
Stephen Drane |

By your command, Kyle!
I had a five-player table with an APL of 2, so we were at Tier 1-2 without adjustment.
There was a brand-new sorceress, a bard, a fighter, a fighter/wizard on the path to becoming an eldritch knight and a summoner (and, of course, his eidolon).
The straight fighter was the one who dished out 13 damage only to see none go through , although he did perk up when he rolled a crit next round. The sorceress only had magic missile (but did knock down a damaged dog with 2 force damage). The star performer damage-wise was the eidolon, with S/B claws bypassing the DR.
The combat (and stony defense in particular) certainly made them think. "Hmm, so it hasn't moved since its skin went stony... maybe it's immobile?"
"So it went normal, attacked, then stoned up again... maybe it can't attack in that form..."
There were some experienced people at the table who almost know the Bestiaries backwards, so good job keeping them guessing!
The dogs didn't do well on initiative, so one was almost down before he had a chance to stone up (eidolon claw, with the magic missile finishing the job), and then the other was surrounded by party members who were hacking away. The aforementioned crit softened him up, and he went down promptly when he ran out of stony defense. So in the end, the combat still only took 2 or 3 rounds.
That's probably far more detail than necessary.
In closing, thank you for writing this scenario. The Disappeared was one of my favourites, and Library of the Lion is right there along with it!