Legal to post copyrighted materials???


Conversions


Hey,

I own some old books. I would like to convert some of the old stuff in them to Pathfinder. Is it okay if I post the original text, and my conversions to it on here?

Can't be to cautious.... :D

Grand Lodge

That would be a question for the original copyright holder.


It depends on how you do the conversions.

If you convert them into unrecognizable variants with different names, then you can claim the work isn't a "copy" but is in fact a new work of art. However, if you end up with something recognizable and the original creator sues, then you put the question of "is it recognizably the same stuff" into the hands of a jury.

Posting the original text is a direct copyright violation, especially for the use you have here.

There is a "fair use" clause in the copyright law that says any published material can have (usually small) excerpts copied for legitimate purposes (such as doing a review). Posting a bunch of monster descriptions with the express purpose of putting your own versions of them out there would probably run afoul of even the "fair use" clause.

My recommendation would be "don't do this without the express, written permission of the original author."


In general, you can't post copywritten materials. Thats why they were copyrighted in the first place - the original authors didn't want their stuff to be made freely available to everyone.

At least in the US, there are Fair Use laws that do allow a limited amount of copywriten material to be reproduced. However, what exactly is considered Fair Use is vague, and can only be determined by a judge. Even then, what one considered Fair Use may be too much for another judge.

Its just easier to not reproduce copywritten materials at all.


So lets just say I post the conversion of a prestige class, just the barbones basic stuff that everyone needs to know about the prestige (as it's very uncommonly known). Is this common? Do you think that this is acceptable (literally 1/2 page worth of information).


well many monsters have similar stats to coprwrited ones. just post the crunch and leave out the fluff.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Conversions / Legal to post copyrighted materials??? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Conversions