Making Holy Water

[poundpuppy30]

Is this considered crafting because I don't see where it would require crafting since all you are doing is having your character if they can cast "bless water" on a pint of regular water in a flask; which changes that water into holy water, then putting a stopper to it and whala a flask of holy water is created. Of course you pay the component cost but no crafting skill is needed on your part correct?

[SCPRedMage]

Bless Water has not been banned, so you CAN use it. You'll need to have any holy water you create with it on a chronicle sheet, signed off on by a GM, and judging by similar rulings, other players CANNOT keep any holy water you make, even if they pay for the material components.

[Jiggy]

You can't have any items carry over from one scenario to the next unless you purchase it or find a special rule explicitly allowing it to be permanent (such as the Guide's allowance of one instance of continual flame).

[Starglim]

poundpuppy30 wrote:

Is this considered crafting because I don't see where it would require crafting since all you are doing is having your character if they can cast "bless water" on a pint of regular water in a flask; which changes that water into holy water, then putting a stopper to it and whala a flask of holy water is created. Of course you pay the component cost but no crafting skill is needed on your part correct?

A PC can cast bless water. Its effect expires at the end of the scenario.

[Pirate Rob]

Since buying holy water has the same cost as the material component of bless water it's largely irrelevant.

[poundpuppy30]

Well I was thinking about if I needed holy water while in a dungeon I can pop an empty flask out, fill it with water, cast bless water and whala I have holy water to use on an undead; since no shops pop up in a dungeon to buy items. Is this rule about not being able to keep stuff you make listed anywhere in the pfs rules because I didn't come across that.

Also I noticed you can't give items away to other party members or lend money to other party members but if you make an item like holy water can you sell the vials to party members since this goes around the no crafting rules?

[Starglim]

poundpuppy30 wrote:

Is this rule about not being able to keep stuff you make listed anywhere in the pfs rules because I didn't come across that.

Crafting is not relevant here. You cast a spell.

Guide to PFSOP p. 26 wrote:

All spells and effects end at the end of a scenario with the following exceptions:

(you may read the exceptions, bless water is not one of them)

poundpuppy30 wrote:

Also I noticed you can't give items away to other party members or lend money to other party members but if you make an item like holy water can you sell the vials to party members since this goes around the no crafting rules?

You get the amount of gold written on your chronicle sheet and signed off by the GM. You can spend that amount of gold to buy items from NPCs or to claim items found in the adventure as part of your share of the treasure. Your fellow party members have the same options. You should see that there is no way beyond the end of the scenario for them to give you gold or for you to give them items.

[poundpuppy30]

Where can I look at the PFSOP p. 26? Is this a download you can link?

[poundpuppy30]

I found it and read it thanks.