Dunwright's page

121 posts. No reviews. No lists. No wishlists.


RSS

1 to 50 of 121 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>

Mako42 wrote:

Thank you for the responses. They are very informative. I do not stereotype but I am trying to understand that now that the mechanic for determining good and evil (alignments) has been removed; what has replaced it to allow determining good and evil since the game still describes situations where good and evil need to be determined.

Roleplaying. Edicts and anathemas are roleplaying prompts and you have to roleplay to handle them. Technically this should have always been obviously the case, and if that wasn't clear to everybody before the remaster then that's just solid evidence that the old alignment system did more harm than good.


2 people marked this as a favorite.
Deriven Firelion wrote:
Dunwright wrote:
Ravingdork wrote:

After hearing the plausible explanations in this thread, I decided to take an even closer look. I looked at my hard copy with a magnifying glass, and have downloaded the PDF and extracted the images for closer inspection using both digital tools and my many years of experience with both art, graphic design processing, and AI tools.

There is now no doubt whatsoever in my mind that about 75% of the imagery on pages 6 and 7 of Feybound (particularly the interior and garden areas) were generated wholesale with AI. It's possible some additional post processing was done as well, but there remain clear signs of heavy AI use.

This was not a layering or upscaling mistake, but a clear, intentional use of AI.

If Paizo intends to stick with it's anti-AI policies, then I hope they start enforcing it better.

I don't think they have the resources to carefully monitor the AI usage of all of the dozens (hundreds?) of digital artists they contract with. They're struggling as is and have had to lay off a lot of people. And AI is being added to all sorts of digital tools with varying degrees of clarity/disclosure to an extent even Paizo themselves struggles to manage for the things entirely under their own purview (see for example James Jacobs' posts in this thread). I expect their anti-AI stance to continue generating controversies like this one going forward, though I also don't expect it to change any time soon because Paizo has a very "socially conscious" fanbase (for lack of a better word) that would raise a huge fuss about it and because I imagine most of the staff at Paizo probably does genuinely feel the same way about it. It is possible that Paizo will eventually stop commenting on these sorts of allegations at some point and just rely on a known public stance of "we check these things as best as we can and we ask the artists we hire really nicely not to use
...

Software is a lost cause quite frankly, even if the software they're using doesn't incorporate genAI/LLM/ML/whatever into producing its outputs the coding to actually make the software program probably involved such tools if it has been update any time in the last year, maybe more. Organizations that tried to take an anti-AI stance on coding already gave up on it months ago (e.g. Linux) and currently there's a popular Indie video game dev being torn to shreds online for voluntarily disclosing that they used an AI tool to help them bugfix something in the weeks leading up to release after a Unity engineer couldn't help them solve an issue- and I promise the only thing unique about that situation is that they voluntarily disclosed what they did (and are now being punished for doing so). Coding involves AI tools now, it's just how it is.

Actual artwork doesn't necessarily have to involve AI tools, but since most of the art in these books is made with digital tools and altered with digital tools and commissioned out to dozens of artists I doubt they'll be able to truly guarantee no AI involvement at any level in all of the art in all of their books going forward.


3 people marked this as a favorite.
Ravingdork wrote:

After hearing the plausible explanations in this thread, I decided to take an even closer look. I looked at my hard copy with a magnifying glass, and have downloaded the PDF and extracted the images for closer inspection using both digital tools and my many years of experience with both art, graphic design processing, and AI tools.

There is now no doubt whatsoever in my mind that about 75% of the imagery on pages 6 and 7 of Feybound (particularly the interior and garden areas) were generated wholesale with AI. It's possible some additional post processing was done as well, but there remain clear signs of heavy AI use.

This was not a layering or upscaling mistake, but a clear, intentional use of AI.

If Paizo intends to stick with it's anti-AI policies, then I hope they start enforcing it better.

I don't think they have the resources to carefully monitor the AI usage of all of the dozens (hundreds?) of digital artists they contract with. They're struggling as is and have had to lay off a lot of people. And AI is being added to all sorts of digital tools with varying degrees of clarity/disclosure to an extent even Paizo themselves struggles to manage for the things entirely under their own purview (see for example James Jacobs' posts in this thread). I expect their anti-AI stance to continue generating controversies like this one going forward, though I also don't expect it to change any time soon because Paizo has a very "socially conscious" fanbase (for lack of a better word) that would raise a huge fuss about it and because I imagine most of the staff at Paizo probably does genuinely feel the same way about it. It is possible that Paizo will eventually stop commenting on these sorts of allegations at some point and just rely on a known public stance of "we check these things as best as we can and we ask the artists we hire really nicely not to use AI and to check if any of their tools are using it".


1 person marked this as a favorite.

On the subject of the possibility of AI upscaling being used, pretty much all digital art tools are going to increasingly have "AI" incorporated into them (and the hard line between this and the algorithmic way they already automated work is to a large extent imaginary anyway) so you can expect to see this a lot more anyway unless Paizo insists on making all their contracted artists draw by hand... and even then Paizo themselves will probably inadvertently introduce some artifacts at some point via whatever way they choose to digitize that. I am *not* a graphic design expert like the above but I have a little common sense and I can realize if you're not placing every pixel deliberately yourself- if you're even so much as using the fill bucket or a lasso fill, or automatic blending/layering, whatever-
then the computer program is helping smooth things out for you algorithmically. The best artists will use the best programs and the best programs will have the best algorithms, which increasingly will have "AI" in them, often undisclosed or not clearly signalled. Every now and then something a little sloppier will make it past both the artist and the editor (this happened plenty even before AI) and because these tools leave different artifacts than the older tools they will be immediately obvious to the people who eagerly look for this stuff.


2 people marked this as a favorite.
AestheticDialectic wrote:
Old_Man_Robot wrote:
AestheticDialectic wrote:
. The issue undergirding all wizard discourse is that people are mad it's not the strongest class anymore. It's extremely evident, and in my thread some people even argued that the class should get to do literally everything but healing (unwilling to give anything up!)
If this is your legitimate and sincere understanding of this discussion, it doesn’t really feel like you actually engaging with what people are saying.
It is an unspoken component that is not always consciously understood, but is very clearly there. No one will admit to this, but it's clear as day

I think you're wrong on both counts here; not only is it not the primary motive for most of the people in this discussion, but also for those few which it is they admit it freelt and have done so in multiple threads (for example Deriven Firelion, who has stated outright that he wants the Wizard to be "king caster" again in either this or one of the other Wizard threads that ruotinely pops up). You don't need to imagine other people's motives, we're all posting anonymously on the internet about a game, people will just tell you what they want and why they want it.


SuperParkourio wrote:
Dunwright wrote:
You can sometimes have more than 3 actions in this game though, for example if a party member cast haste on you. Then you could grapple somebody with your first action (extending the grabbed/restrained condition until the end of your next turn on success) and then use 3 strikes for Godbreaker.

Nope. The quickened action can only be used for what the effect says it can be used for. The action from haste can only be used to Stride or Strike. It can't be used to Grapple, and it can't even be used as part of the action cost for Godbreaker.

The quickened source would actually need to say that the action can be used for Grapple. There is no such player option in the game.

You are correct actually I think, I got a little distracted by the feat describing itself as three Strike actions (Strikes being allowed by the Haste version of quickened), but it's actually a 3-action activity which I believe you can't force quickened actions onto. Mea culpa.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
The Raven Black wrote:

Since the feat (level 20) does not mention the Grapple action, but only the Restrained and Grabbed conditions, I would adjudicate it does not suffer from the time limit of the Grapple check.

So, your target would stay Grabbed/Restrained until it escapes or you move.

Agreed it could be clarified.

Godbreaker doesn't apply the condition though, you have to already have the creature grabbed/restrained to start it and the feat only says it "remains grabbed or restrained", presumably from whatever was already applying those conditions. By your logic somebody could use Godbreaker to extend a grabbed/restrained condition indefinitely even if the creature was grabbed/restrained from something with a finite duration, like the Grapple check or a spell. This would be pretty powerful, since retrained doesn't let you do anything but try to escape (which you can fail repeatedly at) and now the Monk doesn't even need to spend actions or make checks to try to keep you restrained. And if there is a spell that can work for this then you can extend the grabbed/restrained even after the spell ends; if it was applied by, say, Grasp of the Deep as mentioned earlier, this may not even require the Monk to remain close to the creature. The spell itself has no such requirement, neither the Godbreaker feat (though it does land you adjacent to the creature), neither the grabbed or restrained conditions, and none of these say the conditions end if you move either; that language is only found in the Grapple description. So why would such a restriction be added if Grapple doesn't come into the conversation at all? Arguably, if Grapple is no longer what is applying the condition here, this should work even without a spell; you can grapple a creature, Godbreaker it next turn, and now by your logic Godbreaker is controlling the grabbed/restrained conditions so they no longer have any duration nor any restrictions on the grappler moving around. If grappled is no longer controlling the conditions and imposing a duration/action cost to sustain, I don't see why it would still impose a restriction on moving around, especially since we know there are way to apply those conditions from a distance without grapple.

I don't think any of that is supposed to work that way, so I would strongly reject that ruling. In my interpretation Godbreaker's language is just telling you that using it won't cause those conditions to end just from using it. It isn't changing where those conditions came from or what restrictions those sources placed on it.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
AestheticDialectic wrote:
YuriP wrote:
Furthermore, in a party I play in—which includes both a wizard with Spell Substitution and an arcane sorcerer—the spells the wizard has swapped in have either been ones the sorcerer already has in their repertoire, spells that had no meaningful impact (often overlapping with skill checks), or long-duration utility spells that we already possess as wands or scrolls—water breathing, for example.

I was going to write about why I don't take the way Deriven plays the game seriously, and how I think it poorly impacts his analysis of the game, and also why I try, but don't always succeed is completely ignoring his responses, but this is something I need to ask directly here: why in earth do you have two primary arcane casters in a party, and why aren't they choosing their spells in tandem and working their kits around each other to cover a broader base of abilities? Exequiel or whatever their name is said something similar about having a wizard and sorcerer in the same party and the sorcerer "not waiting 10 minutes" (in game, not real minutes) for them to prepare dispell magic because said sorcerer had it as a signature spell

Do people often have such adversarial and uncooperative playgroups? Are people often choosing classes that fight for the same limelight? This is not a class design issue, that's an annoying player(s) issue

Contrarily, having players whose classes overlap a fair deal isn't typically that much of a problem if your players aren't annoying. If e.g. your cleric is pouting every time somebody else contributes some healing you may be the one with a table of annoying players. Food for thought.


The Raven Black wrote:
SuperParkourio wrote:

Godbreaker requires you to succeed at all 3 Strikes for the target to remain grabbed or restrained. Otherwise, the condition ends.

This distinction is meaningless, because the condition expires at the end of your turn anyway, as described in the Grapple action. And since Godbreaker costs all 3 actions, there's no opportunity to use any action to extend the condition.

The benefit for landing all 3 Strikes should instead say "the grabbed or restrained condition is extended to the end of your next turn."

There is no mention of using the Grapple action in the feat's description though.

Why would its time limit apply ?

It's sort of implicit. I could be missing something but I'm not aware of any other way a monk could achieve the "you have a creature grabbed or restrained" requirement besides grappling. There aren't that many things that apply those conditions, and many of the others arguably wouldn't meet the requirement, e.g. if the monk took cleric dedication and managed to get access to the Slither spell, a creature can be restrained by that but the spell specifies rhe creature is restrained by the snakes. So does it meet the requirement that YOU have a creature grabbed or restrained? It seems debatable at best but I'd lean toward no. Other spells like Grasping Vine and Grasping Earth are phrased similarly. Something like Grasp of the Deep might work, depending on how your GM rules it.


SuperParkourio wrote:

Godbreaker requires you to succeed at all 3 Strikes for the target to remain grabbed or restrained. Otherwise, the condition ends.

This distinction is meaningless, because the condition expires at the end of your turn anyway, as described in the Grapple action. And since Godbreaker costs all 3 actions, there's no opportunity to use any action to extend the condition.

The benefit for landing all 3 Strikes should instead say "the grabbed or restrained condition is extended to the end of your next turn."

You can sometimes have more than 3 actions in this game though, for example if a party member cast haste on you. Then you could grapple somebody with your first action (extending the grabbed/restrained condition until the end of your next turn on success) and then use 3 strikes for Godbreaker.


One way to make the spellbook an interesting/reasonable restriction and also give the wizard class some unique identity that leans on them being the premier magical scholars and generalists might be to let them learn spells from any tradition.


Sibelius Eos Owm wrote:

I don't know if this rightly belongs here, but I'm considering it a funny oversight that has crept up since the remaster.

While it makes sense that Pharasma disallows dedicated holy or unholy followers, the fact that holy water remains the primary low-level mundane option for anti-undead consumables means Pharasma's church no longer gets to fill a (admittedly minor) narrative role as a ready source for anti-undead equipment to townsfolk and adventurers alike.

Technical solutions for this include importing holy water from other churches, but this is unsatisfying to me especially in adventures where the local temple of Pharasma is the only game in town re: major divine services. There's also ghost charges as an alchemical bomb, but with bombs being martial weapons and priests not usually being alchemists, this isn't doing the things I want out of it.

Meanwhile, there is a 5th level item from the unremastered Book of the Dead called Life Salt. If this or something similar to it (perhaps without the mention of cleansing with holy fire), returned with a level 1 variant, that should very neatly do the trick. I have already been treating 'vital salts' as a sanctification-neutral variant of holy water that does all the same jobs (like sprinkling to help banish haunts) albeit only affecting undead/void healing and dealing vitality damage with no mention of holy/unholy.

The game may not need another variation of holy water, but the temples of Pharasma in my games very much would like their own in-house method of dealing with undead (esp incorporeal) that doesn't require sanctification or knowledge of alchemy to create.

(Maybe have it be the result of adding ritually purified salt to a healing potion and boiling it down until the salt crystals grow back out of the solution, taking the vital energy with them--have that idea for free if it appeals to you!)

To be honest, I actually think it doesn't really make sense that Pharasma doesn't sanction Holy priests. Back in the alignment days I might have accepted them saying she doesn't have good priests (although, notably, with 2e pre-remaster they actually instead opted to say she has LN and NG priests but no NE or CN ones), or I might have accepted her not having the new holy sanctification if the holy/unholy tags had been kept limited strictly to celestial/fiend business, but as it is the unholy tag is STRONGLY associated with the Undead (there are more creatures tagged unholy+undead than unholy+fiend) and their creation, so it seems exceedingly strange to me to suggest Pharasma is entirely neutral on this front and is committed to neutrality to the point she won't even countenance holy priests even though pretty much all of her enemies are heavy on the unholiness. The holy water thing is sort of handwaveable; the only detail about how its made just says it is eater blessed by a "benevolent" deity, which is vague/subjective and non-mechanical enough you can squeeze Pharasma in (even if it seems weird for her to nake Holy items for her priests who can't be Holy), but it's just one manifestation of a larger issue which is that the way the (un)holiness traits are inconsistently applied to the undead, those who create them and those who fight them can cause a dissonance between mechanics and fantasy, and not just for Pharasmins. Create Undead is an unholy ritual and an edict of Nhimbaloth's, but Nhimbaloth's priests cannot be unholy. Urgathoa's on the other hand must be. And Fandarra's priests can be unholy even though creating undead is anathema for them. If you needed to kill a Ravener, an Undead dragon that sustains itself by feeding on souls, you can forget about the Pharasmins, those would-be guardians of the cosmic cycle of souls and deestroyers of undead; you're better off calling on a priest that can actually trigger its weakness to Holy, like an Ashavan.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
OceanshieldwolPF 2.5 wrote:
I thought PF2 didn’t *have* Bestiaries, but used Monster Core…

Prior to the remaster they were called Bestiaries, and indeed the product linked in the OP appears to be the pre-remaster PF2E Bestiary 3 originally released in 2021, despite whatever dates it says on that page.

For reference: https://store.paizo.com/pathfinder-bestiary-3/


Tectorman wrote:
moosher12 wrote:
Deriven Firelion wrote:

Just a minority of old school gamers holding onto a form of casting that writers of novels for these games don't even use in their books because it's so bad for storytelling.

I still remembering reading a bunch of Forgotten Realms books. I don't remember a single one using Vancian casting for any of their wizards. They cast the right spell at the right time to fit the story. No mention of Vancian casting or much about it.

I can think of one instance, but it's a very old instance. Varian Jegarre's riffle scroll spellcasting definitely did feel like prepared casting in Prince of Wolves. But then we get to Declan Avari in Winter Witch and while he alludes to preparation, it's less touched on, in most encounters, they are just casting without referring to any limits. But then in Plague of Shadows Kellius is just casting spells.

The closest I ever saw in all the Pathfinder fiction I've ever read (which is all the comics and all of the novels up through Godsrain) was either Nightblade or Nightglass (the one where the main character is from Nidal). Our MC is obviously meant to be a Wizard and we explicitly see him deciding which spells to prepare before an upcoming battle (I think to defend some Strixes).

And even then, we never see an instance of him saying "I'll pick Lightning Bolt, but how many Lightning Bolts do I want?" or "Oh crap, I prepared Dispel Magic but it looks like I needed a second casting of that" or "Oops, I prepared too many Dimension Doors". Same thing with Ezren and every other so-called Wizard in print. If they were all statted out as P1E Arcanists or 5E Wizards, casters that also have to decide their spell lists but don't have to sweat how many castings of this or that, the novels and comics otherwise stay 100.0% the same.

Unicore wrote:
I would actually greatly enjoy some pathfinder fiction about a wizard always having the wrong spells memorized and getting by anyway having to make the most out of the wrong spells.

It is a little surprising actually the extent to which D&D/Pathfinder fiction largely declines to make use of this fairly unique style of spellcasting, because while it can be a little frustrating or stifling to play with I think it'd actually work great for narrative storytelling. It's an interesting "hard magic" system for characters to have to navigate.


I think based on some of the comments some people have very different ideas about what qualifies as "Vancian" but I would say I don't think I've really seen what I would consider Vancian casting in much if any media, the distonguishing characteristic of such being that a caster prepares everything they're going to be able to do at the start of the day and can't meaningfilly deviate from that, but also can still cast what they did prepare instantly. I am frankly not really sure where others are finding this in media. I can think of instances obviously where wizards need to research certain spells, or spend time performing rituals to cast them. But this is not Vancian casting, especially in the latter instance. I can't think of any stories where a wizard locks in their spellcasting possibilities at the start of the day but carries those spells around in their head ready to be unleashed at a moment's notice.


Deriven Firelion wrote:


5E did it. It's the biggest game in the fantasy RPG market.

D&D5E actually got around to ditching a lot of D&D tropes before PF2E hit the scene, while PF1E was still functionally D&D3.5.5: strict Vancian casting, Paladins and Monks restricted to specific alignments, mechanically relevant alignment rules in general... that last one has, ironically, only been half-ditched by the PF2E remaster in a effort to avoid being too similar to D&D for legal reasons. I suspect by the time PF3E comes out Wizards will be adapted to neovancian/flexible spellcasting by default. This would have caused more of an uproar in the jump to 2E (see Xenocrat's comment above about the Paladin -> Champion change), but today (and in the hypothetical future many years from now when 3E comes out) I don't think people be overly fussed about it, and I don't see many people going to bat for strict Vancian casting as something that really needs to stick around. Perhaps it will be a variant rule or an archetype like Flexible Spellcaster is now.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Sounds to me like a great example of the problems I was trying to get at in my previous post. People can't help but think "why is the Filipino stuff leaking into my fantasy Vietnam?". I don't think this is a very fun or useful way to engage with the setting- if we take the world of Golarion at face value there's nothing strange about the Dewangayaw being worshipped in both Xa Hoi and Minata- but I do think the way the setting is designed with very obvious culture silos that strongly correspond to real-world countries and peoples encourages people to think this way.


Finoan wrote:

Depending on if you define "scroll" by the actual RAW or if you inject your preconceptions about it having to be a writing on parchment...

You could create a scroll that takes the form of a bottle of liquid. You would still have to use the Cast a Spell item activation to cast it with. Not just anyone could drink it and have it work.

The Magic Scroll stat block (which per the Scroll rules is what you consult to determine the item level and price of a scroll) says it is a roll of paper or parchment. But I was surprised that this was the only place I could find any description of what a scroll actually is.


benwilsher18 wrote:
Tridus wrote:

Speaking of new stuff... Saturate. This spell creates a Quicksand Hazard.

Quicksand pulls creatures in with no save. It's a DC 20 Athletics check to swim back up to your waist (if you get below that), at which point you can also use DC 20 Athletics to move 5 feet, and eventually land prone if it gets out.

This is a 20' burst, so the worst case scenario for something inside it is effectively losing an entire turn and change just swimming 5' at a time, and then being prone...

But what about all the creatures in the bestiary that don't have Athletics? This is ~1/3 of the entire bestiary (737 out of 3063 non-unique creatures) and they're only using STR. Given most creatures don't have over a +5 STR, most of those have better odds of crit failing than they do of succeeding.

That makes this effectively a hard counter since they can't do a whole lot until they get out and the odds of straight up suffocating even if the players do nothing else whatsoever are pretty high (and the other players are probably not going to stand around doing nothing).

This seems absurdly out of line for a rank 2 spell. I'm not sure whoever created this really thought about how this hazard would interact with NPCs that don't have Athletics. Given how strong the action denial is, it's probably overtuned even if theres no check as it would still take multiple actions to get out and land them prone with no save.

What rank 2 spell is "AoE lose a turn or risk suffocation and then also be prone, no save"?

The way I read the Quicksand hazard, it doesn't actually do anything until it is triggered by someone walking on it, at which point it partially submerges the triggering creature only and then rolls initiative. I don't read it as immediately submerging everything in the area as it appears.

I agree that as written the quicksand doesn't trigger until somebody walks on it; I'm not sure this matters that much because you can still shape the burst to cover every square surrounding a creature meaning they will have to walk over it, unless they can fly. Any creatured that walks on it does become automatically submerged up to the waist.


ornathopter wrote:
Trying to have no earth analogue regions is just a great way to find out what culture the writers think is 'default.'

I mean, part of my assertion is that the game is already doing that anyway- both in the fact that the Western fantasy stuff spills out all over the setting in a way most of the "regional" (e.g. foreign to the main bulk of writers) fantasy stuff doesn't and in the fact that they've already picked the Inner Sea as the setting's default/primary region. You certainly haven't avoided this issue with the cultural siloing.


My point is in this alt-Golarion the Inner Sea wouldn't be Fantasy Europe, nor Tian Xia Fantasy Asia, you'd have oni and sasquatches and sphinxes and genies and every sort of thing all over the place and distributed across the world. You wouldn't be able to find an obvious counterpart of your real world culture to take offense at for not being exactly like the real world but you'd see the things your culture contributed to the setting all over. This is kind of how it already works if you are from a Western culture: you get to see Western things like angels and demons and fey and elves and dwarves and gnomes and druids and paladins and wizards with their wands pretty much wherever you go in the setting. You don't just see them in the designated Western fantasy silo.


2 people marked this as a favorite.
The Raven Black wrote:

Thank you for these clarifications.

What I find most ironic is that you would need Additional Lore Imp though. Because it is not a Devil anymore.

Agreed, that'd be pretty silly. Actually, the presence in the remaster of more "generic" fiends like the imp and erinys which arise in any/all of the unholy planes and are not tied to any particular family of creatures makes a pretty compelling argument for letting Fiend Lore be a thing.


Claxon wrote:
i guess it's worth mentioning, it seemed like in pF1 the writers did write a lot of places as analogs of our real world. I think with PF2 they have been trying to be more thoughtful about using the real world as inspiration, but rewriting things to not be analogs of the real world.

Honestly, I think the "problem" (insofar as there is one) is that Golarion is just very siloed, with each region having its own particular theme. That's not actually a bad thing, in fact in many ways it's a good thing: it lets both GMs and adventure writers create highly thematic campaigns focused on the things they want to focus on. But, when you have all the African fantasy stuff down in the continent South of the main, and all the Asian fantasy stuff in the continent East of the main one, and all the Amerindian fantasy stuff on the continent that's to the west and seperated by an ocean, it can't be that surprising that people tend to just think of these places as "fantasy Africa/Asia/America", and then from there it's quite easy to see why people are sometimes not well-pleased with the presentation of those places. A lot of this is kind of just baked in from 20 years ago unfortunately.

Not that anybody asked me (and they probably shouldn't, I doubt I can write as well the people working at Paizo), if I were remaking Golarion from the ground up I would try to mix all these various cultural influences in together and have them all distributed prevalently across the world; so you can have Kitsunes living next to Anadis in a kingdom ruled by Rakshasas or whatever. You could still have siloed regional themes, but the themes would be focused varyingly on either less culturally specific concepts (e.g. a pirate region like the Shackles) or on concepts that don't have any real world analog (e.g. a nation ruled by undead like Geb), and not things like "this is our Asian fantasy silo".


2 people marked this as a favorite.
The Raven Black wrote:

So a PC could invest in Additional Lore Undead to cover all undead.

But to cover all Fiends, it would currently need to take :

Additional Lore Daemon
Additional Lore Demon
Additional Lore Devil
Additional Lore Asura
Additional Lore Div
Additional Lore Oni
Additional Lore Qlippoth
Additional Lore Rakshasa
Additional Lore Sahkil
Additional Lore Velstrac

And that is not even counting Unique Fiends that do not belong to the above categories, nor Swarms similarly uncovered for that matter.

Nor those covered through Arcana like Bebilith.

And we would also need an Additional Lore each for Ahvothian, Erinys, Greater Barghest, Imp, Night Hag, Ostovite, Skelm, Soul Eater and Vescavor Queen.

I don't think so.

Well, actually, not that I've seen it mentioned much but I'm pretty sure post-remaster Asuras, Rakshasa and Onis are no longer considered fiends. As far as I can tell no creature of those types that has had stats printed since the remaster has the fiend tag, and those that have both legacy and remaster stat blocks lost the fiend tags they had. Asuras and Rakshasas are now usually Spirit/Unholy and Onis are Giants (besides the Asura/Rakshasa/Oni tag itself of course).

EDITED to add a lot:

Actually I want to talk about the above changes a little because it's a fairly substantial change that I haven't seen mentioned much online. Maybe this should be its own thread at this point but for now I'll post it here.

The description of the Fiend tag says:

Fiend wrote:
Creatures that hail from or have a strong connection to the unholy planes are called fiends. Fiends can survive the basic environmental effects of planes in the Outer Sphere.

This is basically the same as the legacy description, it just substituted "unholy" where it used to say "evil-aligned". Going by this definition the change to Rakshasas and Oni makes sense, because these were native to the Universe and therefore had no connection to the unholy planes, so this is a move toward definitional consistency for Paizo. The Asuras not being Fiends is a little weirder, since they do actually live in Hell, but I assume they removed the tag because of the new remastered Asura lore which paints them not as merely spiteful villains but as philosophical nihilists with some virtues of their own; remastered Asuras also have the ability to switch between holy and unholy sanctification, and in doing so swap their holy/unholy trait, so removing the fiend tag probably helped simplify the mechanics of that so they don't need to also become celestials or something. However both the remastered Asuras and Rakshasas now have "Spirit (Occultism)" listed under the Recall Knowledge check on their stat blocks and lack the Fiend trait, so I don't think Fiend Lore should cover them.

Onis are even stranger, because the remastered ones not only are not Fiends but don't even have the Unholy trait like remastered Asuras/Rakshasas, and their Recall Knowledge checks just list Humanoid (Society). In legacg they used to list both that and Fiend (Religion). With Onis now being just Giant Humanoids who are Fiends, not Unholy, not Spirits, and whose typical RK check is Humanoid (Society), they basically have nothing to do with Fiends at all now.

Some of the other individual fiends you mentioned like Soul Skelms probably wouldn't be considered Fiends either if their stat blocks were remastered because they have nothing to do with the unholy planes, though others like the Soul Eater probably would because they live in Abaddon.


Now that I've gone looking I see there's also a Rare Background (Once Possessed) that grants Fiend Lore, but the way it describes it makes it sound like it's an unusual Lore (and the background is rare), whereas many of the backgrounds that grant Undead Lore just toss it out there with no special description like it's normal and are common backgrounds.


Tridus wrote:


NPCs don't interact with PC rules and restrictions and can do pretty much anything anyone feels like. So I wouldn't put much stock into that.

This is true to some extent, but I don't think I've seen NPCs with skills that don't exist for PCs listed.

Tridus wrote:


Paizo also has a habit of one writer doing things that don't line up with anything else,

Also true, which is why I qualified my statement as "at least one" person at Paizo. Still, it says at least something that somebody at Paizo wrote it and it got approved by the editorial process and published, and the really egregious mistakes are more common in APs IMO.

Tridus wrote:
Depends on how you define "symmetry", as creatures are not equally distributed.

That was my point, yes. Fiends are much more common in the game and are more likely to be encountered as hostiles, even though in a narrative taxonomical sense "fiend" is generally regarded as being at about the same rank as "celestial" or "monitor".

Tridus wrote:
Bony Undead Lore/Fleshy Undead Lore/Blood Drinking Lore/Translucent Undead Lore just don't have the same ring to them. ;)

No, but the actual creature tags (Skeleton, Zombie, Vampire, etc.) ring about as well as the Fiend subcategories (Demon, Devil, Daemon) do.

Tridus wrote:
Where the line is on this is pretty fuzzy, because ancestry lores like Elf Lore exist RAW, but if you allowed the Human equivalent of Human Lore it covers the most creatures of any lore despite only being for a single ancestry because Human is kind of a default for so many NPCs.

Agreed, skill delineations are messy. On the other hand, I don't think Human Lore would really be that much of a problem, at least as far as actually recalling knowledge goes... okay, you can identify humans (as if you couldn't already), now what? Usually the fact that they're human and the weaknesses, habitats and general traits of humans are the least relevant facts about a human NPC. On the other other hand, mechanical bonuses such as using Human Lore with the Knowledge Is Power feat could be an issue just due to abundance, even moreso than Fiend Lore.

Tridus wrote:
Class features don't have to follow the normal skill rules. Esoteric Lore for example is clearly not legal to pick in general as it explicitly violates the Lore rules. But Thaumaturge gets it because the class says so.

True. In fact, the Necromancer text sort of implies (though doesn't outright state) that it's Undead Lore skill is not "normal" in that way, so maybe it should actually be a point against allowing Undead Lore generally (and by way of analogy, Fiend Lore).

Tridus wrote:
Aside from all that, it's worth noting that what actually gives a better DC is fully GM fiat. The rules do not say "you used a Lore so you get a lower DC no matter what."

Yes, but there are other possible interactions than just the reduced DC. For example, the Unmistakeable Lore feat which prevents critical failures when Recalling Knowledge with a Lore skill. That makes it a relevant question whether a player can take Fiend Lore and never get false information about fiends or whether they have to take Demon Lore, Devil Lore etc. individually for this benefit, totally seperate from the question of whether the GM is granting DC adjustments for any particular checks. You also just might have more training in a particular lore than whatever the closest relevant non-lore RK skill for something is; you could be very skilled in Fiend Lore or Undead Lore but not in Religion, and thus want to use to those lores for RK checks against those creatures even if you're not getting an extra DC adjustment for it.


The Raven Black wrote:

I go with the assumption that you can take a Lore for each creature type.

And Lore Fiends is definitely less broad than Religion and IMO covers the same kind of diversity in creatures as Lore Undead does.

To identify creatures that require a Nature or Religion check with Lores, I go with :

Nature
Lore Animals
Lore Plants
Lore Fungi
Lore Fey

Religion
Lore Undead
Lore Fiends
Lore Celestials
Lore Monitors

Lore Fiends fits quite nicely with all the others.

I agree with this in general, but to play Fiend's Advocate for a second here, I do think this is where the theoretical symmetry of the system butts up against the actual practice here. Namely, fiends are just much more commonly encountered (especially as enemies) in actual games, which will tend to make some GMs feel that "Fiend" is too broad of a category in a way "Celestial" or "Monitor" don't, even though theoretically they should be equivalent. And if one does deem it too broad a category and try to maintain the symmetry, it feels too punishing in the opposite direction; it's one to thing to say seperate lores are needed for Demons and Devils, but telling players they need to pick individual lores for Agathions and Aesir feels like telling them not to even bother with those.

Still, I would come down on the side of saying Fiends should be a valid lore type for a few reasons:

1. Paizo themselves have used it
2a. I think creature types in general should by default be considered valid fot specific lores,
2b. Especially if the game regularly uses the tag in a way that is mechanically significant across various spells/feats/items, which is the case here: examples include the Summon Fiend spell, many feats in thd Archfiend dedication, Fiend Warding Tattoos, the Fiend-trampling Stature and Fiend Slayer feats, and many others.
3. Though it is a somewhat broad category with multiple categories falling entirely within it, this is alao true of many other creature types for which Lores exist; Undead for example contains Skeletons, Zombies, Vampires, and several other creature types which each have a plethora of entries all on their own, but Undead Lore is a Necromancer class feature and SuperBidi has said he uses it with the Knowledge Is Power feat in his own games, and of course Celestials and Monitors are in the same boat. One might infer from the description of the Lore skill itself that these are too broad: it calls out both "Demons" and "Vampires" as examples for the "specific creature or narrow category of creatures" lores, but this hasn't stopped Paizo themselves from using Fiend Lore and Undead Lore, so I don't think one should try to read into that in a way which would exclude these. In my opinion, "Fiends" and "Undead" are pretty much analogous categories for this consideration, and that even extends to the aforementioned problem of them being very common as enemies, so to me these would either have to be allowed or disallowed together.


Just going to note there is an NPC stat block from the NPC Core, "Fiend Caller", that has "Fiend Lore +18" listed under its skills. So somebody at Paizo at least seems to think that makes for a valid lore category. Personally I think defined creature types should generally be considered Lore-worthy by default, and "fiend" is a tag that has mechanical interactions in several places with many different feats, spells and items.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

To that point, there are several gods and demigods in the setting which make disputed claims to being the progenitor of certain races or types of creatures. Off the top of my head:

- Kabriri's religious teachings claim he the Leng ghouls (like other ghouls) camd to be when he spread ghoul fever to Leng and that they later turned their back on him, but Leng ghouls themselves reject this story and claim thekr existence predates Kabriri
- Many scholars and religious texts claim Jezelda was the first to spread lycanthropy to mortals, though ironically Jezelda's own cultists are largely noncommital about whether this is actually the case
- Ragadahn claims to be the father of all dragons and linnorms, a claim which dragons themselves largely reject as heretical (though not to his face) and which linnorms often accept.

There's probably more, these are just off the top of my head.


Tridus wrote:


You can't use Religion on Undead because mindless undead can't be reasoned with (they're mindless), and intelligent undead are functionally at the same reasoning level as living creatures.

Sure, maybe that's fair enough for creatures that are literally mindless, but there are still all sorts of creatures in the game that like animals have very low intelligence modifiers and are not generally capable of conversation but still aren't mindless. Why couldn't Nature (which also covers elemental creatures) be used in this way on, say, a Living Boulder, an elemental creature from the Plane of Earth with an Int of -4 which is described as "Barely more intelligent than many animals" and has no language? Clearly you're not going to be talking to it without something like one of the feats mentioned earlier, and if it's roughly as intelligent as many animals then it should be possible to reason with it to the same extent you can reason with an animal. So why wouldn't you use an appropriate "knows a lot about this type of creature" skill to influence it like you can with Animals? Like I said, it raises the question, but I think the answer is just that animal training is a real thing and a common trope so it's a special exception. I suppose you could houserule it so all animal-level-intelligence creatures can be influenced by the appropriate skills.

Tridus wrote:
But the fact that my Oracle is a master of understanding how to get stuff done in the halls of power in Taldor doesn't mean they know the slightest thing about calming down an angry bear in the wilds.

Correct, and that's not a problem for the system because they probably won't be able to use Diplomacy for that. There are feats and spells to make that sort of thing work.

Tridus wrote:
Whereas a woodsman/herd animal tender/etc who spends all their time dealing with animals probably does know something about that.

Agreed, and I think Nature is meant to represent that and so I'd make it

clear that improving the attitude of an animal is something Nature can be used for, in an animal trainer sort of way. Actually talking to them like a Druid is a Diplomacy thing, and the Druid gets feats for that and has spells for that.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
TheFinish wrote:

it's because "imposing your will on animals" is 95% knowing how those animals will react to what you do, which is Nature, not Diplomacy.

Perhaps, but that does raise the question why you can't, using the exact same logic, use Religion in the exact same way on Undead, or Occultism on Oozes, or Arcana on Constructs, or even Society on Humanoids. Actually, I suppose with feats like Streetwise, Courtly Graces, Leverage Connections and so on you can use Society for certain usages normally associated with Diplomacy in certain contexts... but it does require specific feats to do that. It's not an inherent feature of the skill, and it only works in certain contexts and in specific ways. If you really want to push it, Lore skills of specific creatures or creature types could be used in place of Diplomacy on the relevant creatures by this logic.

Again, I think Nature with regard to animals specifically is really the oddball in that it lets you command a certain creature type (notably just animals, not plants or fey or elementals or anything else that generally falls under Nature) as a basic feature of the skill. I think this is done because animal training is a real thing and a common feature or many human societies even in the real world, as well as a common fantasy trope, so I'm sympathetic to why this special exception exists and am willing to suggest it should maybe even be expanded a little or at least clarified to let it be used for normal animal training stuff. But I don't think it should be allowed to cannibalize the functions of the Diplomacy skill entirely for this creature type, certainly not without at least some feat investment or specific class features.


3 people marked this as a favorite.

I think you're just not reading it correctly? I'm not going to bother quoting the whole lore entry here but the way I read it, they were mortal warriors who later ascended to godhood (quite normal in this setting), and it was presumably in this capacity as mortals that they were among the ancestors of the Tian people. This doesn't imply anything about the origins of humans generally nor does it even imply these gods created the Tian people or something.


I think we're mostly in agreement Sibelius, I said toward the end of my post that I think ideally Nature should be allowed to cover anything a person handling an animal could normally do (including improving its attitude toward you) and Diplomacy should be used for things like actually holding a conversation with an animal. Actually with feats like Tame Animal, Nature already can be used for this purpose for any animal that isn't actively hostile, but I might be inclined to make it a basic feature of the skill since Command an Animal already is. I suppose one could allow Nature checks to converse with an animal while using Speak with Animals, but besides being against the general thrust of the system and besides the spell calling out Diplomacy, it seems to be against the general point of Speak with Animals: if you're not trying to actually speak with them you don't need the spell, and if you are actually speaking with them then that's a Diplomacy thing because that's just literally what Diplomacy is for, talking to creatures to do things like make an impression, make a request or gather information.


Just as a curiosity I wanted to see how many feats in the game exist that allow you to use Diplomacy on other types creatures like the Druid feats, what their access is and what creatures they effect I came up with this, which may not be a complete list but illustrates how common this is in the game system:

Animal Elocutionist (Gnome, Animals)
Animal Empathy (Druid, Animals) and Animal Empathy (Ranger, Animals)
Aquatic Conversationalist (Azarketi, Animals with Aquatic or Amphibious traits)
Cattle Speech (Minotaur, cattle, bison, antelopes, and other grazing mammals that travel in herds)
Corpse Tender Dedication (mindless undead)
Croak Talker (Tripkee, Animals that are amphibians)
Koi Secrets (Kobold, fish)
Natural Ambassador (Awakened Animal, Animals)
Nocturnal Kindred (Vampire, rats, bats, wolves)
Ooze Empathy (Oozemorph, Oozes)
Plant Empathy (Druid, Plants)
Ratspeak (Ratfolk, rodents)
Reptile Speaker (Lizardfolk, reptiles)
Sacred Wilds Oath (Spirit Warrior, Animals)
Skittertalk (Anadi, arachnids)
Small Speak (Surki, insects, arthropods, and terrestrial invertebrates)
Speak with Bats (Sprite, bats)
Speak with Flowers (Ghoran, flowering plants)
Speak with Kindred (Leshy, plants and fungi)
Speech of the Mammoth Lords (Mammoth Lord, megafauna)
Treespech (Ardande, woody plants like trees and shrubs)
Undead Empathy (Skeleton, mindless undead)
Voice of the Elements (Dragonblood, elementals that don't speak any language)
Voice of the Elements (Kineticist, mindless elementals)
Voice of the Night (Dhampir, bats, rats and wolves)
Wave Speaker (Merfolk, animals that have the amphibious trait, aquatic trait, or a swim Speed)
Worm Empathy (Worm Caller, cave worms)

And I'm possibly missing a few here, and not counting non-feat things like the fact that e.g. the Speak with Animals spell says it lets you use Diplomacy on animals, or items like Needle of Undeath which lets you use Diplomacy on mindless undead once a day. So from that angle it seems quite normal that one is expected to use Diplomacy to influence animals rather than Nature; in general you use Diplomacy to influence everything, you just need feats or spells or items or other such things to help you in cases where you couldn't normally communicate with the creature or it couldn't normally understand you. That's just how Diplomacy works in this game. The oddball here is really just that the Nature skill lets you command an animal (which naturally has some conceptual overlap with using Diplomacy to make a request) or to train animals. This is (in my opinion) fine, since commanding and training animals is a normal thing even normal humans without any magical items or magical ancestries or magical spells can do (both in our world and on Golarion), and it doesn't usually look much like Diplomacy per se (which usually impies conversing with the creature on its own level to some extent), but it does cause a strange bit of overlap. Probably if I could change anything I would just make it so Nature can also be used to improve the attitude of an animal. This makes sense to me because the sort of people who train and command animals naturally also have to build a rapport with them, and I don't think this would make feats like Animal Empathy (Druid/Ranger) useless because you would still need that to communicate with Animals in a more freeform way than the Command/Training that Nature does, e.g. to ask questions and recieve answers, make requests rather than issue commands, and so on. Using Nature can then be reserved for the sorts of things a "normal" animal trainer (things like a warhorse trainer or a carnival lion tamer or a hunter with a pack of hounds)
might be able to accomplish and Diplomacy + feats/class features/etc. or spells can be used for actually straight up talking to animals like you'd expect a fantasy Druid to do.


Tridus wrote:
moosher12 wrote:
It does make me think, I'd like to see an expert skill feat that lets you use Nature to Make an Impression on an animal to improve its hostility level for the purpose of future taming. Perhaps with a -2 penalty at expert proficiency, removing the penalty at master proficiency.

Gonna be honest: I'm baffled that Nature can't already do this and I've been playing this game for years.

It makes far more sense than Diplomacy. Animals are not diplomats.

I think it would probably make sense to move influencing or making an impression on animals to Nature since it is a skill that already exists and is already used to command and train animals as one of its basic functions and has many feats revolving around that function, but from the perspective of just the Diplomacy skill I can see why they did it that way. Diplomacy is theoretically what you use to influence ANY creature in the game, even though for certain creature categories what it looks like to influence them is quite different from what it looks like to influence an intelligent humanoid. In those cases, the way this is typically handled is that you need specific feats or class features to use diplomacy on those types or creatures: a Druid's Animal or Plant Empathy lets you use it on animals or plants, the Corpse Tender Dedication lets you use it on mindless undead, the Oozemorph archetype's Ooze Empathy feat lets you use it on oozes, and so on. In general this works fine and doesn't really cause any confusion, but that's only because there isn't a basic "Ooze" skill which can be used untrained to command oozes or an "Undead" skill which can be used untrained to command mindless undead. There is however a "Nature" skill which can be used to command animals, so it kind of throws a wrench in things. Of course the Nature skill also has other uses, but those are mainly in being the Primal counterpart to Arcana/Religion/Occultism. Besides that it's main use is in commanding and training animals, which is unfortunately quite similar conceptually to Diplomacy.


Claxon wrote:
Dunwright wrote:
or taking it to the nearest bloomery to have it smelted. That just doesn't seem on par with the listed examples to me.
I don't outright disagree with you, but like if you have access to the right spells it becomes trivially easy to do (teleport to a volcano or disintegrate).

Trivially easy, sure, but they represent a rather substantial level of power on the part of the one who can make such a thing trivially easy (also, teleportation effects of that sort are almost always uncommon). I'm just saying it seems silly to list those things out as examples of how it can be destroyed if it can also be destroyed in the ways pretty much any other piece of armor can be- if that's the case why not just say that?


4 people marked this as a favorite.
VerBeeker wrote:

I mean I could see him doing it.

Nex has.

I imagine some other figures have as well.

Also we’re talking about all this and not acknowledging that Lovecraft’s books are all true stories, so is he an interviewer/chronicler in this canon??

I'm pretty sure the Osirian gods that have the same name as real Egyptian gods are said to be actually those same gods and that they turned their attention from Golarion to Earth in ancient times. I'm not sure if Paiso has retconned all of that though, I haven't seen them mentioned much since 1e and it seems like the kind of thing they'd want to leave behind as an artifact of the D&D-Pathfinder transition days.

Re: Lovecraft, I think Cthulu is ondeed sleeping on Pathfinder Earth. So, probably.


Warmagon wrote:
Thralls work differently, ergo there is something different that makes them more like minor obstacle than a 'real' enemy.

Notwithstanding of course that even the various thralls that are more like "real" enemies (Living Graveyard, Perfected Thrall, etc.) can also be moved through like difficult terrain and shoved aside. Again, I agree enemeis should be able to tell automatically when they can move through a creature. Thr game isn't really designed for hiding this knowledge, it's implicitly universal. I just disagree that you should be able to infer anything more from that fact alone- nevermind that whatever you might infer could very likely be wrong (since there are many different types of thralls- "this enemy will die in one hit" is not true for the aforementioned thralls, "this enemy will not hit me when not directly commanded to" is not true for Skeletal Lancers) or could be true of minions generally even when you can't move through them (like "this enemy will not generally stride or strike unless commanded").


1 person marked this as a favorite.

I don't know, it seems a bit silly to say a graveknight's armor can be destroyed by a 6th rank spell that totally obliterates matter and force constructs, taking it to another plane of existence whose energies are antithetical to it (doing this is a 7th rank uncommon spell or 7th rank uncommon ritual that also requires you to be in possession of a planar key, which is also uncommon), journeying to the heart of an active volcano (these are often gateways to the Plane of Fire in their own right) and throwing it in One Ring style... or taking it to the nearest bloomery to have it smelted. That just doesn't seem on par with the listed examples to me.


2 people marked this as a favorite.
Arkat wrote:
but I wouldn't go so far as to bring up the White Russians of 1930s Russia, Rasputin,

Well, that one is a little tricky because Baba Yaga in Pathfinder (who is a major figure in Irrisen) is said to from the area of Russia on Earth and there's an Adventure Path dealing with Baba Yaga which takes you Russia in the year 1918 and tasks you with killing Rasputin, who is in fact Baba Yaga's estranged song. Otherwise I would agree with you, and in the other cases mentioned I do, but this is just what the lore is there.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
TheTownsend wrote:

I don't see why they couldn't be self-taught. A youth stubles upon a wizard's spellbook and a champion's sword and shield in the woods where some unlucky party died, and spends years studying both, practicing every day. An urban thief burgles the appartment of a studious sorcerer and becomes fascinated with the reseach on teleportation until the veil opens up to them. A weaver hired to craft base textiles to be made into legendary mage's robes becomes obsessed with the arcane runes they're instructed to only begin the inscription of, gradually merging theories with their observations of the monks who frequent their services into a martial style all their own.

The magus subclasses are admittedly a fair bit more prescriptive than most PF2 classes, but I wouldn't necessarily assume the particular focus spells and martial styles have to be passed from teacher to student. The assumed implication could be that these patterns naturally emerge from blending magic with certain martial styles.

A magus certainly could be self-taught, as could indeed a wizard by the same logic, and I think Paizo devs would probably encourage people not to feel like playing a certain class locks them into any particular background, but I would suggest that the "typical" magus is probably not self-taught.

This next bit I'm writing is digging into 1e material, but since it's a lore question rather than a rules question and I don't think it's been specifically retconned I feel comfortable asserting that it has (or at least can have) some relevance to the discussion. 1e divided its classes into three categories which were used to influence character ages of you wanted to roll randomly for them, the idea being e.g. it usually takes longer to become basically proficient as a wizard than as a barbarian so a level 1 wizard will tend to be (but not always be) a little older on average than a level 1 barbarian. These categories were:

Intuitive: his category includes barbarians, oracles, rogues, and sorcerers.

Self-taught: This category includes bards, cavaliers, fighters, gunslingers, paladins, rangers, summoners, and witches.

Trained: This category includes alchemists, clerics, druids, inquisitors, magi, monks, and wizards.

Not all of these classes made the jump to 2e, and some that did were changed substantially, and in any case I wouldn't go so far as to suggest any of these classes should be "locked" into these categories; it's fine to play a self-taught wizard, or a rogue who was trained by a master thief. A fighter may have trained at a noble fencing academy and a monk may be somebody who intuitively awakened an awareness of his ki much like a sorcerer does their magic. But I do think this is a helpful quick guide for what the typical fantasy of these classes is.

All that being said, the iconic magus, Seltyiel, first learned magic by teaching it to himself from a magic tome, so certainly a magus can be self-taught! And since I brought up 1e it's only fair to mention that 1e also had a Magus archetype (Eldritch Scion) which selected a magical bloodline and cast spells spontaneously with CHA like a sorcerer, which is more in-line with the "intuitive" category. Given the hybrid nature of the class, it may even be that the martial skills and the magical skills are not acquired in the same way; perhaps a student at a wizardly academy practices fencing in his own time and experiments with incorporating magic into his bladework. You can imagine all sorts of origins for your specific magus character... but I would still suggest that most magi in the setting are probably formally trained to some degree.


As far as the spellcasting portion of the magus goes they are basically wizards (even down to the spellbook), the difference being that they split their studies between wizardry and martial practice. So I would suggest that they probably generally have similar origins to wizards, such as the two you mentioned, being trained in academies or apprenticed individiually under a master. Given the more martial inclination, I would suggest that the academies which train magi may be military academies which are sponsored by states/kingdoms rather than the more typical strictly-scholarly academies one usually imagines for a wizard. But you could fit magi into a more typical magical academy too; it is a unique magical practice which is worthy of study in its own right.


Finoan wrote:

Being able to target an area spell to a location that the caster cannot see is a violation of the rules for Targeting.

Sorry, can you quote what rule you think this is violating?


1 person marked this as a favorite.

One thing I will note regarding Fireball specifically is that unlike 1e, which was quite clear, which was quite clear that fireball starts as a spark originating from the caster and detonates when it hits a solid barrier or object, 2e fireball does not state that there is any physical effect that originates from the caster that can be detonated early. As far I can tell it simply detonates are the designated origin point (pre-remaster it even said the fireball "appears" there, but post-resmaster that word was changed to "detonates" which is less clear but still doesn't suggest anything about there being a spark travelling from thr caster like 1e.). Per the line of effect rules you still need line of effect to the desired origin point of the fireball, which may or may not be affected by the presence of a wall of force, but I see nothing to indicate a fireball would detonate on a wall of it hit one. I think the spell would either be cast successfully or fail because you don't have line of effect (depending on how you rule that issue), and would never detonate outside of the desired originating point of the blast.


3 people marked this as a favorite.

1. IMO, yes. YuriP notes that the Archives of Nethys description actually links to the invisible condition page here, but I think that's just a judgement call from the AoN folks. However, I think it's the correct call.

2. Following from 1, I'd say yes, until somebody detects the wall by some means.

3. Following from 1 and 2, I'd say yes IF the wall is still undetected (undetected meaning they don't even knlw what spaces the wall occupies, so this seems fair), noting that since a wall has no stealth DC any seek check can from it from undetected to hidden. Hidden (meaning your enemy knows what spaces you occupy but not your exact position) technically still imposes a DC 11 check, but makes an exception for area effects (presumably because it fills the entire square so your exact position is irrelevant). Given the nature of a wall, I'd be willing to say that all attacks against it should work like an area effect for this purpose; if you're attacking the right square you literally can't miss it. Not sure that that's precisely RAW, but it makes sense to me.

4. Here we get a little funky. For a detected wall, I would say it works like any other wall, since "visibility doesn't matter for Line of Effect". RAW I think this would cause physical effects to be unable to target creatures through a wall even if the wall is undetected. If the wall is undetected however, it would be cheesy to let you discover it by trying to target a creature on the other side and failing. I would say if the wall is undetected you should be able to target creatures on the other side, and the wall will then block appropriate effects (revealing itself and suffering the impact of the effect, no DC to be hit by as per point 3). I am not sure this is RAW though. RAW I think the spell simply fails or cannot be cast due to lack of line of effect.

5. The answer here should follow from 4.


I imagine most of the inconsistencies are just errors that editing didn't catch. Personally I'd follow normal English rules (proper nouns are almost always capitalized) unless it's explicitly stated somewhere that you shouldn't.


On the other hand, if the party's solution to "try to catch a yak" is "spin a madcap top at it", it can be a suitable challenge at any level.


3 people marked this as a favorite.

To be honest, now I think your table not letting you use skills to calm an animal may be the least strange part of that entire incident.


None of us were at your table so we can't speak as to whatever fine details if any may have thrown this off, but based purely on what you've told us I see no reason why you wouldn't be able to use your skills to calm the animal (though I agree with Dragonchess Player that Diplomacy is a more suitable skill than Nature here; Nature can command an animal, but I think this is more like changing attitudes under the Diplomacy skill, and Nature's command an animal automatically fails if the creature is hostile or unfriendly anyway).


Kavlor wrote:


Koschei the Deathless—effectively the progenitor of the very concept of the "lich" in a form close to the modern one.

Well, Pathfinder actually did try to use this one a little; in 1e there was a demon lord called Kostchtchie, who wass a originally a mortal that struck a bargain with Baba Yaga to become immortal and had his wish twiated by having his soul placed in a torc and made him a giant, after which he fled to the Outee Rifts and eventually became a demon lord without ever having died. There was at least some mythological inspiration here, though a lot of his attributes were inherited from the D&D demin lord of the same name who was similarly loosed based on the Slavic myth, and I think he was quietly dropped from 2e, partly because they wanted to get away from shared gods with D&D due to legal concerns (see also Orcus among others) and possibly partly because that interpretation of him was extremely misogynistic (a characteristic inherited from D&D depictions- not sure if that's accurate to the myths) in a way Paizo's writing teams have moved away from depicting. It would be interesting to see a more faithful rendition attempted, but I think they might avoid it on account of the potential legal concerns re: the D&D character.

1 to 50 of 121 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>