
FiddlersGreen |

The second-last line of the spell description reads:
"Spells cast on other targets are vulnerable to dispel magic as
normal."
Now, when you say "other", you are usually making an exception to a subject matter. If you are talking about birds, then "other creatures" refers to any creature other than birds.
My question is: what is the subject matter that is being excepted to in the spell description? Are there targets for which a spell made permanent with a permanency spell will not be subject to dispel magic? Or should the word 'other' be omitted to avoid confusion, such that the line reads:
"Spells cast on targets (and areas?) are vulnerable to dispel magic as
normal."

Khuldar |

The second-last line of the spell description reads:
"Spells cast on other targets are vulnerable to dispel magic as
normal."Now, when you say "other", you are usually making an exception to a subject matter. If you are talking about birds, then "other creatures" refers to any creature other than birds.
My question is: what is the subject matter that is being excepted to in the spell description? Are there targets for which a spell made permanent with a permanency spell will not be subject to dispel magic? Or should the word 'other' be omitted to avoid confusion, such that the line reads:
"Spells cast on targets (and areas?) are vulnerable to dispel magic as
normal."
Personal permanencied spells have a caster level restriction to dispell:
You cannot cast these spells on other creatures. This application of permanency can be dispelled only by a caster of higher level than you were when you cast the spell.
The line you quoted just lets you know to use the normal dispel rules for everything else.
or at least, that's my reading.

FiddlersGreen |

FiddlersGreen wrote:The second-last line of the spell description reads:
"Spells cast on other targets are vulnerable to dispel magic as
normal."Now, when you say "other", you are usually making an exception to a subject matter. If you are talking about birds, then "other creatures" refers to any creature other than birds.
My question is: what is the subject matter that is being excepted to in the spell description? Are there targets for which a spell made permanent with a permanency spell will not be subject to dispel magic? Or should the word 'other' be omitted to avoid confusion, such that the line reads:
"Spells cast on targets (and areas?) are vulnerable to dispel magic as
normal."Personal permanencied spells have a caster level restriction to dispell:
Permanency wrote:
You cannot cast these spells on other creatures. This application of permanency can be dispelled only by a caster of higher level than you were when you cast the spell.The line you quoted just lets you know to use the normal dispel rules for everything else.
or at least, that's my reading.
Ah, I missed that line there. I think you're right. Cheers.