
![]() |

DrDeth wrote:Everyone's entitled to err on the side of their own personal tastes, but I stand by my opinion that the only thing worse than movies based on video games are video games based on movies.Shadowborn wrote:If the movie is going to be anything like the last two, then just tar and feather anyone planning on being involved in the project. Nip that right in the bud right now. Movies based on video games are so consistently bad that there's no point in making them just because one might buck the trend.I kinda liked the first one. It was hardly Oscar worthy, but it was a fun film. Jolie was great.
If you consider the Arkham games to be based on the Batman movies (they are clearly a very different version of Batman, but I doubt we would have seen them had not the movies been such a huge success), then they are examples of good video games based on movies.
Other than that we have Telltale Games' superb "The Walking Dead", which is one of the best video games Iv'e played this year and is simply better than the TV show in every way (again, I know it's actually based on a comic book but it happened because of the TV show).
Other than that, some of the Star Wars video games were decent, some were great (Knights of the Old Republic by Biowere). I never played the aforementioned "Escape from Butcher Bay" but I only ever heard good things about it.
Besides, the movie "Doom" was, like, the best movie ever.

![]() |

If you consider the Arkham games to be based on the Batman movies (they are clearly a very different version of Batman, but I doubt we would have seen them had not the movies been such a huge success), then they are examples of good video games based on movies.
The Arkham games are pretty blatantly NOT based on the Nolan-verse Batman, given the existence of superpowers and the fact that Two-Face's criminal career lasted longer than 20 minutes.

ngc7293 |

Sebastrd wrote:Sorry, but after looking up Gemma, I have to say, "Maybe?"Especially if they go with the more realistic Lara of the reboot, instead of the blowup doll of previous games.Of course, Gemma also has the right assets to play either.
The Jolie movies were based on a popular video game. I liked both movies.
However, if someone wants to create a new movie and base a character on realism like Bear Grylls, watch reality TV.
If not, make an entertaining movie based on a video game.
If it's going to be the other way around, I'm sure there will be a lot of people NOT watching it.

![]() |

The Jolie movies were based on a popular video game. I liked both movies.However, if someone wants to create a new movie and base a character on realism like Bear Grylls, watch reality TV.
If not, make an entertaining movie based on a video game.
If it's going to be the other way around, I'm sure there will be a lot of people NOT watching it.
Er, I'm talking about basing it on the VIDEO GAME reboot. The one that was the most successful entry in the franchise to date. And that is being re-released on the PS4 and XBone.
The fact that I called it more realistic is mostly based on the fact that Lara in the game looks more like an actual woman than a blowup doll.

ngc7293 |

Er, I'm talking about basing it on the VIDEO GAME reboot. The one that was the most successful entry in the franchise to date. And that is being re-released on the PS4 and XBone.The fact that I called it more realistic is mostly based on the fact that Lara in the game looks more like an actual woman than a blowup doll.
Then Why are you posting in the Movie section? The OP asked for a vote on a replacement for Angelina Jolie. Nothing in it said ANYTHING about a game or a movie. Since the post was in movies, I had to assume this was for a movie. I didn't like any of the Rough and Real characters that were posed and I gave my 2 cents on the matter.

Rynjin |

Then Why are you posting in the Movie section? The OP asked for a vote on a replacement for Angelina Jolie. Nothing in it said ANYTHING about a game or a movie. Since the post was in movies, I had to assume this was for a movie. I didn't like any of the Rough and Real characters that were posed and I gave my 2 cents on the matter.
Context.
It's important.

Oceanshieldwolf |

Jaelithe |