Baleful Polymorph in PFS


Pathfinder Society

Sovereign Court

So, I have a character concept I want to play. Unfortunately, it hinges on Baleful Polymorph.

As in, at the start of a session I contract some spellcasting services to cast Baleful Polymorph on my character. Level 5 spell, total cost 450 gp per cast. And I have to resolve the condition (it is a curse) by the end of the session or the character is "unplayable". Note: I want this curse, and will pay for it, but it still fits the definition of "unplayable".

Resolving the Baleful Polymorph is a non-issue due to Kitsune having the Shapechanger subtype.

450 gp isn't bad at the higher levels, but having to beat a Will DC 17 to keep class abilities, or pay another 450 gp to try again, is going to be a little difficult at lower levels. And I'd like to play it from 2 xp on.

Is there anyway we can get Baleful Polymorph added to the list of spells that carry over between scenarios? Is there a boon out there to allow you to keep a curse/condition, even when it has a mechanical effect?

Any other suggestions?

Grand Lodge 4/5

Baleful Polymorph was front and center to the arguments previously about having to clear everything. It's not going to be added to the things that stick around.

Liberty's Edge 5/5

Kitsune change won't cure Baleful polymorph.

Grand Lodge 4/5

Andrew Christian wrote:
Kitsune change won't cure Baleful polymorph.

It will, actually. Kitsune have the Shapechanger subtype, and Baleful Polymorph says this:

Quote:
Incorporeal or gaseous creatures are immune to baleful polymorph, and a creature with the shapechanger subtype can revert to its natural form as a standard action.

You'd have to make the will save to not have your mind turned into an animal, but you can turn back fine.

Dark Archive 5/5

Yeah- that wont fly at my table either....

Grand Lodge 4/5

wellsmv wrote:
Yeah- that wont fly at my table either....

What won't fly? If you mean keeping Baleful Polymorph from scenario to scenario, yeah, it shouldn't fly. If you mean any of the rest of it, I don't see why you would have any reason to disallow it, unless it resulted in problematic behavior.

The Exchange 4/5

What shape are you wanting from baleful?

5/5 5/55/55/5

You might hit some table variation on whether you can voluntarily fail the fort save but not the will save.

There is a baleful polymorph curse but I don't think that makes all baleful polymorphs a curse.

Being a kitsune and all wouldn't just taking the fox shape feat do most of this for you?

Sovereign Court

Started with the concept of a Swashbuckler(Mouser) being an actual cat.

Kinda evolved into Cat Sith from Dresden for those of you familiar.

And who doesn't want to play the cat that started "cat vs commoners" thread from other systems...

Occultist 1(have one from the playtest), Swashbuckler(Mouser) 2, Barbarian(Urban) 2, Occultist X is the current napkin sketch. Occultist gets the ability to use spells that don't have somatic or verbal components so either Ghost Sound/Message to communicate to party. So as long as I make the saves it should not really hamper the party any. And if I don't make the save, I just spend the session in Kitsune form with an Agile Rapier.

Surprisingly effective once the Amulet of Mighty Fists(Agile) and Lesser Beast Totem come online. So 4 claws and a bite with Dex to damage around level 5.

For some reason I was thinking Baleful Polymorph had the curse keyword added in Ultimate Magic.

I had not realized Baleful Polymorph was at the center of the discussion previously. I guess to play this character concept I'll just have to shell out the gold and making the saves every session then.

Grand Lodge 4/5

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Note that Ghost Sound cannot replicate intelligible speech, and Message requires you to be able to speak yourself.

Sovereign Court

Hm... there it is, Figment Subschool. Good to know. And I suppose the verbal components of Message are not referring to the actual message you want to send, but rather the 'mic check' before hand.

Ioun Stone then, I suppose.

Grand Lodge 4/5

Yeah, the verbal components of Message are to set the link up, they're not the message themselves.

5/5 5/55/55/5

Surprisingly effective once the Amulet of Mighty Fists(Agile) and Lesser Beast Totem come online. So 4 claws and a bite with Dex to damage around level 5.

How do you get four claws? A cat has two. Barbarian claws go on your hands, you specifically can't grow them on your feat as per the faq.

Sovereign Court

Can you point me to that FAQ? I am not seeing it under Advanced Players Guide FAQ.

Regardless, a cat does not have arms, there are other creatures with feet claws, and who says a cat's default claws are on the front feet?

And the extra claws aren't really that important. If I go fox shape though I'd pick them up.

5/5 5/55/55/5

*Dig dig dig*

I really wish they'd put these all on one page...

Linky

If you are a quadruped (or have more than four legs), you can have claws on your feet. If you have claws on all of your feet, normally you can't use all of those claw attacks on your turn unless you have a special ability such as pounce or rake.

5/5

Jeff Merola wrote:
Andrew Christian wrote:
Kitsune change won't cure Baleful polymorph.

It will, actually. Kitsune have the Shapechanger subtype, and Baleful Polymorph says this:

Quote:
Incorporeal or gaseous creatures are immune to baleful polymorph, and a creature with the shapechanger subtype can revert to its natural form as a standard action.
You'd have to make the will save to not have your mind turned into an animal, but you can turn back fine.

I'd think if you failed the will save, you'd be a little more problem than that...

PRD Baleful Polymorph wrote:
If this second save fails, the creature loses its extraordinary, supernatural, and spell-like abilities, loses its ability to cast spells (if it had the ability), and gains the alignment, special abilities, and Intelligence, Wisdom, and Charisma scores of its new form in place of its own.

Kitsune shape change ability is a Supernatural ability. If you fail the Will save, you lose that ability. If you made the Will save, you'd still have it and could revert as you wish though...

Sovereign Court

It has nothing to do with the Kitsune change shape ability, and everything to do with the shapechanger subtype. Baleful polymorph specifically calls out creatures with the shapechanger subtype can shift back to normal as a standard action.

5/5 5/55/55/5

Firebug wrote:
It has nothing to do with the Kitsune change shape ability, and everything to do with the shapechanger subtype. Baleful polymorph specifically calls out creatures with the shapechanger subtype can shift back to normal as a standard action.

Right, but why would a kitty cat know that its a kitsune that can do that?

I mean I haven't ASKED my cat if he's ever thought of being a kitsune but I'm going to go out on a limb and say he hasn't. The bewildering interactions of polymorph rules aside, without having the mental faculties to know "I am a kitsune, I can change my shape" you can't do it.

You can get 99% of what you're going for here with the foxshape feat. Head for that

5/5

BigNorseWolf wrote:
Firebug wrote:
It has nothing to do with the Kitsune change shape ability, and everything to do with the shapechanger subtype. Baleful polymorph specifically calls out creatures with the shapechanger subtype can shift back to normal as a standard action.

Right, but why would a kitty cat know that its a kitsune that can do that?

I mean I haven't ASKED my cat if he's ever thought of being a kitsune but I'm going to go out on a limb and say he hasn't. The bewildering interactions of polymorph rules aside, without having the mental faculties to know "I am a kitsune, I can change my shape" you can't do it.

You can get 99% of what you're going for here with the foxshape feat. Head for that

This.

You no longer have the mental capacity of a kitsune. You think you're a house cat (or whatever you've changed into). You have no knowledge, desire, will, or wherewithal to try and change to anything else if you fail your Will save.

Sovereign Court

BigNorseWolf wrote:

*Dig dig dig*

I really wish they'd put these all on one page...

Linky

If you are a quadruped (or have more than four legs), you can have claws on your feet. If you have claws on all of your feet, normally you can't use all of those claw attacks on your turn unless you have a special ability such as pounce or rake.

So as a quadruped, i could get claw x3 and bite x1, standing on 1 leg with a spinning flurry of claws... or just go fox form and be less complicated. And less thematic.

The way you are arguing baleful polymorph is as if the specific exception for shapechangers was not there. Polymorph subschool changes your physical form, but it never says you change your creature types (and subtypes). And as creature subtypes are not ex, su, or sp you keep it regardless.

4/5

2 people marked this as a favorite.
Kevin Ingle wrote:
BigNorseWolf wrote:
Firebug wrote:
It has nothing to do with the Kitsune change shape ability, and everything to do with the shapechanger subtype. Baleful polymorph specifically calls out creatures with the shapechanger subtype can shift back to normal as a standard action.

Right, but why would a kitty cat know that its a kitsune that can do that?

I mean I haven't ASKED my cat if he's ever thought of being a kitsune but I'm going to go out on a limb and say he hasn't. The bewildering interactions of polymorph rules aside, without having the mental faculties to know "I am a kitsune, I can change my shape" you can't do it.

You can get 99% of what you're going for here with the foxshape feat. Head for that

This.

You no longer have the mental capacity of a kitsune. You think you're a house cat (or whatever you've changed into). You have no knowledge, desire, will, or wherewithal to try and change to anything else if you fail your Will save.

I don't know. My cat is constantly willing himself to develop opposable thumbs. I dread the day he finally succeeds.

5/5 5/55/55/5

Firebug wrote:


So as a quadruped, i could get claw x3 and bite x1, standing on 1 leg with a spinning flurry of claws... or just go fox form and be less complicated. And less thematic.

Nope. Doesn't matter how many claws you have, you can normally only make use of 2 of them.


What if his ally pathfinder uses speak with animals to tell him he's a fox-person? Does his cat brain explode and get super smart as he changes back to a kitsune? Maybe if fox's (haha) cunning cast first?

5/5 5/55/55/5

Peshmonster wrote:
What if his ally pathfinder uses speak with animals to tell him he's a fox-person? Does his cat brain explode and get super smart as he changes back to a kitsune? Maybe if fox's (haha) cunning cast first?

Baleful polymorph doesn't change the type, so he's still technically not a an animal you can talk to with speak with animals.

As a cat, he probably considers the talky party members beneath his notice. He's DEFINITELY going to consider turning into anything thats notacat as a downgrade. His people are gods you know.

Scarab Sages 2/5

BigNorseWolf wrote:
Firebug wrote:


So as a quadruped, i could get claw x3 and bite x1, standing on 1 leg with a spinning flurry of claws... or just go fox form and be less complicated. And less thematic.
Nope. Doesn't matter how many claws you have, you can normally only make use of 2 of them.

It is like how some people say you can get 2 gore attacks or two bite attacks with a single head. Though you have one head, you are not really able to much on multiple targets in one round like Homer on doughnuts.


BigNorseWolf wrote:
Peshmonster wrote:
What if his ally pathfinder uses speak with animals to tell him he's a fox-person? Does his cat brain explode and get super smart as he changes back to a kitsune? Maybe if fox's (haha) cunning cast first?

Baleful polymorph doesn't change the type, so he's still technically not a an animal you can talk to with speak with animals.

As a cat, he probably considers the talky party members beneath his notice. He's DEFINITELY going to consider turning into anything thats notacat as a downgrade. His people are gods you know.

So you just need fox's cunning then. Either way I like this thread, because now I can use baleful polymorph to change anything with the shapechanger subtype into a kitten and if they fail the will save I can show my GM that they cannot do anything about it.

Sovereign Court

Whoa, who said anything about "kittens"?

I wasn't going for a cute angle here...

5/5 5/55/55/5

Peshmonster wrote:


So you just need fox's cunning then.

That doesn't help. You're now an especially smart cat that KNOWS its better than anything else. Nor is giving you an int score of 6 going to let you suddenly speak taldan and let the party explain the complex predicament you're now in.


BigNorseWolf wrote:
Peshmonster wrote:


So you just need fox's cunning then.

That doesn't help. You're now an especially smart cat that KNOWS its better than anything else. Nor is giving you an int score of 6 going to let you suddenly speak taldan and let the party explain the complex predicament you're now in.

You don't need Taldan, you still can understand common. Then someone just tells you that you are not a cat. You don't lose your ability to understand a language when you are polymorphed (from polymorph itself, you do because of having an int less than 3), you do lose the ability to read and speak it though. Once the stat is bumped back up you are just fine.

Scarab Sages 2/5

BigNorseWolf wrote:
Peshmonster wrote:


So you just need fox's cunning then.

That doesn't help. You're now an especially smart cat that KNOWS its better than anything else. Nor is giving you an int score of 6 going to let you suddenly speak taldan and let the party explain the complex predicament you're now in.

How about the Bear's Jig masterpiece? Lets them gain intellect as the Awaken Spell for a few rounds.

5/5

Peshmonster wrote:
BigNorseWolf wrote:
Peshmonster wrote:


So you just need fox's cunning then.

That doesn't help. You're now an especially smart cat that KNOWS its better than anything else. Nor is giving you an int score of 6 going to let you suddenly speak taldan and let the party explain the complex predicament you're now in.

You don't need Taldan, you still can understand common. Then someone just tells you that you are not a cat. You don't lose your ability to understand a language when you are polymorphed, you do lose the ability to read and speak it though. Once the stat is bumped back up you are just fine.

Umm...Taldane IS common...


Kevin Ingle wrote:
Peshmonster wrote:
BigNorseWolf wrote:
Peshmonster wrote:


So you just need fox's cunning then.

That doesn't help. You're now an especially smart cat that KNOWS its better than anything else. Nor is giving you an int score of 6 going to let you suddenly speak taldan and let the party explain the complex predicament you're now in.

You don't need Taldan, you still can understand common. Then someone just tells you that you are not a cat. You don't lose your ability to understand a language when you are polymorphed, you do lose the ability to read and speak it though. Once the stat is bumped back up you are just fine.
Umm...Taldane IS common...

For now, I was just making my post correct for all possible futures...yeah

Sovereign Court

I'm doing something similar although using Fox Shape. Per talking to other party members, there is a ring in the ACG that allows you to talk even when shape changed.

5/5 5/55/5 *** Venture-Captain, Germany—Hamburg

If you fail the will save, Baleful Polymorph turns you into a normal animal, except that your actual stats are "sleeping" somewhere in the background, which is why your mental ability scores and alignment change to those of the animal. That's how I always rule it, which means such a character is essentially dead unless something like Break Enchantment is cast on the victim.

Seriously, Baleful Polymorph is an offensive spell. Trying to abuse it should remain a dangerous thing to do.

Peshmonster wrote:
Either way I like this thread, because now I can use baleful polymorph to change anything with the shapechanger subtype into a kitten and if they fail the will save I can show my GM that they cannot do anything about it.

Yep, if you cast Baleful Polymorph on an NPC and that NPC fails both saves, you have defeated him/her. Happened to me once in a home game when the witch wanted to try out her new spell on the boss of the dungeon they were in. The barbarian wasn't too happy to see the fight he was looking forward to being canceled.

2/5 *

Pathfinder Rulebook, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber

I baleful Polymorphed the first big fight in Where Mammoths Fear to Tread, the big fort stacked monster failed its fort save and passed its will. It was a beautiful thing.

5/5 *****

Ellias Aubec wrote:
I'm doing something similar although using Fox Shape. Per talking to other party members, there is a ring in the ACG that allows you to talk even when shape changed.

Expect a lot of table variation on whether or not the ring gives you the ability to speak when you are otherwise unable to do so or just let's you know 4 extra languages.

Liberty's Edge 5/5 5/5 *** Venture-Lieutenant, Indiana—Martinsville

A Kitten, huh?

To bad Tibbits are not around, that would be fun...

Grand Lodge 4/5

andreww wrote:
Ellias Aubec wrote:
I'm doing something similar although using Fox Shape. Per talking to other party members, there is a ring in the ACG that allows you to talk even when shape changed.
Expect a lot of table variation on whether or not the ring gives you the ability to speak when you are otherwise unable to do so or just let's you know 4 extra languages.

Uh...why would there be table variation on this?

The ring in question wrote:
The wearer retains the ability to speak in these languages even if she assumes a form normally unable to do so (such as a druid wild shaped into a wolf).

Community / Forums / Organized Play / Pathfinder Society / Baleful Polymorph in PFS All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Pathfinder Society