Torbyne wrote:
They touch on this in the recent Polygon interview, "Imagine if you woke up one day," Sutter said, "and you still have all your knowledge, and you still have roughly a sense of who you are, but you have no real memory of your past. After The Gap, whole nations knew that they are at war with other nations, but they didn't really remember why. People might have recognised their wives or their children, but they didn't have any specific memories of how or when they got together. That event is far in the past of Starfinder, but it’s nonetheless played havoc on the setting. Society has just sort of reshaped itself and that, to me, is a very interesting question." So there was a collapse but now, after several centuries, things have normalized a bit.
I get it's an interesting question, because it is, but it seems...superfluous? Like...either it matters in the here now, in which case the book is going to have to spend a goodly amount of pages trying to convey what was lost vs. what wasn't and the consequences of how adjudicating one way shapes your game adding in a significant amount of complexity that the setting becomes about The Gap by default
or
It's so far in the past as to be a weird setting quirk with players (and DMs) never really getting to engage with the Very Interesting Question because the setting
answered it.
Now..by 'fiddly details' let me go through this thought experiment -
It's december 25h, 2016 and you wake up with no idea what's going on. you have a vague sense of if where you are is 'home' or not, can sorta recognize close relatives (parents, children, spouses) and have all your technical skills.
The question yet answered is "what records are gone?" - if it's anything related to history then your music is gone, your e-mail is deleted, all the documents on your hdd are gone, video games are gone (credits, copyright dates yo), actually your OS is probably gone as well because historical information is in the code.
Phone numbers are gone - they're actually smart numbers that convey geographic information, and you can't remember your name.
You can't celebrate christmass, even if the bible isn't blank, because it's not in the bible it's in a bunch of media works that provide historical clues.
You probably can't even celebrate the new year because calendars give tons of information and would have to be expunged.
You have no access to your bank accounts, because financial history is even more information dense than a mere calendar.
You don't know where you work, you have the food findable in your house. You can drive a car, which is fine, until you run out of gas because you don't know how to actually refill the gas stations.
You better hope little notes to one's self about where trucks, boats and other deliveries are going because basically 20% of the Earth's population is going to starve or freeze over the next three months or so as utilities fail, the economy has been vaporized, and farmers have no idea what they planed to plant for the coming year. That would require climate data & weather patterns which, again, are information dense. The world descends into warlords with production capacities cut in half and you'd be lucky to stop at 18th century levels of technology as about 80% of the world's population dies.
And that's us, with modern equipment and knowledge. You do that to an agrarian society at war? It's Bronze Age collapse all over again.
To whit - There aren't 'empires suddenly at war' because to have an empire you'd have to have people that know each other more than at the squad level and other people wearing the same uniform or the same flag. TO have a war you'd have to have troops moving coherently against each other. What you've got now is roving banks of, well, bandits hungry, armed and trained in violence. You have no songs, because traditionally they'd speak to historical events. Tax rolls are blank, pursers don't remember where coin is hid or maybe they just run off with the money or get cut down by the generals and knights who suddenly are freed from emotional, cultural and legal ties to the rulers and as the strongest and most powerful take over.
Culture, by the way The Gap is currently explained, is expunged.
If culture and nationality isn't expunged then it's going to start getting very, very, very complex on 'well, what exactly did survive?' while also not being enough information that several centuries of determined investigators with access to magic and super science couldn't have put things back together.
Like...the book is going to have to sell me on what this setting feature brings to the table because so far it just looks like another nightmare thing to try to engage with.