Basilisk |
What psionics need is not a different way to do things, but different things to do than arcane and devine magic.
I agree in that I think that psionics should be different from the other types of magic. I have to say I have always seen the way that magic works as being a Triangle of sorts. Mages get their power from books, which is a very structured style of magic, and power. Priests get theirs from an outside source. Where Psionics is the other balancing effect of this triangle. Its not an outside source its an internal one, and its structured but unlike mage magic its not learned from books or any such thing.
Its book learning, divine, and the mind or will depending on how you view it. And I think a Triangle for magic works.
I would love to see a Pathfinder version of Psionics. To update the rules, and help balance out settings. I think psionics bring something that the other magic types just don't.
The other questions were: How can I get you to buy a psionics book and use it in your campaign?
Make one that's good is the simple answer. I would buy a book of psionics from pathfinder just to see if its good, or because you made one. To be honest. But as a fan, I would like to see something that helps flesh out campaigns and such better. That is balanced, as the XPH book is, and well done of course.
Mind you I expect all that from you anyway as the Beta is so why wouldn't anything else you do be so. Mostly I would like to see you make it your own. Keep what you like throw away the rest. If you want suggestions ask Ed Bonny, I love the man's work for Lost Empires of Faerun, and his psionic Forgotten Realms stuff was good. They just didn't publish most of it. But that's because they are the Red Wizards of the coast.
What is an absolute deal-breaker?
A deal breaker to me would be not supporting the product. One thing that irritates the heck out of me is when cool ideas come along, and you buy the book, and it never gets updates, new prcs, or even remembered it seems.