One more thing - As someone who likes to follow the rules - I can see the problem.
But from a game perspective for people who have never played this type of card game... as was the case last night - It makes no sense.
To the Dr. I was playing with, a lab researcher, and resident nurse, if you are forced to discard - why would you have to time it correctly?
I mean you are discarding in either case. One discard happens before the other. In one case you get the bonus, in the other you do not. There is not a clear measurable transition point built into the game... since it is so gray, might as well just combine them and get the bonus.
Just our thoughts. Mind you we were playing the second scenario after Brigandoom.