No I'm not GMing this currently, so this is just a thought exercise, however last night two deep into Hard Root Beer I thought, what if you can split the party somehow, and have Baphomet and his allies go all Freddie Kruger on them, the trick is it can't be for the whole adventure cause it might get old, but if say for one week you scheduled for each person to have a solo one on one adventure (the other party members can still show up and hang and watch and do whatever, maybe even let them thematically aid another...
Anyway just an idea I had :-)