| williambertram |
Thank you for posting this. It's hard to believe this vaguery has made it this far, and that literally dozens of threads full of confused players on the same subject still has not promoted clear, and easy to understand language like you wrote. I am using your clarification in my game. It's like writing "Rogues can sneak attack from stealth" or "Rogues cannot sneak attack from stealth" would kill them or something. Frustrating.
...I think everyone agrees that the rules for Stealth and Perception and Sneak Attack are very vague and open to misinterpretation. My hope in this thread can be used to constructively reach a consensus on how to rephrase/rewrite these rules to make them clear, concise, and correct.
A grand experiment, if you will.
This is a huge post so I've buried the relevent discussions in the following spoilers:
** spoiler omitted **
** spoiler omitted **