I had a dispute come up in a Pathfinder Society game concerning how Weapon Snatcher operated. The GM (who is of some higher prestige than myself in my local area) says that since Weapon Snatcher specifically states:
Quote:
A rogue with this talent can make a Sleight of Hand check in place of a combat maneuver check when attempting to disarm an opponent.
It means that all the rules that concern a slight of hand check, also carry over into the check made for the slight of hand. These include but are not limited to:
1. The Target not being aware of the person using the skill (meaning I can't use Weapon Snatcher on a target who knows I'm there, as per the wording of Slight of Hand
Quote:
You cannot use this skill to take an object from another creature during combat if the creature is aware of your presence.
2. That the action is a standard action as said (as opposed to an Attack-Equivalent action that a Disarm attempt would be)
Quote:
Any Sleight of Hand check is normally a standard action.
3. It is possible to use Weapon Snatcher to try and disarm a weapon as a move action (as per Slight of Hand)
Quote:
[Y]ou may perform a Sleight of Hand check as a move action by taking a –20 penalty on the check.
4. I do not need the Improved Disarm feat to avoid the attack of opportunity since the skill check doesn't draw one normally.
5. Basically the only thing the Advanced Talent changes is that I can steal a weapon someone is holding from their hand using slight of hand.
When I originally designed this character, I had never heard (nor read on the forums) this interpretation of Weapon Snatcher so when I wanted to employ it in the game, I was completely taken aback by how much more underwhelming his interpretation made it. In addition, several other GMs (also more prestigious than I in our PFS circle) agree with his interpretation.
I understand the Advanced Talent to basically allow the user to replace the CMB check with the rogue's slight of hand bonus, and I've read similar interpretations on the forums. My question is this, what is the proper way this Advanced Talent functions in PFS?