
LoomyNess |

Thanks for the quick replies everyone. It is certainly reassuring that it works the way it says. I threw the second example in to see what others thought more than anything. Though I do wonder why this even became an issue. I took the duetist archetype and was going to have a butterfly or if the gm allowed it a songbird with perform as it's bonus (Wasn't worried either way).
To which he mentioned without any evidence facts or really anything, 'just remember that your familiar won't give that bonus to your versatile performs' to which I asked why and TLDR I am here trying to push for justification of actions as he's effectively house ruled it to just be your ranks + CHA + class and NO bonuses to that perform. Instead you have to get skill focus in the substituted skills which is completely opposite of what I had ever thought (thus example 2).
As a note this group rotates the gm through its players, we often switch seats and between our main gm and myself most of the rules lawyering happens away from the table to not damage the flow for the other members as we have the most knowledge and experience.