Mongriff179 |
This past weekend, I put my players through a custom dungeon with several branches to go through. One such branch held a gauntlet of traps and unfortunately, the rogue tripped one that set off a series of targeted Mage's Disjunction at random magic items. One such item hit was a Bag of Holding. I rolled randomly, using a list of the items my players had at the time (I try to keep track so they aren't rolling through with major items at level 7 or too many things for me to handle against my monsters) and then rolled the saves based said items.
One such item was a Bag of Holding that failed. I let the players know what was going on, but my session ran out before I gave a final ruling on the argument that ensued. The book clearly states the item is destroyed. To me, that is the same as rupturing a bag of holding so everything within is lost. The player who held the item is arguing otherwise.
Opinions?