Given what we've already played, our group would really like to see another city-based AP, where it's based 3/4ths of the time in a big city, with politics and intrigue. We're also bigger fans of low-to-medium magic & fantasy. Between these two things, we'd love to see an AP that's mostly about humanoids and without a lot of kitchen-sink creatures thrown in. So something kind of like Game of Thrones or a Waterdeep campaign, or even a very historical campaign with a little bit of magic and monsters thrown in, etc
This is the missing link for us, since we're finding APs/campaigns of other genres that we like, but that we're putting off since we really need a change of pace- politics, intrigue, character depth, low magic, etc.
If anyone knows of a product like this, will you please PM me?
(we already know about Council of Thieves)
Hopefully their Adventure Path strategy is not to try to please everyone every time, but to really make an excellent genre of whatever specific genre they pick. Trying to please everyone every time is where muzak comes from.