
thecursor |

Need them to be made playable.
Can you truly make the ultimate source for truth and goodness playable? Really? That's like making Mister Rogers President, it would be great but probably not going to happen.
I want to believe that when we finally meet the Flumphs at the end of a long AP, they'll say thank you for dealing with the small stuff while they took out the guy trying to unmake the universe.

Dracomicron |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |

I actually statted them in this forum on April 23rd, 2018: (presented with minor edits)
Pagan priest wrote:Well, there is a creature in the Bestiaries whose description starts out with "Come from distant stars to protect unprepared worlds from cosmic horrors..." Starfinder cannot possibly be complete without the Flumph.Last night as I was picking a friend up from the airport, I had the sudden realization that Starfinder may well be my first and only opportunity to play a Flumph. I'm thinking:
Flumph
+2 Dex, +2 Wis, -2 Str
2 HP
Small aberration with the "Flumph" subtype
Move 10' land, 25' fly
Natural Weapons - 1d3 acid & piercing, otherwise as per Vesk
Darkvision 60'
Stench Spray- cause Sickened for 1d4 rounds, DC 10+primary ability+half level, usable once per 10 minute rest.

johnlocke90 |
FormerFiend wrote:Need them to be made playable.Can you truly make the ultimate source for truth and goodness playable? Really? That's like making Mister Rogers President, it would be great but probably not going to happen.
I want to believe that when we finally meet the Flumphs at the end of a long AP, they'll say thank you for dealing with the small stuff while they took out the guy trying to unmake the universe.
Also, WOTC owns them, so good luck with that.

Dracomicron |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |

thecursor wrote:Also, WOTC owns them, so good luck with that.FormerFiend wrote:Need them to be made playable.Can you truly make the ultimate source for truth and goodness playable? Really? That's like making Mister Rogers President, it would be great but probably not going to happen.
I want to believe that when we finally meet the Flumphs at the end of a long AP, they'll say thank you for dealing with the small stuff while they took out the guy trying to unmake the universe.
I don't think that's true.
beholder, gauth, carrion crawler, tanar’ri, baatezu, displacer beast, githyanki, githzerai, mindflayer, illithid, umber hulk,yuan-ti
No Flumph there. Also they were portrayed in a Paizo product previously.

![]() |

I actually statted them in this forum on April 23rd, 2018: (presented with minor edits)
Dracomicron wrote:Pagan priest wrote:Well, there is a creature in the Bestiaries whose description starts out with "Come from distant stars to protect unprepared worlds from cosmic horrors..." Starfinder cannot possibly be complete without the Flumph.Last night as I was picking a friend up from the airport, I had the sudden realization that Starfinder may well be my first and only opportunity to play a Flumph. I'm thinking:
Flumph
+2 Dex, +2 Wis, -2 Str
2 HP
Small aberration with the "Flumph" subtype
Move 10' land, 25' fly
Natural Weapons - 1d3 acid & piercing, otherwise as per Vesk
Darkvision 60'
Stench Spray- cause Sickened for 1d4 rounds, DC 10+primary ability+half level, usable once per 10 minute rest.
Their flight should specifically be magical (and therefore still work even in vacuum).

LuisCarlos17Fe |
You can't use the name flumph, but you could create a similar creature and with a different name. For example some videogames where they can't use the D&D beholder the monster is "gazer".
Other option would be like a Paizo_WotC "intercompany crossover", a special event like Marvel vs DC. Who would buy this? Collectors and speculators.

Dracomicron |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

You can't use the name flumph, but you could create a similar creature and with a different name. For example some videogames where they can't use the D&D beholder the monster is "gazer".
Other option would be like a Paizo_WotC "intercompany crossover", a special event like Marvel vs DC. Who would buy this? Collectors and speculators.
As we previously discussed, Flumphs aren't proprietary.

![]() |

How do people not know that Paizo has been using Flumphs for years? Like they're in Bestiary one or two?
It may be more that that D&D included them in the base Monster Manual for 5e and having them actually feature in mainstream published adventures like Out of the Abyss instead of treating them like an embarrassment to be buried in more obscure supplements and only starring in third-party or homebrew adventures, and as a punchline in "Top 10 Stupidest D&D Monsters" list articles, as they were in previous editions.
What they may be thinking is, because the flumph is getting more mainstream attention from WotC, they may be more protective of the flumph now than they were in 1e Pathfinder's heyday, making them more likely to try and block Paizo from continuing to use the flumph. I don't know enough about copyright law to know if that reasoning is correct, though...

Garretmander |

thecursor wrote:How do people not know that Paizo has been using Flumphs for years? Like they're in Bestiary one or two?It may be more that that D&D included them in the base Monster Manual for 5e and having them actually feature in mainstream published adventures like Out of the Abyss instead of treating them like an embarrassment to be buried in more obscure supplements and only starring in third-party or homebrew adventures, and as a punchline in "Top 10 Stupidest D&D Monsters" list articles, as they were in previous editions.
What they may be thinking is, because the flumph is getting more mainstream attention from WotC, they may be more protective of the flumph now than they were in 1e Pathfinder's heyday, making them more likely to try and block Paizo from continuing to use the flumph. I don't know enough about copyright law to know if that reasoning is correct, though...
It could also be that since 5e is using them more, Paizo is trying to distance their brand by not using them.

![]() |

Archpaladin Zousha wrote:It could also be that since 5e is using them more, Paizo is trying to distance their brand by not using them.thecursor wrote:How do people not know that Paizo has been using Flumphs for years? Like they're in Bestiary one or two?It may be more that that D&D included them in the base Monster Manual for 5e and having them actually feature in mainstream published adventures like Out of the Abyss instead of treating them like an embarrassment to be buried in more obscure supplements and only starring in third-party or homebrew adventures, and as a punchline in "Top 10 Stupidest D&D Monsters" list articles, as they were in previous editions.
What they may be thinking is, because the flumph is getting more mainstream attention from WotC, they may be more protective of the flumph now than they were in 1e Pathfinder's heyday, making them more likely to try and block Paizo from continuing to use the flumph. I don't know enough about copyright law to know if that reasoning is correct, though...
That's what I'm saying?

![]() |

No idea about how it panned out in Stafinder, but in Pathfinder 2e flumphs seem to have gone the way of Darklight Sisterhood, Absalom cornucopias and jihadist Sarenraeites - as in not written out of the setting, but not mentioned anymore. James did state that the direction they've gone with in Misfit Monsters Redeemed didn't ultimately work with the setting and its approach to horror.
Starfinder could be different though, as its effectively an alternative future of Pathfinder and is under a different creative director.

Dracomicron |
4 people marked this as a favorite. |

No idea about how it panned out in Stafinder, but in Pathfinder 2e flumphs seem to have gone the way of Darklight Sisterhood, Absalom cornucopias and jihadist Sarenraeites - as in not written out of the setting, but not mentioned anymore. James did state that the direction they've gone with in Misfit Monsters Redeemed didn't ultimately work with the setting and its approach to horror.
Starfinder could be different though, as its effectively an alternative future of Pathfinder and is under a different creative director.
Flumphs are SUPER Starfinder-y, though. Weird heroic aliens with dire warnings about outer space monsters?
C'mon. That's practically Starfinder's mission statement.

LBHills |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Personally I think it'd be hilarious if the Flumph Fleet was not only numerous, but more technically advanced than the other Starfinder races.
Science Officer: Captain, we have four Flumph destroyers materializing behind us.
Captain: Holy-! Okay people, everybody think Lawful Good thoughts. Remember, their sensors can read minds!