How do you determine if a person / creature is evil?


Rules Discussion


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Pathfinder 2nd edition does not support alignments but some of the Anathema's have a requirement to kill/destroy evil when found.
Some creatures are obvious like a demon or a devil but what about people, can a person be evil and if so how can a player determine that a npc is evil.
Can a character be evil?


4 people marked this as a favorite.

Same as we do IRL - by their actions and behavior towards other people and society at large.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

The anathema for a cleric of Sarenrae is:
"Create undead, lie, deny a repentant creature an opportunity for redemption, fail to strike down evil"

By your account every citizen of the Cheliax nation is irredeemable since they worship a devil and must be killed. What of those who do evil because if they fail to do it they may suffer punishment.

Another part of the anathema is that a creature must be offered the opportunity at redemption, but would an evil creature accept the offer?


2 people marked this as a favorite.

Not every person who worships does so beyond lip service, especially in a place where it's required by law.

They'd accept redemption because the motives and behaviors of free-willed beings are impossibly complex. People aren't defined by one trait and aren't carbon copies of Dick Dastadly or something.

If you're looking for a discussion of good and evil, the rules discussion for a ttrpg isn't where you'll find it.

edit: and no, going around smiting people because they unpleasant is not an acceptable act.


5 people marked this as a favorite.
Mako42 wrote:
By your account every citizen of the Cheliax nation is irredeemable since they worship a devil and must be killed. What of those who do evil because if they fail to do it they may suffer punishment

... That is a complete non-sequitur--is that how it works in your worldview? The oppressed citizens of a cruel theocratic nation are evil because they are forced to pay lip-service to devils whether they had any personal faith in them or not, whether they had any choice of alternative or not? Never mind that--they're also irredeemable by the same logic that renders them inherently evil in the first place?

That's a scary world to live in, but it has no bearing on the question of Sarenrae's anathema, who is clear and vocal about allowing those who have done evil the chance at redemption if they take it earnestly.

More to the point, I feel like edicts and anathema necessarily include some wiggle room for interpretation because no rule can survive black-and-white treatment with no consideration for intent, least of all a pithy one-sentence commandment.

You fail to strike down evil if you saw evil happening and you failed to intervene (in a way that wouldn't force you to sacrifice yourself) or allow evil that you could have stopped.


3 people marked this as a favorite.
Mako42 wrote:
By your account every citizen of the Cheliax nation is irredeemable since they worship a devil and must be killed.

This is the very type of false dichotomy thinking that the removal of alignment was intended to improve on. The game mechanics are designed to not allow you to think that:

* All citizens of Cheliax are irredeemably evil.
* All chromatic dragons are inherently evil.
* All undead are evil.
* All goblins are evil.
* All _____ are evil.

The very reason for that being that the gaming community wants you to learn that you can't do that type of stereotyping and pass superficial judgment on people IRL either.

Liberty's Edge

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Holy is definitely not evil.
Unholy is definitely evil.

For the rest, you will have to check with your GM.


Thank you for the responses. They are very informative. I do not stereotype but I am trying to understand that now that the mechanic for determining good and evil (alignments) has been removed; what has replaced it to allow determining good and evil since the game still describes situations where good and evil need to be determined.
And no, I do not view people as my character in the game would; I know that IRL there are no alignments set and each decision is a choice.

Edit: Another way to look at 'striking down evil' may be offering redemption and turning the creature away from evil; this would not require termination.


The Raven Black wrote:

Holy is definitely not evil.

Unholy is definitely evil.

For the rest, you will have to check with your GM.

Neither the holy nor the unholy are guarantees of good or evil.

They represent "sides of great cosmic and divine forces in conflict"—with the holy typically being benevolent and the unholy typically being malevolent—though this is not true in every case.

You will encounter instances where holy characters must make "difficult decisions," and unholy characters act out of pure selfishness—yet remain pragmatic, neither committing evil acts nor hindering benevolent ones (sometimes even performing benevolent deeds for their own gain, which is quite common as part of a larger scheme), simply because acting otherwise would eventually cause them problems.

There is even a little scenario I like to propose—which, according to the rules, actually works:

You could create a “desecration” champion of Calistria, with the following anathemas:

Calistria’s anathemas: "become too consumed by love or a need for revenge," "let a slight go unanswered".
Unholy anathemas: "Commit an entirely altruistic act, such as giving something away in charity", "Put anyone's needs before those of your deity" (None of these prevent you from performing acts that others might consider helpful; however, such acts must be carried out with the expectation that they ultimately further your own goals or those of your deity.)
Desecration anathemas: None.

Therefore, technically, you could play an unholy champion of Calistria—a "neutral" goddess—without ever truly committing an act of evil for evil's sake, focusing instead solely on your own selfishness and the values ​​and interests of your deity. You simply can never do good for the sake of goodness itself.

Mako42 wrote:

Thank you for the responses. They are very informative. I do not stereotype but I am trying to understand that now that the mechanic for determining good and evil (alignments) has been removed; what has replaced it to allow determining good and evil since the game still describes situations where good and evil need to be determined.

And no, I do not view people as my character in the game would; I know that IRL there are no alignments set and each decision is a choice.

The general idea is that you don’t need to worry too much about this. Paizo has chosen to be quite lenient when it comes to edicts and anathemas.

Even before the remaster, there were already stories featuring chromatic dragons that weren’t evil, and metallic dragons that descended into evil and tyranny—believing all the while that they were fighting for a greater good.

With the removal of alignments in the remaster, Paizo has further reinforced the notion that things are neither black-and-white nor immutable. Violating an anathema no longer automatically results in a penalty for the character; rather, whether or not a violation has occurred is a matter for the player and the Game Master (GM) to interpret together based on the situation. The system relies on both parties to exercise good judgment: the GM should not use these elements to punish the player, but rather as a way to test the character’s values—while the player, in turn, shouldn’t feel the need to remain constantly on the defensive, clinging rigidly to their anathema at every turn.

The goal is for both the player and the GM to be able to tell a compelling story, allowing them to make their characters and the situations they encounter as complex as they wish.


Good point. I guess I need to discuss with my GM and gaming group to determine how we will handle good and evil determination.


2 people marked this as a favorite.

You kill 'em all and let Pharasma sort them out, of course! 100% success rate!


2 people marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Adventure Path Subscriber

I think Sarenrae’s anathema is a good candidate for a very slight adjustment to move the world evil away from an eMate state of being and towards and act that can be identified in the moment.

My recommendation would be something simple like “fail to stop evil” or “failure to stop evil from happening.”

This would provide a lot of clarity and prevent a lot of the old alignment debates from gaining traction in a Golarion where evil is a subjective term that some objective universal states depend on.


Even when Pathfinder 2nd Edition had alignments, the PCs did not regularly go around casting Detect Alignment to identify evil people. Instead, the GM had to give clues.

GM: You successfully sneak into the temple of the evil cultists though the window. Two guards stand facing the front door, so they are not looking in your direction.
PLAYER 1: How do we know they are evil? We have to find evidence.
GM: In the center of the room is a sacrificial altar that smells of old blood. It is decorated with the skulls of humans and elves. If you want to identify the carved symbols on the altar, make a Recall Knowledge check on Religion.
PLAYER 1: I rolled 19.
GM: The chained skull symbol belongs to Zon-Kuthon, the Midnight Lord, God of Pain and Torture.
PLAYER 2: That counts as evil to me.

I prefer that method myself as opposed to Detect Alignment. The greedy shopkeeper who cheated his customers with unbalanced scales might have officially fallen under Evil alignment, but I don't think that Sarenrae demanded that the shopkeeper be struck down death because of his evil.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Mako42 wrote:

The anathema for a cleric of Sarenrae is:

"Create undead, lie, deny a repentant creature an opportunity for redemption, fail to strike down evil"

By your account every citizen of the Cheliax nation is irredeemable since they worship a devil and must be killed. What of those who do evil because if they fail to do it they may suffer punishment.

Another part of the anathema is that a creature must be offered the opportunity at redemption, but would an evil creature accept the offer?

For it to be an issue for the anathema, it had better be pretty clear. Got some undead that's killed a lot of people and eager to do it some more? Don't just leave it as somebody else's problem. Got an undead that hates the living but handles it by keeping their distance? Not going to trigger anathema to leave them be.

Personally, I prefer groups that don't lean into the holy smiting deities like Sarenrae or Ragathiel.

Mako42 wrote:
Another part of the anathema is that a creature must be offered the opportunity at redemption, but would an evil creature accept the offer?

Potentially, sure. That's kinda what "redemption" means, after all.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Lightning Sentinel wrote:
Not every person who worships does so beyond lip service, especially in a place where it's required by law.

I have an actual example based on a published module of redeemable villains who were stuck being villains because they had little choice.

The main villains in Hurricane's Howl, the 3rd module of Strength of Thousands, are the bandit gang called the Knights of Abendego. Not only are they bandits, but some also worship Norgorber and sacrifice people to him. In their bandit raids, they take captives and give the some of the captives a choice: join the gang or die.

Technically, the party meets only the worst of the Knights of Abendego, but my campaign spent more time among the common people of Jula, the fishing town that the bandits took over 20 years ago. I had to fill in details. The bandit raids on trade caravans had destroyed all overland trade to Jula. Local craftsmen were coerced into working for the bandits. Jula could feed itself with fish, but the Knights of Abendego had essentially all the money in the town. To a young person less than 20 years old, the Knights of Abendego had been in Jula all their life and they were the only path out of poverty. That was part of the backstory of my playtest NPC Kittyhawk, whose deceased boyfriend had been a young and naive bandit.

Hurricane's Howl was deliberately vague about the number of Knights of Abendego, because the module did not intend for the party to fight all of them. Instead, they were suppose to rally the townsfolk to rebel. Nevertheless, the gazetteer article on Jula in the module gave the population of Jula as 292. I set the bandits as 20% of the population to get 58 bandits, not counting the ones stationed out of town at the Prison of the Vacant Eye. The party had already fought 18 on the road and another 7 in town, leaving 33. 18 were assigned to guard gates, leaving only 15. The module put 11 in the Knight's headquarters, which the party defeated, and I decided that the last 4 were a town patrol. The party did not need to lead a rebellion. The 22 assigned as gate guards and town patrols were the redeemable ones, who were not vicious enough for raiding other villages and not converted enough to kill sacrifices to Norgorber.

One of the bandit gate guards, whom I named Louse, explained that he had been a caravan guard captured by the Knights of Abendego. He had killed a fellow prisoner who had attacked him after the Norborgerite cultists had explained that anyone who killed a fellow prisoner could join the Knights instead of being sacrificed. He had changed his name to Louse in shame after he accepted the offer to join the Knights.

That left about 7% of the population of Jula as former bandits, a risky portion (some former captives, such as Louse, returned to their original homes). So I left Kittyhawk in Jula and imported Mkosa there to keep an eye on them after the party departed for other adventures.


Mako42 wrote:
I am trying to understand that now that the mechanic for determining good and evil (alignments) has been removed; what has replaced it to allow determining good and evil since the game still describes situations where good and evil need to be determined.

This is ultimately a GM-player interaction. If you have concerns about targeting the 'wrong' person, talk to your GM about those concerns.

The GM should likely take into account that Sarenrae's anathema were developed before the remaster, and thus may need to be adjusted to account for remaster changes. Offering redemption vs. meting out justice is a great story opportunity, and 'rule of cool' is useful. I would not (as a GM) punish a PC if they come up with a great and cool in-story justification for either decision, assuming it's appropriate. Let them tell their story.

If your group is not comfortable with that and prefers a more bright-line adjudication, to me it would make sense to either use a depends-on-what-the-character-knows or a depends-on-what-the-antagonist-does approach. Though if you as a player work out something better with your GM, go for it.

Liberty's Edge

YuriP wrote:
The Raven Black wrote:

Holy is definitely not evil.

Unholy is definitely evil.

For the rest, you will have to check with your GM.

Neither the holy nor the unholy are guarantees of good or evil.

They represent "sides of great cosmic and divine forces in conflict"—with the holy typically being benevolent and the unholy typically being malevolent—though this is not true in every case.

You will encounter instances where holy characters must make "difficult decisions," and unholy characters act out of pure selfishness—yet remain pragmatic, neither committing evil acts nor hindering benevolent ones (sometimes even performing benevolent deeds for their own gain, which is quite common as part of a larger scheme), simply because acting otherwise would eventually cause them problems.

There is even a little scenario I like to propose—which, according to the rules, actually works:

You could create a “desecration” champion of Calistria, with the following anathemas:

Calistria’s anathemas: "become too consumed by love or a need for revenge," "let a slight go unanswered".
Unholy anathemas: "Commit an entirely altruistic act, such as giving something away in charity", "Put anyone's needs before those of your deity" (None of these prevent you from performing acts that others might consider helpful; however, such acts must be carried out with the expectation that they ultimately further your own goals or those of your deity.)
Desecration anathemas: None.

Therefore, technically, you could play an unholy champion of Calistria—a "neutral" goddess—without ever truly committing an act of evil for evil's sake, focusing instead solely on your own selfishness and the values ​​and interests of your deity. You simply can never do good for the sake of goodness itself.

Mako42 wrote:
Thank you for the responses. They are very informative. I do not stereotype but I am trying to understand that now that the mechanic for determining good and evil (alignments) has been removed; what has
...

"Unholy

Source Player Core pg. 462
Effects with the unholy trait are tied to powerful magical forces of cruelty and sin. They often have stronger effects on holy creatures. Creatures with this trait are strongly devoted to unholy causes, and often have weakness to holy. "

Unholy Champion Causes:
"Desecration (Unholy)
Source Player Core 2 pg. 91
You always take what pleases you, no matter who it hurts, and you spread a malign influence across all you touch.

Edicts subvert or corrupt everything in your path that is pure or holy, sow doubt among those holding ideals of purity or holiness"

"Iniquity (Unholy)
Source Player Core 2 pg. 91
You’re dishonorable, dishonest, and committed to breaking the false hopes of kindness.

Edicts destroy that which offends you or stands in your way, take advantage of others, cheat, steal

Anathema bind yourself with a law other than what your deity requires"

"Unholy sanctification for a champion can be extremely disruptive to a typical game and should be a player character option only in appropriate adventures or campaigns where the group collectively decides to embrace them. "

Not to mention how previously Evil creatures and effects map to Unholy and Good to Holy.

The two sides are definitely good vs evil. It was even delineated as such by Paizo when talking about the removal of alignment. The changing of name was linked to this and not to any change in the setting's struggle of Good vs Evil.


Mako42 wrote:

Thank you for the responses. They are very informative. I do not stereotype but I am trying to understand that now that the mechanic for determining good and evil (alignments) has been removed; what has replaced it to allow determining good and evil since the game still describes situations where good and evil need to be determined.

Roleplaying. Edicts and anathemas are roleplaying prompts and you have to roleplay to handle them. Technically this should have always been obviously the case, and if that wasn't clear to everybody before the remaster then that's just solid evidence that the old alignment system did more harm than good.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder Second Edition / Rules Discussion / How do you determine if a person / creature is evil? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.