Rogeif Yharloc

Flanwaw's page

RPG Superstar 9 Season Marathon Voter. 84 posts. No reviews. No lists. No wishlists.



1 person marked this as a favorite.

Excited to see my little Greenscream made the cut - equally excited to see what all the others look like in the printing.

Marathon Voter Season 9

1 person marked this as a favorite.

I am sore all over and riddled with psychosis but I did it.

Maybe my Ma'll finally love me!

Marathon Voter Season 9

1 person marked this as a favorite.

If you've been seeing a lot of your item and then suddenly you are not seeing much of it at all after a cull - it is very likely your item was a victim. At least, that appears to be the case.

If it so happens your item didn't make it, take the lessons to heart and try again next time. I know I plan to! (unless I somehow make it to top 8, which is not very likely... but you never know.)

Marathon Voter Season 9

3 people marked this as a favorite.
KalEl el Vigilante wrote:

"I survived Paizo Superstar Season 9's first cull!"

I think I'll make a T-Shirt saying that.

Tshirt? I'm getting a tat!

Marathon Voter Season 9

2 people marked this as a favorite.

My item has survived the first cull... HUZZAH!

Marathon Voter Season 9

2 people marked this as a favorite.
Landon Cole wrote:
I've seen a couple of relatively cheap items that are really good. I think I'm actually more impressed when someone comes up with something interesting that can be appropriately priced at less than 1k.

People seem to be tempted to submit high power high cost items, hoping the power=coolness factor will score them some points. It's really a lot more impressive on a design level when designers achieve an awesome effect that a part can use cost effectively.

Marathon Voter Season 9

1 person marked this as a favorite.

'turgid'

Marathon Voter Season 9

1 person marked this as a favorite.
John Whyte wrote:

A drinking item with a random bonus, vs something I'm pretty sure is stolen straight out of a joke from a webcomic.

Also one of these is 83 words and the other is 298
I've seen both before and selected the opponents each other time.
I don't know....

People seem to think that alcohol can do anything - and any ability fits the theme of booze.

It makes me wonder if some among us need to take a few weeks off the sauce.

Marathon Voter Season 9

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Zerri wrote:
I wonder how many times I've voted.... hmm... Though more than one a year does sound cool.

I for one welcome our new designer overlords.

Marathon Voter Season 9

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Yet another theme: improving the utility of scrolls.

Marathon Voter Season 9

6 people marked this as a favorite.

I think i'll autopass on the racist item. And for all future racist items: No, bad, don't do that.

Marathon Voter Season 9

2 people marked this as a favorite.

We're giving up our social lives, our responsibilities, and our sanity for the sake of voting hundreds, or sometimes thousands, of times on a random-pairing vote system for Pathfinder magical items. For most of us, bragging rights and experience will be the most substantive things we'll be getting from this.

So here's the place to show off - and to start...

WOHOO, STAR VOTER! I'm coming for you, Champion title! Take that loved one's who are concerned about where I've been the whole day!

P.S. Let's all remember it's far more important to thoroughly examine the items that are presented and make as informed a choice as possible when selecting the best of the pair. Numbers come second... but second place is still silver :)

Marathon Voter Season 9

1 person marked this as a favorite.
The black raven wrote:
How can you wrote a submission that long and still be under 300 characters ?

The power of BIG WORDS.

Also - i know it's not a big deal but after seeing the same tiny error a few times it becomes annoying.

Yes, affect and effect are different things dangit


2 people marked this as a favorite.
Michael Riter wrote:
Flanwaw wrote:
Looking at the list you got on the first page one of the first things that jumps out to me as being 'missing' are important or notable locations. The major sites of a city can characterize it just as much as the people living there. Who doesn't think of Paris without thinking of the Eiffel Tower, or New York without the Statue of Liberty?

I really should have clarified; when detailing the city districts, certain landmarks will certainly be important enough to gain their own personalized descriptions. One in particular that comes to mind would be the Forum.

Flanwaw wrote:
Also, i'm not sure how closely you plan to tie the setting to historically accurate information for the setting inspirations you provided, but my preference would be to invest heavily in accuracy, or little at all... don't be stuck in between. As a lover of History it just frustrates me to see glaring untruths tucked in between well researched info. If it's all fantastical I hardly care what sort of dinosaurs your orc legionnaires are riding into battle.

This, on the other hand, was something that actually didn't run through my mind. Looking over my notes, it certainly seems that though the setting material is inspired by what I had mentioned, I definitely am leaning towards keeping things on an original timeline rather than taking directly from history. To be more specific, here are my inspirations from history and where they will be prevalent.

Rome: A mixture of the Empire and the Republic as far as the political system goes, but the Emperor/Empress still has the majority of the power. Most of the gods come from this period as well.

Celtic/Gaelic Lore: One of the Empire's newest colonies is similar in culture, and their gods were added to the Pantheon just recently.[/ooc]

Victorian England This, I think, is where the meat and bones of the setting would come into play. As an urban setting, one would definitely find influences from this era in lower, middle, merchant,...

Good to hear about the landmarks, just make sure you have some in there that don't fulfill a practical purpose. A city is just as much a product of its tacky monuments and pointless displays as it is political and cultural buildings.

Good to hear how you are mixing the three, it should prove to be an interesting combination at the very least. It may also be worth mentioning that a series of plagues, known as the Antonine Plagues, may have been one of the major reasons Rome fell. If you want to take your plague inspiration from more than just the black death it may be worth giving that a look-up.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Looking at the list you got on the first page one of the first things that jumps out to me as being 'missing' are important or notable locations. The major sites of a city can characterize it just as much as the people living there. Who doesn't think of Paris without thinking of the Eiffel Tower, or New York without the Statue of Liberty?

Ancient societies often built more landmarks than we do today, as they filled a variety of functions in the ancient city. For one, they were actual landmarks - before the advent of the printing press it wasn't exactly easy to get a hold of a decent map of a city... if one even existed. Iconic and distinct buildings helped people navigate the cramped and maze like corridors so prolific in the time before detailed urban planning. Furthermore, the construction of such a building would bring a great deal of prestige to the commissioner - nothing like a giant statue with "commissioned by Bob" on it to make Bob seem like a way-cool dude. These locations should have both a cultural context within the city - as such things tend to develop overtime. (Think of all the stories and iconography surrounding the Colosseum in Rome, or the Forbidden City in Beijing.) The capital city of a major empire should be filled to bursting with important buildings, decorative constructions, and cultural icons. Make sure each of these gets at least some time in the sun within your setting descriptions.

Also, i'm not sure how closely you plan to tie the setting to historically accurate information for the setting inspirations you provided, but my preference would be to invest heavily in accuracy, or little at all... don't be stuck in between. As a lover of History it just frustrates me to see glaring untruths tucked in between well researched info. If it's all fantastical I hardly care what sort of dinosaurs your orc legionnaires are riding into battle.

Marathon Voter Season 9

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Welp, I have flung my first ever submission into the darkness - only to hope that it returns triumphant.

Though i am a bit concerned it's a little too niche-spell-effect-y.