Dancing Wind wrote:
Tyler Hildebran wrote:
This feels like it's giving gatekeepers more fuel for the fire. Our community is pretty great, and I haven't seen much of that kind of behavior, but as soon as people can point to an app that empirically says "I know more about this than you" it's gonna be a problem somewhere, sometime. Just thought I'd put that out there.
How is having the high score in a trivia game "gatekeeping"? As long as you can buy any Pathfinder publication without proving you have a minimum score in that game, then there is no 'gatekeeping'.
Would Pathfinder be a better game if no one was allowed to know more about Golarian than their GM? Or more lore than anyone else at their table? Do you think GMs are going to recruit players based on a score in a trivia game about Golarian?
Or are you just afraid that some people will brag about their scores in public instead of keeping quiet and pretending they don't really know that much.
I don't care if someone brags, I don't care what their score is, I just want to make sure every table is as welcoming and inviting as it can be for everyone, and being told "no you can't make x character" or "no you can't worship that god" because you know more about the lore than them sucks. If it's your gm making a table wide decision, that's one thing, but I've seen my fair share of people being dicks in my time to know this will probably come up.
I should be clear, I don't mean people are gonna be excluded at the table, nor do I think Paizo would ever put any of their books behind a wall like that. I'm saying there are gonna be people who get shut down at the table, told their voice doesn't matter, and made to feel small because the person telling them that has a higher score than them. I'm not saying the app shouldn't exist, I'm not saying the scenario I listed is gonna be common, just that I wanted to make sure Paizo was considering the ramifications of their actions. I *want* to be wrong, but I felt like it was important to bring up.