|
|
RPG Superstar™ 2012 General Discussion
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Official "Critique My Item" Thread
(Sticky)
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Neil Spicer,
RonarsCorruption,
terraleon
and
54
others
|
1,111
posts
|
by Template Fu
|
|
|
|
The Unofficial Top 32 Guildhall: End of the Mayan Calendar Edition
|
|
by Eric Morton
—
Mike Welham,
Hodge Podge,
JaceDK
and
23
others
|
840
posts
|
by Andrew Marlowe
|
|
|
|
Superstar 2013 - Practice #1 - Closing 20th February
|
|
by Anthony Adam
—
PhelanArcetus,
AHalflingNotAHobbit,
Anthony Adam
and
16
others
|
191
posts
|
by Andrew Black
|
|
|
|
Voluntary Reject Bin 2012, or, "What was I THINKING?"
|
|
by Sean McGowan
—
RonarsCorruption,
motteditor,
Steven T. Helt
and
49
others
|
191
posts
|
by Sam Polak
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: Round 2 Challenge Preview--Organization Name
|
|
by LoreKeeper
—
Anthony Adam,
Sean K Reynolds,
Thomas LeBlanc
and
59
others
|
170
posts
|
by Tacticslion
|
|
|
|
Another over word count entry--truly unbelievable
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Clark Peterson,
Matthew Morris,
Neil Spicer
and
67
others
|
151
posts
|
by Ziv Wities
|
|
|
|
I feel like I'm in Bizzaro world.
|
|
by Andrew Christian
—
Clark Peterson,
Andrew Christian,
Mike Welham
and
47
others
|
142
posts
|
by Hyla
|
|
|
|
Neil's Feedback: Selected, In-Depth Item Reviews
|
|
by Neil Spicer
—
Neil Spicer,
Wild Gazebo,
Vic Wertz
and
39
others
|
128
posts
|
by Bombadil
|
|
|
|
Disappointing (Edit: No, just tired and grumpy :))
|
|
by Evil Midnight Lurker
—
Clark Peterson,
Neil Spicer,
JaceDK
and
49
others
|
123
posts
|
by Set
|
|
|
|
Sean's consolidated advice thread
(Sticky)
|
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Sean K Reynolds,
Neil Spicer,
Kerney
and
43
others
|
123
posts
|
by Azoun The Sage
|
|
|
|
All Items Sorted, So Begins "The Winnowing"
|
|
by Neil Spicer
—
Neil Spicer,
Tacticslion,
Anthony Adam
and
48
others
|
111
posts
|
by Tacticslion
|
|
|
|
"Wonderous" Items vs. "Wondrous" Items
|
|
by Neil Spicer
—
Neil Spicer,
Matthew Morris,
Captain Brittannica
and
40
others
|
109
posts
|
by LazarX
|
|
|
|
No Backstory!!!
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Matthew Morris,
The Sinister Chris,
Clark Peterson
and
41
others
|
96
posts
|
by Walter Sheppard
|
|
|
|
Common themes and items
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Clark Peterson,
Set,
RonarsCorruption
and
51
others
|
94
posts
|
by Thomas LeBlanc
|
|
|
|
Showing improvement
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Anthony Adam,
Neil Spicer,
Shadowborn
and
40
others
|
94
posts
|
by Iain Reid
|
|
|
|
On-going Practice thread for the next competition
|
|
by Anthony Adam
—
Anthony Adam,
motteditor,
AHalflingNotAHobbit
and
12
others
|
92
posts
|
by Curaigh
|
|
|
|
Catharsis
|
|
by Kevin Mickelson
—
Kevin Mickelson,
Mairkurion {tm},
Thomas LeBlanc
and
48
others
|
88
posts
|
by Kevin Mickelson
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: RPG SuperstarTM 2012: Mike Welham!
|
|
by Mark Moreland
—
Mike Welham,
Neil Spicer,
Zark
and
73
others
|
87
posts
|
by Zark
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: RPG SuperstarTM 2012 Top 32 Revealed
|
|
by John Bennett
—
Shadow-Mask,
Thomas LeBlanc,
Cydeth
and
65
others
|
87
posts
|
by Garrett Guillotte
|
|
|
|
Anyone interested in collaborating a wondrous item for fun?
|
|
by ArchMageMyrrendor
—
ArchMageMyrrendor,
OwlbearRepublic,
Mikko Kallio
and
17
others
|
87
posts
|
by ArchMageMyrrendor
|
|
|
|
Discuss Your Creative Process!
|
|
by Chris Shaeffer
—
RonarsCorruption,
Shadowborn,
SmiloDan
and
47
others
|
87
posts
|
by Tacticslion
|
|
|
|
Round 5 Exit Poll
|
|
by Lukas Klausner
—
Neil Spicer,
Epic Meepo,
Cheapy
and
47
others
|
86
posts
|
by Eric Morton
|
|
|
|
If I submit my item, and I lose, do I still forfeit ownership to Paizo?
|
|
by Demonskunk
—
Seth White,
Vic Wertz,
Hitdice
and
43
others
|
85
posts
|
by Garrett Guillotte
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: RPG Superstar: Item Feedback
|
|
by Benjamin Medrano
—
Sean K Reynolds,
Sasayaki,
Sgmendez
and
28
others
|
85
posts
|
by Sean K Reynolds
|
|
|
|
Round 2: The Home Edition
|
|
by Garrett Guillotte
—
OwlbearRepublic,
PhineasGage,
Mr. Swagger
and
23
others
|
83
posts
|
by Kris Newton
|
|
|
|
You don't have to "win" to "win"--so ENTER!
|
|
|
77
posts
|
by Curaigh
|
|
|
|
What's Your Top 5 Favorite Wondrous Item Submissions?
|
|
by Neil Spicer
—
motteditor,
Anthony Adam,
Curaigh
and
47
others
|
76
posts
|
by David Ludwig
|
|
|
|
Round 1 Template Explained
|
|
by Anthony Adam
—
Anthony Adam,
Sean K Reynolds,
gbonehead
and
19
others
|
75
posts
|
by Anthony Adam
|
|
|
|
Top 32: How did we get there?
|
|
by Mikko Kallio
—
Mike Welham,
Mikko Kallio,
Mark Hart
and
24
others
|
74
posts
|
by Adam Donald
|
|
|
|
Flex your creative muscle with the Random Magic Item Generator
|
|
by Jeff Lee
—
Shadowborn,
Standback,
OwlbearRepublic
and
39
others
|
69
posts
|
by Debihuman
|
|
|
|
It's almost Top 32 time... a few words
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
LoreKeeper,
Shadowborn,
IvanSanchez
and
54
others
|
68
posts
|
by Benjamin Medrano
|
|
|
|
What is your favorite core wondrous item?
|
|
by Mike Kimmel
—
Mike Kimmel,
Curaigh,
surfbored
and
47
others
|
68
posts
|
by benjover
|
|
|
|
Top 32: Create a new organization - What are your thoughts?
|
|
by Herremann the Wise
—
Kerney,
RonarsCorruption,
Steven T. Helt
and
34
others
|
66
posts
|
by Chad Bartlett
|
|
|
|
The thoughts of a first time entrant.
|
|
by michael peitersen
—
Tacticslion,
Neil Spicer,
Anthony Adam
and
44
others
|
66
posts
|
by Matt Banach
|
|
|
|
Congrats to all who entered -- and good luck!
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Clark Peterson,
Neil Spicer,
Dagesk Kingdomworthy
and
39
others
|
64
posts
|
by Rorenado
|
|
|
|
RPG SuperStar 2012 Total Number of Round 1 Entries?
|
|
by ValmarTheMad
—
ArchMageMyrrendor,
Neil Spicer,
Vic Wertz
and
29
others
|
62
posts
|
by Andrew Christian
|
|
|
|
Come on and Submit! It's not too late and you can still make the cut
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Clark Peterson,
CuttinCurt,
JaceDK
and
35
others
|
61
posts
|
by Anthony Adam
|
|
|
|
Remember people, this is RPG-Freaking-SuperStar!
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Clark Peterson,
CuttinCurt,
GoldenOpal
and
40
others
|
61
posts
|
by Anthony Adam
|
|
|
|
Question about Feedback
|
|
by Feral
—
Feral,
Clark Peterson,
Neil Spicer
and
21
others
|
53
posts
|
by speed66
|
|
|
|
So, you want to do this because...
|
|
by marv
—
marv,
Clark Peterson,
Pen2paper
and
28
others
|
53
posts
|
by Paul Brown
|
|
|
|
And Now We're Down to the "Golden Tickets"...
|
|
by Neil Spicer
—
AdamWarnock,
Neil Spicer,
OwlbearRepublic
and
33
others
|
52
posts
|
by Mark Hart
|
|
|
|
"Glittering Generalities," and other fun phrases
|
|
by Chris Shaeffer
—
Andrew Christian,
Hodge Podge,
InVinoVeritas
and
17
others
|
51
posts
|
by Saint Trickery
|
|
|
|
Formatting - Ack!
|
|
by Anthony Adam
—
Anthony Adam,
Clark Peterson,
RonarsCorruption
and
25
others
|
51
posts
|
by Xaaon of Xen'Drik
|
|
|
|
Round 2 Exit Poll - Create an Organizaton
|
|
by Caedwyr
—
Pedro Coelho,
Chad Bartlett,
Kradlum
and
32
others
|
49
posts
|
by Chad Bartlett
|
|
|
|
Anyone Else Having Trouble Voting?
|
|
by James Raine
—
Gary Teter,
Seabyrn,
Drejk
and
28
others
|
49
posts
|
by Seabyrn
|
|
|
|
How I blew it.
|
|
by ciretose
—
Clark Peterson,
Deiros,
Anthony Adam
and
25
others
|
48
posts
|
by Deiros
|
|
|
|
Entered all five years?
|
|
by Nickolas Floyd
—
Phloid,
Sebastian Hirsch,
Xaaon of Korvosa
and
20
others
|
48
posts
|
by Neil Spicer
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: It's RPG Superstar Time!
|
|
by the Haunted Jester
—
Matthew Morris,
Dennis Baker,
Jim Groves
and
27
others
|
48
posts
|
by Dennis Baker
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: RPG SuperstarTM Top 8 Announced!
|
|
by dinketry
—
Sean K Reynolds,
Mairkurion {tm},
Clark Peterson
and
31
others
|
46
posts
|
by steelhead
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: Round 1 Deadline is Tomorrow!
|
|
by LoreKeeper
—
Draconas,
Anthony Adam,
AdAstraGames
and
24
others
|
45
posts
|
by Curaigh
|
|
|
|
Advice Thread from Non-Judge Observers
|
|
by Jonasty1031
—
Neil Spicer,
Clark Peterson,
JSollars
and
28
others
|
44
posts
|
by Eric Hindley
|
|
|
|
Some Common Misteps I'm Seeing This Year
|
|
by Nazard
—
InVinoVeritas,
RonarsCorruption,
Nazard
and
19
others
|
43
posts
|
by Deiros
|
|
|
|
What the Heck is a Gyst? — In Defense of Obscure Language
|
|
by Evil Lincoln
—
Evil Lincoln,
Stormfriend,
BigNorseWolf
and
17
others
|
41
posts
|
by Celestial Healer
|
|
|
|
Another Superstar season coming up, I can feel it....
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Anthony Adam,
motteditor,
Curaigh
and
12
others
|
36
posts
|
by Curaigh
|
|
|
|
Round 4 Exit Poll (Design Encounter with Map)
|
|
by steelhead
—
steelhead,
Pedro Coelho,
Clark Peterson
and
21
others
|
36
posts
|
by Pedro Coelho
|
|
|
|
I'm getting geeked...
|
|
|
36
posts
|
by Jerett Schaufele
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: RPG SuperstarTM: Top 4 Announced!
|
|
by Cheapy
—
Todd Stewart,
Neil Spicer,
Mark Moreland
and
26
others
|
34
posts
|
by Laithoron
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: RPG Superstar: Encounter Challenge Preview
|
|
by Ian Eastmond
—
Neil Spicer,
Dhampir984,
Draconas
and
18
others
|
34
posts
|
by Steve Miller
|
|
|
|
Round 3 Exit Poll - Create a CR 7 Golarion monster
|
|
by Deidre Tiriel
—
Pedro Coelho,
Clouds Without Water,
Mikko Kallio
and
26
others
|
34
posts
|
by Jerall Toi
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: Words from the RPG Superstar Trenches
|
|
by LoreKeeper
—
Noteleks,
marv,
Clark Peterson
and
24
others
|
34
posts
|
by Daniel Rust
|
|
|
|
Neil Spicer: Editors' Choice Judge
|
|
by F. Wesley Schneider
—
Clark Peterson,
Neil Spicer,
F. Wesley Schneider
and
16
others
|
32
posts
|
by Clark Peterson
|
|
|
|
Ultimate Equipment congratulations!
|
|
by Eric Hindley
—
JaceDK,
Curaigh,
Tom Qadim
and
12
others
|
31
posts
|
by Will Cooper
|
|
|
|
So, the wait begins, that must mean it's that time... Fun Time
|
|
by Anthony Adam
—
Anthony Adam,
Luthia,
ArchMageMyrrendor
and
14
others
|
31
posts
|
by AdamWarnock
|
|
|
|
Submission issue?
|
|
by James Olchak
—
Daniel Rust,
OamuTheMonk,
Neil Spicer
and
10
others
|
29
posts
|
by Anthony Adam
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: RPG Superstar: Monster Stat Block Preview--Notes for the Competitors
|
|
by Dragon78
—
Dragon78,
Hodge Podge,
motteditor
and
18
others
|
29
posts
|
by RonarsCorruption
|
|
|
|
A Message For The Top 8 - Keep Your Eye On The Prize!
|
|
by Neil Spicer
—
Neil Spicer,
Power Word Unzip,
terraleon
and
13
others
|
28
posts
|
by Power Word Unzip
|
|
|
|
+10 skill bonuses
|
|
by Luthia
—
Bob Drouin,
Clark Peterson,
Neil Spicer
and
14
others
|
28
posts
|
by Bob Drouin
|
|
|
|
Exploring the mysteries of item pricing
|
|
by Jeff Lee
—
Shadowborn,
Neil Spicer,
RonarsCorruption
and
16
others
|
27
posts
|
by Luthia
|
|
|
|
GM discretion vs. RAW?
|
|
by Buckinin
—
Buckinin,
Dennis Baker,
RonarsCorruption
and
15
others
|
27
posts
|
by Luthia
|
|
|
|
Round 1 Template (continued)
|
|
by Anthony Adam
—
Anthony Adam,
Ian Eastmond,
Cheapy
and
8
others
|
25
posts
|
by Clark Peterson
|
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: Status Report: RPG Superstar 2012
|
|
by baron arem heshvaun
—
John Benbo,
Neil Spicer,
Sean K Reynolds
and
19
others
|
25
posts
|
by Fredrik
|
|
|
|
RPG Superstar 2013?
|
|
by Goraxes
—
Bombadil,
motteditor,
Neil Spicer
and
14
others
|
24
posts
|
by Jacob Trier
|
|
|
|
Top 4--A trip down memory lane
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Clark Peterson,
Neil Spicer,
Cheapy
and
9
others
|
24
posts
|
by Jeremiziah
|
|
|
|
Reflection on the why
|
|
by Anthony Adam
—
Thomas LeBlanc,
Mikko Kallio,
Clark Peterson
and
15
others
|
24
posts
|
by Mikko Kallio
|
|
|
|
Disqualification
|
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Bob Drouin,
Hodge Podge,
Kain Darkwind
and
17
others
|
23
posts
|
by Bob Drouin
|
|
|
|
Top 16 Round 3 Monster Mash is on!
|
|
by Scott Fernandez
—
Thomas LeBlanc,
King of Vrock,
Curaigh
and
17
others
|
22
posts
|
by Thomas LeBlanc
|
|
|
|
Question About Round 4
|
|
by Alex Head
—
Alex Head,
Luthia,
James Jacobs
and
9
others
|
22
posts
|
by RonarsCorruption
|
|
|
|
Clarifications on the monster round
|
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Bob Drouin,
Hodge Podge,
Fax Celestis
and
9
others
|
21
posts
|
by Chris Shaeffer
|
|
|
|
It's official! Superstar 2012 is here! It is ON, so get to work!
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Matthew Morris,
Steven T. Helt,
Seth White
and
16
others
|
21
posts
|
by Matthew Morris
|
|
|
|
Round 3 Home Edition
|
|
by Dan Jones
—
SmiloDan,
motteditor,
Curaigh
and
4
others
|
20
posts
|
by Nicos
|
|
|
|
Attention Top 32: Sit down, shut up, be happy!
|
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Neil Spicer,
Epic Meepo,
Sean K Reynolds
and
13
others
|
19
posts
|
by Chad Bartlett
|
|
|
|
The GOAL versus the TASK--a funny observation about the first round by Clark
|
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Clark Peterson,
Matthew Morris,
RonarsCorruption
and
6
others
|
19
posts
|
by Matthew Morris
|
|
|
|
Can a weapon be a wondrous item for the purpose of the contest?
|
|
by ciretose
—
AdamWarnock,
Neil Spicer,
ciretose
and
8
others
|
18
posts
|
by AdamWarnock
|
|
|
|
Reimagining the Monk: Why not make it an RPG Superstar Competition?
|
|
|
16
posts
|
by Dabbler
|
|
|
|
A message to all who entered
|
|
by Gerrard Dixon
—
Anthony Adam,
Alex Head,
Cieran Esthravau
and
11
others
|
16
posts
|
by Cieran Esthravau
|
|
|
|
Some rules questions
|
|
by Dragon78
—
Wild Gazebo,
Herremann the Wise,
Mike Kimmel
and
8
others
|
16
posts
|
by Matthew Morris
|
|
|
|
Encounter CR vs Party Level
|
|
by Caineach
—
Andrew Christian,
Neil Spicer,
Caineach
and
8
others
|
15
posts
|
by Andrew Christian
|
|
|
|
Introducing the official RPG Superstar 2012 Jacob avatar
|
|
by Jacob Trier
—
JaceDK,
Jiggy,
Bruno Kristensen
and
8
others
|
14
posts
|
by Bruno Kristensen
|
|
|
|
Superstar chat tonight (Thursday) 9pm ET at Beautiful Brains
|
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Neil Spicer,
Hodge Podge,
Curaigh
and
3
others
|
14
posts
|
by Chris Shaeffer
|
|
|
|
Moonbrook's Marble
|
|
by Ryan Dancey
—
OamuTheMonk,
AHalflingNotAHobbit,
Ryan Dancey
and
5
others
|
13
posts
|
by gbonehead
|
|
|
|
Question for the judges about Round 4 dates
|
|
by Tom Phillips
—
Clark Peterson,
Tom Qadim,
Curaigh
and
7
others
|
13
posts
|
by Curaigh
|
|
|
|
Non acceptance Round 2 purge
|
|
by Samuel Grundy
—
Samuel Grundy,
Vic Wertz,
King of Vrock
and
6
others
|
13
posts
|
by Vic Wertz
|
|
|
|
Round Two - Organization Feedback a few days early
|
|
by Herremann the Wise
—
Luthia,
OwlbearRepublic,
Stormfriend
and
8
others
|
13
posts
|
by Andrew Newton
|
|
|
|
Review My Item
|
|
by Sasayaki
—
Sasayaki,
Curaigh,
RonarsCorruption
and
9
others
|
13
posts
|
by Curaigh
|
|
|
|
Once more, with feeling
|
|
by Jacob Kellogg
—
Fax Celestis,
Jiggy,
Mark Hart
and
6
others
|
12
posts
|
by Will Cooper
|
|
|
|
Can I use non-Core spells for prerequisites?
|
|
by uriel222
—
DankeSean,
BQ,
Neil Spicer
and
5
others
|
12
posts
|
by Sean McGowan
|
|
|
|
Auto-Reject 9, intellectual property and inspiration...
|
|
by Luthia
—
Luthia,
ArchMageMyrrendor,
Hydro
and
6
others
|
12
posts
|
by Luthia
|
|
|
|
RPG Superstar Simon Cowell?
|
|
by James Conder
—
Anthony Adam,
Clark Peterson,
Wild Gazebo
and
5
others
|
11
posts
|
by Anthony Adam
|
|
|
|
For those of us playtesting...
|
|
by RonarsCorruption
—
MicMan,
RonarsCorruption,
Sean K Reynolds
and
5
others
|
11
posts
|
by MicMan
|
|
|
|
Round 6: All Jacobs fight in Thunderdome for right to dragon-scribe avatar
|
|
by Mike Schneider
—
Jiggy,
JaceDK,
Thomas LeBlanc
and
6
others
|
11
posts
|
by Jacob Kellogg
|
|
|
|
