The Pun-isher |
OK, I'm glad to know this won't work, rather than continuing to accidentally break the rules.
As for the case with destroying the boat, our GM decides things by what would make sense with what's actually happening for things like that. Dropping a 6000 pound piece of rock from 200 feet above a ship and dealing as much damage as the Paladin would from hitting it a few times makes a lot less sense than the elemental crushing the ship under it, so we went with that.
Ironically, this wasn't even the worst break of the rules involving falling Elementals. The cult we did it on did it back to us, but instead of dropping a single Earth Elemental on a ship they dropped several dozen Earth and Fire Elementals on most of the city we were in.
Because we don't go back and retcon stuff, I guess this one is going back into Pandora's Box.
Thanks for the help, everyone.