
SillyOldeBear |
The trigger for the Shield Block reaction specifies physical damage (bludgeoning, piercing, slashing), but the effect text does not explicitly do so.
One interpretation of the effect text could assume that the damage being discussed is restricted to the triggering damage, in terms of how much damage can be blocked and how much unblocked damage the shield would take. The RAW interpretation assumes the shield could block and take any kind of damage as long as some of it was physical.
The RAW interpretation leads to some odd possibilities. If there is an attack that does 1 piercing damage and 19 spirit damage, the shield block would block 10 of the damage and would take 10 unblocked damage, even though the spirit damage by itself could not be blocked at all.
If we use the non-RAW interpretation, the shield could only block the 1 point of piercing damage and would not be damaged at all. This seems to make more sense to me, but is not explicitly stated in the rules.
I'd like to hear other opinions on this issue.