Riddles are a staple of myths in the real world going back a very, very, VERY long time.That much I agree with.I love it all, combat, RP, building characters, political intrigue, skill challenges...
Except mazes and puzzles. F*** that mess. Let me roll an int check and move on, my 23 int wizard should be able to solve that if I'm too dumb for it.
Oh Lordy yes! I am not that great at puzzles most of the time. I really can't understand the point of them either. Yes, I know they are a staple of certain types of fiction. I never understood their inclusion there either. It always seemed like poor storytelling to me.
"Gosh I can't figure out a reason why everyone else didn't kill the monster before this guy showed up. Guess I'll throw another puzzle in there, that's always good to make people miss the hole in the plot."
That's what I said. I know they are a staple in certain types of fiction. But it almost always seems like a very poor plot device in all those old ones as well. Even more so when you assume magic is available.
Why would the evil mastermind put a puzzle, maze, or riddle controlling his secret escape route? That would just slow him down trying to escape. Especially when you consider he could just use magic that identifies and only opens for him. No puzzle necessary.
Ok, your secret escape tunnel has a set of levers to pull in the correct order or 'dead,' so why would you put a set of levers on the outside coming in? You can walk into your fortress through the front door. If you want to make a stealthy entrance, again there is magic you can use without weakening your security.
Ok, so you have a set of levers on the outside coming in. Why make there be any logical order? It is the key to your whole security. Maybe it would be smarter to make it random and just memorize it.
Ok, you've got the levers and there is a logical order. If someone uses the wrong order, why have it shoot a dart that just might inconvenience someone's great grandmother? It wouldn't even stop a cookie selling girl scout (some of them are damn tenacious).
Yes, occasionally there is an actual reasoning behind them. Like the Egyptian pyramids conglomeration of traps. Their religion has them being buried with riches, can't let others steal them, but they also don't want to be trapped in there forever. AND they don't have magic to take care of it.
And occasionally you could have some sort of DR Evil that likes to watch the helpless scurry through the death maze. But that particular brand of insanity should be pretty rare (rather than every other bad guy).
Yes, they are a staple. That doesn't mean it makes any sense.
If you use "making sense" in the narrative sense as a standard do you realize how many standard fantasy tropes go away?
It doesn't have to make sense from our non magical world's perspective. Just internal logic would be nice.
I dislike, and have not before, nor will again use the word "homebrew".
It's game/system ideas, not beer.
I get really annoyed over the excessive use of abbreviations instead of typing out the whole word/phrase. Is it that difficult to type it out? I can understand if you're hand writing it, but...
|
Yes, occasionally there is an actual reasoning behind them. Like the Egyptian pyramids conglomeration of traps. Their religion has them being buried with riches, can't let others steal them, but they also don't want to be trapped in there forever. AND they don't have magic to take care of it.
And occasionally you could have some sort of DR Evil that likes to watch the helpless scurry through the death maze. But that particular brand of insanity should be pretty rare (rather than every other bad guy).
Yes, they are a staple. That doesn't mean it makes any sense.
I just go with the classic 'tests to prove your worth' thing. Often BBEGs can't be bothered to create their own labyrinth and just set up shop in on of said 'tests to prove your worth' labyrinths.
|
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
One of the dungeons I made confronted the adventurers with two doors. Behind one was a deathtrap. Behind the other was the tower treasury. The players came across a fairly simple riddle that indicated that the door on the right was the correct one to open.
The door to the right led to the deathtrap -- because the BBEG was not an idiot.
| 4 people marked this as a favorite. |
I have it all worked out on how to turn Carrion Crown into Ghostbusters, now I just need the time...
I get really annoyed over the excessive use of abbreviations instead of typing out the whole word/phrase. Is it that difficult to type it out? I can understand if you're hand writing it, but...
Whrn my PCs are all SAD, I'll GMPC a MAD, and MAD makes it not OP for good party balance. Especially when they're up against a strong BBEG or in one of the APs.
I get really annoyed over the excessive use of abbreviations instead of typing out the whole word/phrase. Is it that difficult to type it out? I can understand if you're hand writing it, but...
Anymore I post about 98% of the time from my phone. Abbreviations are a must.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
It just gets to me when I spend more of my time trying to figure out what the Hell the acronyms and abbreviations mean than I do reading the post.
I get really annoyed over the excessive use of abbreviations instead of typing out the whole word/phrase. Is it that difficult to type it out? I can understand if you're hand writing it, but...
If you're going to make a point about people using abbreviations and end it with "is it that difficult to type it out?" you should take care not to undermine your point by using contractions like "you're" (instead of you are) and "word/phrase" (instead of word or phrase).
You really answered your own question there.
I don't see that was the same thing, seeing as the contractions are accepted use of the English language, and I don't have to do research every time they are used to figure out what they mean.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
So shun me, hence the point of the thread...
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
The research is the bigger part of the problem; not everyone frequents the boards (or other boards) enough to know what all the abbreviations and terms are. If so, we wouldn't have the story of how the mighty Stormwind Fallacy got its name.
Some terms have migrated from online games, for example. It took a while before I understood what people were babbling about when they talked about aggro as I don't frequent those sorts of boards.
I don't see that was the same thing, seeing as the contractions are accepted use of the English language, and I don't have to do research every time they are used to figure out what they mean.
Abbreviations (or more accurately, acronyms) are an accepted part of ANY language.
Do you say:
"I'm calling the Federal Bureau of Investigation!"
or
"I'm calling the FBI!"
Same with ATM, PIN, etc.
Even more so with the advent of the internet. I understand being annoyed at the more esoteric ones, but extremely common ones like IMO should be instantly translated by most people, and at worst all it takes is looking it up once. At which point it speeds up the typing process considerably, especially for people who are slow typers, are typing long messages, or who are posting from a phone (or any combination of the above).
|
|
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
The research is the bigger part of the problem; not everyone frequents the boards (or other boards) enough to know what all the abbreviations and terms are.
I spend a fair amount of time on the boards, and I occasionally run into abbreviations that I have to assume the poster pulled out of the ass-end of nowhere, because I don't have a clue what they mean.
Riddles are a staple of myths in the real world going back a very, very, VERY long time.That much I agree with.I love it all, combat, RP, building characters, political intrigue, skill challenges...
Except mazes and puzzles. F*** that mess. Let me roll an int check and move on, my 23 int wizard should be able to solve that if I'm too dumb for it.
Oh Lordy yes! I am not that great at puzzles most of the time. I really can't understand the point of them either. Yes, I know they are a staple of certain types of fiction. I never understood their inclusion there either. It always seemed like poor storytelling to me.
"Gosh I can't figure out a reason why everyone else didn't kill the monster before this guy showed up. Guess I'll throw another puzzle in there, that's always good to make people miss the hole in the plot."
That's what I said. I know they are a staple in certain types of fiction. But it almost always seems like a very poor plot device in all those old ones as well. Even more so when you assume magic is available.
Why would the evil mastermind put a puzzle, maze, or riddle controlling his secret escape route? That would just slow him down trying to escape. Especially when you consider he could just use magic that identifies and only opens for him. No puzzle necessary.
Ok, your secret escape tunnel has a set of levers to pull in the correct order or 'dead,' so why would you put a set of levers on the outside coming in? You can walk into your fortress through the front door. If you want to make a stealthy entrance, again there is magic you can use without weakening your security.
Ok, so you have a set of levers on the outside coming in. Why make there be any logical order? It is the key to your whole security. Maybe it would be smarter to make it random and just memorize it.
Ok, you've got the levers and there is a logical order. If someone uses the wrong order,...
Consider LOTR, the riddle above the door to Moria. It was intended to allow allies a way into Moria without requiring the dwarves to share the password with each individual. It was also made in light pf the elves culture and abilities. It even stumped Gandalf.
There are occassional puzzles that make sense, and the bbeg isn't always the one who made it.
If the GM(Game Master) is going to RP(Role Play) a Sphinx, keep in mind that they love riddles.
When I GM, a Sphinx can answer any question, but only in the form of a riddle. They don't know the answer till they get someone to solve it.
Likewise, Djinn can't grant their own wishes.
Otherwise, they would have power beyond their CR(Challenge Rating).
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
This is starting to sound like "dang puzzles gettin in da way of mah killin stuff".
This is starting to sound like "dang puzzles gettin in da way of mah killin stuff".
Only if you insist on reading it that way.
Not everybody finds puzzles fun. I sure don't. I like a good riddle (a GOOD riddle mind you, none of those obtuse b$#!#++% riddles you can literally only guess if you already know the answer like what's in the Hobbit) every now and then, but I've never been a big fan of purely mental puzzles.
This is starting to sound like "dang puzzles gettin in da way of mah killin stuff".
There's always the "The Riddle of Steel" for that.
I once started trying to design a dungeon for Pony finder.
First encounter: A Sphinx living at the fork in the road.
"To reach the dungeon you must follow the right path."
The right path leads to the dungeon entrance. The left path leads back to town.
