2 = 15) After racial adjustments

Pick a class from among the Core classes, the Base classes excepting Summoner, the Hybrid classes, and Unchained Summoner (starting HP is maximized, starting wealth is average);
Vigilante (Teisatsu).

Pick a race
Halfling.

Pick a campaign trait from the Hell's Rebels Player's Guide, but it will not have any mechanical effect;
Historian of the Rebellion.

Pick a reason to protest from the Hell's Rebels Player's Guide;
Meeting a contact.

Set forth how you learned about the Aria Park demonstration (i.e., through word of mouth, from a handbill, from a poster, etc.); and
Word of mouth from one of his fellow servants/slaves at Aulamaxa manor.

Summarize your political sympathies and how you came by them, and what organizations you are a part of or orbit - the factions represented at Aria Park will include at least, in no particular order, liberals, radicals, anarchists, and Ravounel nationalists (these terms to have roughly the meanings they had in about 1850 in Europe - if you would like further explanation, please feel free to ask).
Mix a subjugated halfling population, repressive government, and instruction in Desna’s precepts and you get a liberal halfling looking for freedom. He is anti-slavery and anti-aristocracy and wants liberal reforms in Kintargo’s jurisprudence as well as the economic opportunities that come with these ideals. He has been trying to hook up with the silver ravens and has contacts with the bellflower network as well as desna’s hidden faithful.

I intend to stat him out and go into a more detailed origin/background sometime tomorrow (Tuesday, I am on US eastern time) afternoon


Still running through ideas. Quick question, is vigilante considered a base class?


Interested. I’ll see what I can cook up.


I haven’t submitted anything (and I’m not going too) but here are my thoughts:
1. Four weeks is a long time and two weeks is just about perfect.
2. I wouldn’t just end the recruiting I would give 24 hour notice.

Just my thoughts have fun.


Hmmm… I am thinking about submitting a Druid. I’ll throw out some ideas over the next couple of days.


I’ll have my warpriest done today


Nice rolls. Also, with lay on hands, smite, and heavy armor paladins are great frontliners. I think brvheart thinks we might need more than 1.


Lady Shakira Gabrielle Suna wrote:


I am not sure yet, but it looks like we have melee and divine covered. So I am thinking arcane or Striker type.

Magus?


Thanks that is helpful!

Edit: requested access to map.


Since I’ve settled on a class I should roll hit points
hp lvl 2: 1d8 ⇒ 7
hp lvl 3: 1d8 ⇒ 4
hp lvl 4: 1d8 ⇒ 8
hp lvl 5: 1d8 ⇒ 3
hp lvl 6: 1d8 ⇒ 1
hp lvl 6 Reroll: 1d8 ⇒ 5

Edit: I assumed max hit points at 1st level. Let me know if I’m wrong.


I will be putting together a Warpriest of Mitra.. more to come.


Dotting. Not sure what I’ll cook up … let me put some ideas together.


My advice is always play what the wife wants. ;)


I’d be interested in dark tower too. And if can’t get the band back together for your Razor’s Coast game I could wip something up.


Lice


Ripostes


Thrust


I’d be interested in of the frog god games stuff you’ve run (except rappan athuk I don’t feel like a dungeon craw). You might get more interest if you started a new recruitment. I’ve poke around your alias a bit and looks like you are using pathfinder rules and not swords & wizardry correct?


I am going to dot. To be upfront I have absolutely no experience with Starfinder but I’ve been looking things over and will try to put something together before the deadline (I still have a couple of hours). Right now I’m thinking a mechanic of some sort, possibly an android.


Hello again. I withdrew Bug-eyed Thom from from your other kingmaker recruitment because I didn’t think he was a good fit. I have another idea for a Skald. Painting in broad brushstrokes he will be an Ulfen hired as a bodyguard/fixer for a member of house Labeda. The member of the house wanted a bodyguard to be more like the Taldens and their kings by the use of an ulfen as a bodyguard and few having one as a status symbol.


Old School GM Obermind wrote:
Apologies to all in advance but I will put things on hold for now, while I mull over if this was actually a good idea or not in this format.

Sorry to hear that. Let us know what you decide.


hustonj wrote:
Smiles-a-lot wrote:
Right now I’m thinking about a varisian fortuneteller/harrow reader. Looking for something gish like with some personality.
Thaumaturge, perhaps?
Veegees wrote:
Like others have suggested thaumaturge could work. You could also go with oracle with the battle mystery for a similar gish like personality.

Those both looks good. Thanks for your help!


Right now I’m thinking about a varisian fortuneteller/harrow reader. Looking for something gish like with some personality.


Nice resource pinvendor. At the very least it gave me some ideas. Also, I’m still looking over the 2e classes trying to figure out what classes best captures my concepts.


Whoot. Thanks for running this! I’ll have something ready tomorrow still running through ideas.


@ HeIaman -think you get 6 non-combat skills. 3 for your class, 1 (trade or knowledge, pg35), 2 for your 8 intelligence (learning skills, pg35).

Unlike the optional extra combat skills based on intelligence the non-combat skills appear to be part of the core rules.


Oceanshieldwolf wrote:
Daniel Stewart wrote:
SO would it be possible to be a dwarf fighter/cleric?? Was looking over the character and thought it might give us a little edge with a dwarf in the group!!

I mean a dwarf’s axe will necessarily be smaller than a human’s…

I was mulling over being an elf or half-elf F/MU but I’m not sure I can bring myself to do it, and the 4 Wisdom really doesn’t help. For those of you familiar with Sarn, my low-Int cleric in Helaman’s OSR game, I’m quite interested in the difference between his “wise enough to recognise a good idea, but not smart enough to generate one” and this nascent low-Wis fighter - “super smart and capable of generate intelligent solutions, but not exactly wise enough to know whether they are actually a good idea to go ahead with.” Which makes both of them kinda irritating to be around socially. Sarn endlessly gets the wrong end of the stick, while this guy won’t know when to stop telling you things he’s thought of.

But generally, they are both friendly, helpful and love to hang out. And beat things to a pulp, because, you know…combat etc…

Looking forward to this. Sarn is great.


Daniel Stewart wrote:
SO would it be possible to be a dwarf fighter/cleric?? Was looking over the character and thought it might give us a little edge with a dwarf in the group!!

I like it.


If Alina ever gets class levels majordomo investigator might be a good fit.

Still working on my bard. I should have it. Done this weekend.


Daniel - I’ll check. I have the World of Greyhawk campaign setting books. I’ll see if I can find them.


^^ What he said.


Probably won’t be submitting any thing for this but I just wanted to drop in and say thanks for the guides you’ve done!


Helaman wrote:
So... reroll 4d6 and re-assemble as desired?

I think Reroll and switch one pair of stats.


Eric Swanson wrote:
I could swap out my CON for INT if you want a magic-user in the group ;)

My thoughts are play what you want. Party balance is overrated in my book.


No worries. Thanks for the update.


Oceanshieldwolf wrote:
So…everyone who has revealed their age is 50 or older. That leaves you and me, Obermind…my profile lists my age but is out of date. But how out of date is it? And is the GM the youngest of us all?!? Inquiring minds wish to know! Well, ok, OSW does…

My guess is that OSW keeps his profile pretty up to date so I’m thinking you are 47. As for the GM I do think he is the youngest about 45ish.


Sounds good. I’ll go thief or maybe a multi-class thief of some sort. Unless someone else has their hart set on thief then I’ll pivot to something else.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Once the GM decides about adjusting stats I’ll decide what to play….. luckily probably not a gnome. I am leaning toward something thief related but want to see what everyone else decides as I have several ideas percolating.

Just throwing out some ways I’ve seen stat adjustments work:

Reroll one stat.
Allow minus 2 to one stat to plus 1 to another stat (max -4/+2) no stat adjusted to lower than 8.
Switch 2 stats.
Reroll dice that come up as a 1
Turn one rolled 1 into a 6 (or 4 or 5)

I am also fine with anything else including rerolling (or not doing anything at all).


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Flanderdash wrote:


So, Paladin maybe?

Edit:
Ability Requirements: Str 12, Con 9, Wis 13, and Cha 17
Prime Requisite: Str and Cha 16+

Ah, well. Guess not.

I think you still can as the GM wrote earlier in character creation about “Removing ability and race requirements from individual classes, but keep the XP bonus for high main stat”


Looks like:
STR 12
DEX 16
CON 14
INT13
WIS 12
CHA 10


I don’t see different time zones being an issue. Plus, if I ever get to Europe, Canada, or Australia I’ll have people to visit. :)

Edit: posted while you posted about rolling

4d6: 4d6 ⇒ (2, 6, 1, 4) = 13
4d6: 4d6 ⇒ (6, 5, 4, 5) = 20
4d6: 4d6 ⇒ (6, 2, 2, 6) = 16
4d6: 4d6 ⇒ (3, 4, 3, 6) = 16
4d6: 4d6 ⇒ (3, 6, 1, 3) = 13
4d6: 4d6 ⇒ (3, 2, 2, 5) = 12


Thanks again for running this!

Here is a bit about me… I’ve been playing rpgs since Jr High in 1982 with basic, expert, and ad&d. Along the way I’ve played a bunch of other systems (Star Frontiers, Boot Hill, Gangbusters, Marvel Superheroes, Traveller, GURPS, Mouseguard, and many more) but fantasy settings are my favorite. I’ve made lifelong friends through gaming and have been playing pathfinder 1e, biweekly, with the same group, and some of our grown kids now, since 2010.

On a personal note I’m a 53 years old male originally from NY but have lived in the Midwest (Indiana) (UTC-5)for the last 28 years. I have 2 kids (one in college) and have been married for 23 years. I too work from home 2-3 days a week. As far as other hobbies go I am a voracious reader, very amateur guitar player, firearms enthusiast, and avid board gamer who likes to cook (I know, my wife hit the jackpot). I also enjoy playing Baldur’s Gate ee on my iPad when I have time.

For pbp I have the time to post everyday and my life is pretty scheduled so I will be able to give you notice of anything that will impact my posting.


Dot. Thinking about some thing bardish


Thanks for the invite!

Looks like fun. See comments below
===========================

These are currently under consideration (compiled from several different sources):

Character Creation
Sounds good to me. Either stat generation method is fine

Miscellaneous
I think dual class for humans only is fine.
Always wanted to try weapon speeds too.
Critical hits & misses yes. Max damage is fine.
Perception stat is worth a try. It can be changed later if needed.

Overall it sounds like fun! Let’s give it a go!

rolling rampage suspended :(


GM Nightfiend wrote:


Trying to hammer down all these timelines has been interesting. From what I can tell he ascended sometime in 2765 AD. Based on this. Cayden Cailean Now there is a chance that this information is CRAP. (Shrug) If someone has a better source with more accurate info, let me know.

If anyone else is interested in Galarion timelines, I found this to be helpful. Golarion Timelines To move the timeline chart, click it and drag it.

That is very helpful. Great Resource! Thanks.


DM DoctorEvil wrote:
Mostly, the rules will be secondary to the story and the roleplay, so don't fret too much about it. Just bring the adventuring spirit.

With that approach I’ll play anything you run but I think some APs naturally lend themselves to this. My first vote would still be curse of the crimson throne for this reason. However, I haven’t played it so take it for what it is worth.


Nice! I’ve always wanted to play curse of the crimson throne, hell’s rebles, or war for the crown. I’d be interested to see how 2e’s changes affect the social aspects of these APs.

Good luck.


Sign in to create or edit a product review.

Add PDF $19.99

Add Print Edition $19.99 $10.00

Non-Mint Unavailable

My favorite Adventure Path so far!

5/5

UPDATE: This is the LONGEST adventure path module by far. We have been on this module twice as long as any other AP in the series. Very fun, but it maybe could have been broken into two.

I have to say, this adventure path is probably the most fun of all of the Skull and Shackles Adventure paths to date.

The PC's have a solid mission and have a great motivation to seek out and complete each of this module's challenges. The AP starts with the Pirates gaining status and being able to take part diplomatically in pirate matters in the Shackles. The mechanics for this arrangement work well, and the case being made for each is interesting to Role Play. A page with all of the NPC portraits on one page would have added visual props.

The onus on the PC's to build a fleet is exciting, although the amount of money the Pirates need as opposed to what they have found across the last four modules is insufficient. I luckily read ahead and planted some extra plunder among the various wreckage's on the Island of Empty Eyes. The pirates COULD just spend a couple of weeks grinding away on pirate ship encounters from module one and two, but that tends to be anti-climatic and the group would rather do new stuff.

The quests and places for adventure are well thought out, difficult and exciting. The various challenges and the rewards for completing each give a sense of accomplishment. There is also some final closure to the PC's longstanding rivalry with a competing free captain of the Shackles.

The overarching storyline about warring nations is almost not needed in the AP as it adds little in the way of motivation for pirates, they could have had the rivalry be somewhat more local instead of geopolitical.

That aside, the adventure path is outstanding and the players are having a blast with it. They are excited to finish up in module 6.


Excellent Adventure for my campaign

5/5

I may be biased in my review due to a major plot item interacting perfectly with my particular campaign and characters, but nonetheless I feel the need to give the AP 5 stars.

The premise is the only somewhat shaky leg of the AP, and the players are kind of like "we have to prove ourselves AGAIN?!" That sentiment is quickly discarded however as the adventure gets underway. Meanwhile the addition of cyclopes as a major element is welcome; it is nice to see classical fantasy elements included in an AP, and their inclusion on the cover and back indicate that they are a major part of the AP.

The tragic NPC and his/her dilemma sets my PC's up perfectly and the ultimate plot payoff can differ somewhat from the AP in my campaign depending upon what the affected PC decides to do with the clues given. The maps included are detailed and I would like a flip mat of the ultimate ruins included in the AP. I was going to enlarge the map to 1":5' scale and print it in tiles on the printer but it ended up being over 120 pages!!! Using that much printer paper and spending that much time taping the sheets together would be cost/time prohibitive. Not to mention the file becomes cumbersome when enlarged to 90x126. Would the market be large enough to support a flip mat? I am not so sure. A printed paper map poster possibly. $9.99??

I like this AP and liked how it flowed coherently from start to finish. Tempest Rising, while excellently written and intriguing was jumbled up somewhat, not gaining its sea-legs until act 3. Isle of empty eyes flows smoothly from start to finish and very little GM work is required to make this AP fun and exciting.


Great Writing - Lack of Maps

3/5

I purchased this to help flesh out the individual isles in the Skull and Shackles Adventure path. I was happy that the writing encompassed the isles, but unfortunately there are NO maps of the isles in the gazetteer. A gazetteer without some maps is like a pirate ship without a crew. The Inner Sea World Guide is how each campaign setting supplement should be written. Yes, making maps of the isles and of the major ports of call is tedious; however once the work is accomplished, it is done forever and the world gets more detailed and more fleshed out. If it is too difficult to map from scratch, use Google maps to overlay existing locales on Earth like the Marshall Islands, and illustrate the overlay into a map for the guide.

I really don't need more monsters. Between the Bestiaries, the AP's and the campaign settings, we are being overwhelmed by monsters. Save those monsters for the AP's or for campaign specific bestiaries and flesh out the campaign resources with more MAPS.


Paizo needs plot flow charts

3/5

This adventure is pretty fun for my players right now, but the hodge-podge of clues and intrigue points starts to make running the adventure somewhat tedious.

I propose that Paizo include one page in each adventure path that details all of the plot progression points in a flow chart, or plot circle fashion so the GM can easily track the plot and can navigate the adventure without having to jump around in the book randomly to try set up his/her own plot flow chart.

I think this simple inclusion would make Tempest rising and other adventure paths more exciting to run and less tedious for GMs

[update 2/7/2013] The players finished this AP. The beginning portion of the AP was basically skipped over due to the fact that the contests and the whole setup felt somewhat contrived with a nobody orc insinuating himself into the pirate's lives. The second part of the AP was the most difficult as it was a large intrigue involving many NPC's and locales. I purchased the Isles of the Shackles supplement to augment the locales with hopefully some visuals (maps of the ports of call) but was disappointed that it didn't contain island maps I needed to make the locales come to life.
The AP picked up noticeably towards the end with the regatta, and the players were noticeably more excited to get involved in a seafaring adventure at the end of the AP. The way scoring was done worked well and the introduction of the PC's nemesis gave them some motivation.

Overall, I would have liked to have seen the locales fleshed out more. The inner sea world guide is replete with maps of each locale in the book and the middle part of the adventure would have been better served by having some visual aides.


The first AP I've run in Pathfinder

4/5

The Good: The adventurers have a nice mix of shipboard life, land-lubbing autonomy, and the NPC's detailed are fleshed out nicely and really come to life.

The Bad: The endless days upon ship splitting up tasks amongst four players can get tedious and drag on as each gets multiple interaction (separate....DON'T SPLIT THE PARTY)opportunities every day.

The Ugly: Some NPC's weren't fleshed out at all, and so it was hard to divert PC attention from some of the key crew members. Exploring the ship stealthily seemed a little contrived and farfetched for my taste.

The Wormwood Mutiny is a fun way to get the characters into the pirate way of life. I agree with the press-gang mentality of the adventure, and I basically started the PC's with little to nothing in the way of gear and everything they got was scrounged up.

There wasn't enough info on the Wormwood's magic user, Longfarthing, but the rest of the PC's were pretty well fleshed out.

The end scene was a little too much Roger-Rabbit for my likes and I had to modify the ending somewhat to make due in the interest of time.

I wasn't much of a fan with the dynamic of sneaking around the ship, it seems a little too contrived and with no where to go, anyone stealing something could be caught with a full ship health-and-welfare inspection. Also the number of days spent on sea had to be compressed somewhat as 17-odd days of doing the tasks and having each player in their own little world interacting with PC's can make for very loooong drawn out gaming sessions.

Overall I think the adventure went well and the party was excited to exact their revenge upon Plugg and Scourge, the fact that the players had such enmity against the antagonists means that the press-ganging and pirate justice had the desired effect. These NPC's were not just regarded with the usual apathy that villains usually engender.

All in all four stars.