Ok I must have failed at explaining. Sorry.
I will go with this plan as it seems to be consensus but I want to point out how spread out we are.
We are looking at 5-7 bandits on horseback. We have to assume about half the horses will make their ref saves vs. the entangle. This means Timothy will be a target for both arrows and melee attack.
With the given starting points Caelus can just about reach Timothy with a move action but that path sends him Through the entangle. This could be a problem. That entangle is a DC15 reflex save correct Aldarion?
Another thing to point out is that the entangled condition will likely only effect the horses. The riders, who as forest brigands will likely have at least short bows, will be free to fire at will. Or more likely at Timothy.
Last attempt at explaining the rope-trick.
Goal: To allow one person to close and bar the gate. Note, not to close the gate but to turn it from a 2-3 person job to a 1 person job. This allows us to concentrate our forces.
Assumptions: I am assuming the half of the gate farthest from A2 will be left open if it is the other half the plan still works but the Donkey will be behind A3 rather than A2 and all references should be read as such.
The rope is attached to the door, likely to the bracket the bar slides through it then dangles loosely to the ground. This is visible but as the rope does not appear to be connected to anything it is very likely to be overlooked until it is too late.
Appearing to be dangling loosely the rope in face enters a small cut, divot or ditch that runs around the open door and across the entryway. This is not a major excavation. Less than an inch deep and covered with swept dust. This will make the rope invisible while posing no resistance to the rope when the donkey pulls. The rope will jump out of the cut and straighten when tension is applied.
The ditch or cut will guise the rope around one of the posts supporting the walkway or around a small post driven into the ground for this purpose. This post will change the pull from a diagonal pull to the E by E to a nearly true E pull. This will not shut the door but it will get it to within inches of shutting and a simple shoulder shove while affixing the bar should do the rest.
Is this clear?
Using the rope trick means one person at the gate, one person at the donkey and three people at the focal point. As the donkey herd is almost halfway to the focus point that means within a round they can be joining the conflict. The consensus plan has us scattered in four separate groups rendering us vulnerable to being individually overpowered.
As I said I can go with the consensus plan. Caelius will be on the roof of either A2 or A3 ASAP and launching arrows in any case, So I am not too concerned about his safety. I am quite concerned about Timothy's ability to survive 1-2 rounds of arrow fire and a possible charge or at least a double move and attack by a someone whose horse made their save.
Thoughts