Dam web browser crashed before I posted my reply - sorry this is only what I remeber of what it was going to say.
Talon wrote:
Not every joke one tells starts with an open declaration that the speaker is intending to tell a joke. This joke for example would have failed If I had added one. And I believe there is a place for humor in these boards, otherwise no one would have answered to this "rubbish".
The problem of unmarked humour was first noted in the 80s and the solution is a Smiley.
a) I can't see your face, how do I know a joke is a joke. For the same reason it is dangious to say Fire in a crowd, not everyone can see your humous intent and some people over react.
b) not everyone is part of your culture or speaks your langauge, hence your joke might not be funny when they try to understand it from a second language speakerspoint of view.
c) looking at a thread at a later time, your post can be seen out of its original context and then not be seen as a joke and may be even libalious.
With a Smiley I would probly have laughed or even joined in, without it, it irritated me. The AP is 400 pages long, almost none of the NPC are described in full in one place, in fact most of them have descriptions in 2 or more places. The adventrure is confusing enought as is and they did not put the descriptions of an NPC with there stat blocks with there motivations through the path at the same location. It would not have suprised me that there is some side block somewhere that a major NPC has a twist that I did not see on the several reads throughs I have done. Please tell me as your sure you can remeber all the 400 pages of the adventure? Personally I have no such confedence and I am computer programmer that us used to this sort of useless specifications ;)
Also, remeber that only 1% to 5% of readers will reply /at all/ to any posts on a list or board. Hence as 2 or 3 people where confued at the smallest you confused 40 people, and it could have been at the outside 300.
Regards
DaveF