
avr |

I suspect the balancing factor, such as it is, is needing a fistful of material from a plane with the {element}-dominant trait as a material component. Which would be tricky to acquire and too bulky to fit lots of in most spell component pouches. Otherwise yes it looks like a straight upgrade on fire shield, though at a spell level 1 higher for most casters.
Edit: though I think SR: yes is the default.