
TheNoslen |
TheNoslen wrote:I've got a situation I'm not entirely sure how to play out, would be good to get some advice.
Essentially, just finished rescuing Marquel, ended the session before delivering him to the captain. [...]
Anyone have any tips on how to react to this? What would Cassius do?That part in bold could be what saves you. Like Shaun and Raynulf I too have played with this type before, and it can be tiresome. The only reasonable, adult thing to do is let the poor sap go through with their ill conceived plan against the NPC with several levels over him, and then get rightfully smacked upside their thin-skinned head. Actions should have consequences. However, I'm going to advice against this. The adult reaction is not appropriate here as the problem never would have arisen if the player could behave like an adult. The player will just get increasingly prissy when his frustrations find not an outlet, but yet another imagined insult when the Captain successfully defends himself. A moody player at the table will just ruin the session for everyone.
Instead, consider playing up the reunion between Marquel and the Captain the next time your play. Emphasize the Captain's worry about his lover and that he might have been in an agitated state when he tossed this mission on the PCs' shoulders. Try to elicit sympathy and maybe this player will find it in his sensitive little heart to forgive him. As GM the best thing you can do in this situation is to try and defuse the situation, not to meet force with force.
Turns out after a week between sessions and a bit of wandering through town, the PC calmed down a little. I had Nones try and march the group to the captain (one PC resisted but having Marquel leave the party to go to the Captain convinced them all to follow), and after the reunion, the Captain did give a brief apology as to his secretive nature, explaining that he was sincerely worried about his lover. This kept the PC happy and so no retaliation was forthcoming!